Sad Dog Story

I’m surprised that I haven’t told this story but I did a search and couldn’t find anything. I also tried to find an article to link to, but can’t find one. You’ll just have to take my word that this is a true story. It’s also very sad; if you’re already blue, you might wanna skip this.

My dog Crease is clicker trained; I use a clicker (or clicking sound with my mouth) to positively reinforce my dog’s behavior. She’s better behaved and knows a bunch of tricks, all thanks to this method, a woman named Beth and a black Lab named Gwennie.

When Crease was tiny I took her to a puppy socialization class led by Beth. From there we progressed to Beginner Clicker Training and Intermediate Clicker Training. Those two classes were taught by Beth and Gwennie. Gwennie was amazing. She loved to “work” and did trick after trick after trick, acting as an example for the dogs in the class to follow. One of her best tricks was called “Bang!” Beth would point her finger like a gun at Gwennie and say, “Bang!” Gwennie would immediately lie on her side, perfectly still but for her tail. Such a sweet, happy dog; she couldn’t help wagging.

Crease learned to heel, to lie down, sit, stay, “Sit Pretty,” and roll over from Gwennie’s examples. She had a really tough time with “Bang!” but finally did get it, months after the intermediate class was over.

One day in the summer of 2001, I was driving around town doing errands and listening to the news station when I heard the terrible news. The night before, Gwennie had been shot and killed by St. Paul marshals. I had to stop the car to sob.

Later that week, I heard the whole story from another clicker training student, a friend of mine but closer friend of Beth’s.

Beth, her husband and their three kids live in a part of St. Paul that is known for drug dealing and prostitution. Beth was out of town. Her husband Tom and their kids were on their way to run some errands and take Gwennie to the vet for a checkup. Everyone was in the backyard when Tom heard Gwennie barking furiously around the side of the house. As he rushed around the corner to see what was happening, he saw a marshal shoot Gwennie. She collapsed. Tom called her name. She got up slowly and stumbled to Tom, dying at his feet.

It seems the marshals had the wrong address.

So does this qualify as irony? Or merely a sad coincidence that her best trick was “Bang!” and she was shot to death…

Bah. I’ve got the cold weather blues; telling this story didn’t help my mood.

That Crease is a cutie! I have a crazy dog who is half Chihuahua and half Corgi.

Very sad story GfH. Wonder why you thought of it today?

I can’t imagine my grief and rage if that happened to my dog. My dog is very protective of her family, and if the cops ever burst in, I might as well be prepared for her death. She wouldn’t understand the significance of the uniform, and would attack the invaders of her home. They would shoot her, without a doubt.

I only hope to God that they take the time to make sure they have the right address.

I don’t know why I thought of this story today, Ninety.

Yep, Lissa, I worry about what you’re saying too… The only thing my smallie has on her side is her smallness.

I think it’s just so crazy that Gwennie, a virtual paragon of the canine world, was killed in this manner.

I remember when this happened. There was a huge outpouring from the St. Paul dog community. There were public meetings wiith the police and at least one lawsuit filed. As I recall, the marshalls were looking for someone who had lived at that address several years earlier, and if they had followed their own procedures (checking property tax records, for example) they would have known better.
My dogs are clicker trained, too. It’s the only way to train Dachshunds. It lets them believe that they are training you, and appeals to the strong-willed control-freak in each of them.

What a sad story. :frowning:

Did the owners ever launch a lawsuit or anything? Did the marshals ever appologize for shooting their dog?

Gazelle,

That is so sad and tragic. I don['t know what I’d do if that was my dog. :frowning:

It just sucks. I hope the family can find love from another doggie someday.

Punky! You have low riders too! I definitely have to hug you at PorkDope now. Get ready! Clicker training rocks. About the only thing for which it hasn’t worked is barking. It’s gotten better… but she’s a herding dog, y’know?

Stephi, they did launch a suit. I don’t know the outcome.

Siemsi, they got another doggie. A sweet golden retriever who I hear is dumb as a post.