Poll: Strawberry Shortcake Or Cream Cheese Pound Cake With Strawberry Coulis?

Option 1: Strawberry Shortcake- an all-American classic, I like to make the shortcake with Bisquick, just very slightly sweetened. Real homemade whipped cream. Mmmm, one of the true simple pleasures in life.
Option 2: Cream cheese pound cake with strawberry coulis- I have never made this before, but I have all the ingredients and it looks and sounds delicious. I bet I could eat that strawberry sauce just all by itself.
I can’t decide what to make tomorrow (Sunday). Please vote now!

ETA: I messed up the poll thing- can you just tell me which you prefer?

Gimme some of Option 1!

I’d go for the classic strawberry shortcake.

Why not cream cheese shortcake with strawberry mouse?

I’m thinking this is a win-win. But if I have to pick one I’d vote shortcake.

I guess I’ll be the first to decent. Pound cakes are better than shortcakes, just in general.

I’ll be the 2nd - cream cheese poundcake??!! Oh yeah!!

Both look good, but I’m giving a slight edge to the shortcake in option 1. It looks lighter, and I like lighter things with strawberries which has a delicate flavor to me.

Pound cake with coulis.
It’s easier, and will last longer too.

Oh damn. That pound cake looks amazing.

Definitely that one.

they both sound great, so I flipped a coin and strawberry shortcake was the result.

Though I admit I am thinking of making the pound cake, I have some currants in the freezer that need eating instead of strawberry coulis :stuck_out_tongue:

You should definitely make that poundcake sometime. I made that recipe last Christmas and it was a huge hit, although I made it with blueberry coulis instead of strawberry. I will definitely be making that pound cake again - the cream cheese just gives it a tang that is really great.

I was going to just say Option 1 and then I had to go look at Option 2. God!

May I please have a slice of both?

So when do we get to enjoy the fruits of the very arduous labor that is having to decide between them?

I didn’t make either today- I had to clean almost my whole house and that’s some labor, right there.

So, I have decided to make the cream cheese pound cake, tomorrow. I just had shortcake not too long ago so I don’t have that craving for it, but I am getting pretty excited about the pound cake. Mmmm. You can have a bite, Bees.

Make sure for the poundcake you leave a lot of time to bake it.

The recipe says 1 1/4 hours, and I don’t know if maybe my oven temperature is off or something, but I had to leave it in for about 20 or 30 minutes extra (can’t remember exactly). I just kept checking every once in a while until a skewer inserted into the cake came out clean.

Pound cake, please.

You’re late, we ate it all. Sorry.

Strawberry shortcake isn’t bad, per se, but the dessert itself isn’t all that great. What’s important is the ambiance associated with the dessert: You need a bunch of kids and a grandmother, and you make a day of going to pick the strawberries, and then all the kids help Gramma whip up some cream, and then you eat it on the front porch in June as the Sun’s going down with your feet dangling off the porch swing. That’s what’s great about strawberry shortcake. If we’re just talking about the dessert itself, by all means go with that poundcake instead.

Well, I don’t want to say that your grandmother was a bad cook, but I have to disagree. I’m not counting that pseudoshortcake with storebought little sponge cakes- that’s just nasty. But homemade strawberry shortcake… mmm mmm good. See now you make me want that instead.