Is anyone else even willing to weigh in on the possible implications of Zeriel in my summaries of Drain and Mahaloth? Ed is the only one I recall taking a stab the Zeriel was scum.
I just realized that Red already just previously posted a similar theory about a scummy Drain and Tom wrt Tom’s flameout. Guilty of skimming a paragraph as Town :eek: and we’re both in agreement that it is pretty far flung speculation.
I’m going to leave my vote on Mahaloth at this point and call it a night. Drain and Ed would be on on my short list for trying to make heads or tails with Tomorrow, if the Town has one. 4 unconfirmed on 1, plus a swath of pre-sub pages, plus Zeriel and Mhaye unflipped is just a bit too much to ask of me and my usual approach to come up with a zinger. So let’s just get this over with already.
Actually…fuck it. We really did arrive at the same woowoo idea independently, and you know I have no reason to lie about that part. As far fetched as it might be, I’m crazy enough to run with it. Hopefully not off a cliff.
Unvote Mahaloth
Vote Drain
Jesus Christ. Game over.
Also, is LyLo really the time for far-fetched and crazy? And if my goal was to bus Tom for cred, why did I unvote him when he started melting down? I wouldn’t get cred if I unvoted him.
My suspicion on Zeriel was based primarily on the voting record. Coupling that with what appears to be a missing Scum (2 known dead and 2 supposed alive)
Oy!
[Vinnie Barbarino] I’m so confused [/Vinnie Babarino]
I’ll check back, getting ready for work
I think you’re right that zeriel was Scum–the stuff you pointed out seems legit, the math adds up, and just from a metagamey fairness standpoint I think one of the two were Scum.
There is a decent chance I’m going to be stuck in a meeting at 2pm, so just as a reminder:
If I’m not around at 2, I hope to be able to have the result up by 2:30.
Okay, so by my count, Red and Cookies are voting for me, while ed and I are voting for Mahaloth. Mahaloth is voting for ed, and our tie rules say that the person who received the latest vote will be safe, if I’m reading that correctly. That’s me. So right now, our only confirmed Town has set up a scenario in which the person she was voting for as Scum before me gets to be the one who breaks the tie that is currently not in his favor.
W. T. F.
And on that note, I can do nothing else but point at the facts already placed in front of us and let Cookies decide if she’s willing to take the risk at LyLo that Mahaloth is Town. Because by putting this in his hands, that’s essentially what she’s doing.
Sorry…that last post wasn’t very clear. What I’m saying is that the ONLY way we get ahead in this scenario is if Mahaloth is Town and I am Scum. If you’re willing to determine that both of those are true, we live to see another Day. If you think we’re both Scum, that’s great, because it would have been Mahaloth anyway. But if I’m telling the truth, you’ve just handed the win to Scum. On a “woowoo” idea that is “far fetched” and “crazy” and COULD HAVE ALSO BEEN SUGGESTED BY SCUM (although I think Red is probably our other Town).
One last thing. If I’m doing my math right, and we’re right in assuming there’s two Scum out of five players, and you get one toDay, that takes us down to four players. Three in the morning. We’re STILL at LyLo tomorrow. So Scum wouldn’t have nearly as much to fight about as I do right now–they can still win this thing. If I go down toDay, we’re fucked.
Please, Cookies, don’t go with “woowoo” and “crazy” on Day Six! There’s so much more evidence out there. If you’re going to make an actual case, make a fucking case, and respond to my points against what you said. But if this is the way this game ends, I am going to be pissed.
It’s not in his hands. Because he’s not going to vote for himself. His only choice is to lynch himself or lynch you.
I have to assume he’ll vote for you.
It’s really in my hands. I can follow Cookies and vote for you and that seals it, or I can hope Mahaloth doesn’t show up and lynch him.
This assumes 2 Scum.
If you are the last Scum, you would fight this hard.
If there are 2 Scum and Mahaloth is Town, you’d also fight this hard to try to get the win now.
This Scum wouldn’t do that argument isn’t making sense.
unvote Mahaloth
vote Drain
I hope your gut is right, Cookies. At one point you voted for each of us toDay…hehe
I was still hoping that looking at who suspected whom might help.
Drain had Ed as the top suspect but Mahaloth second.
Red had Drain first and Mahaloth 2nd.
Ed had Mahaloth first and Red second.
Mahaloth had Drain first and a wishy washy second.
I’ve also wavered on the Red/Drain issues. Red left a lot less to analyze.
But, anyway, looking at the list and calculating the 3 handed game if we get it right toDay:
Lynch Drain. 3 handed results in Ed and Red lynching Mahaloth. This means Ed and Red must be Town.
Lynch Ed. 3 handed results in Red and Mahaloth lynching Drain. This means Red and Mahaloth must be Town.
Lynch Red. 3 handed results in Ed and Drain lynching Mahaloth. This means Ed and Drain must be Town.
Lynch Mahaloth. 3 handed results in Red voting for Drain, Ed voting for Red, and Drain voting for Ed. Someone willhave to convince someone of something…
We’re done. Game over. Sorry, guys.
Short of both Red and Cookies unvoting me, this game ends now unless there’s only one Scum. If one of you comes into this thread and says you’re not unvoting me, can we end this game before 2:00 so I can go bitch in the Forbidden thread?
Also, this is bullshit that Cookies isn’t coming back here to at least read my defense against her vote, which nobody is bothering to comment on.
I was sleeping, but I am here now.