First, full disclosure lest we speak past each other without knowing it: I’m not a believer. Not just in the Christian religion, but in the existence of an Omni-Whatever God. I’m (mostly) not anti-religion; I can see the benefits that many religions have had on socialization, enforcement of moral codes and even sometimes on science. I just don’t happen to believe that any of them worship something that actually exists.
Also, I won’t be around this forum much tomorrow because of board business. I’ll be around this weekend, though.
I went out a couple of weeks ago and bought a bible. Haven’t read the whole thing yet, of course, but I got through most of the OT (except for the “begats” and some of the “rules” chapters), and I read the Gospels. I’m just starting on the post-Gospel books now.
OK. To my questions. From the Gospels alone, it doesn’t seem like Jesus is the kind of person I would worship even if I did believe in His divinity. I’ll leave aside “He killed the pigs” and all that stuff. My questions are more basic. Sure, He had some good ideas about moral behavior. Most of His Sermon on the Mount was a doozy. I’m confident that Ghandi and Dr. King said similar things. BUT:
Jesus kept telling people to forsake everything except devotion to Him. I’ll give cites this weekend if you need them, but they tended to be “Don’t work for bread of this earth but rather for Heaven, and my Father will give you all the bread you need (knead?)” kind of stuff. Am I to understand all of this to be allegorical, or did He really expect living, breathing people with children to drop everything and follow Him? If the second, isn’t that asking a lot of the needy creatures He created?
His own disciples didn’t buy it. They were constantly asking for proof. IIRC, at one point they even got Him so exasperated that He looked up and said something to the effect of “How much longer do I have to put up with this?” If He was aware that His closest followers had problems believing even with miracles occurring right before their eyes, by what token does He expect someone 2000 or so years removed from the events to believe?
Why, precisely, does belief/worship equal salvation? Well, OK, because He said so. But more generally, why would he say such a thing? I’ll accept for purposes of this thread that true belief automatically leads one to live a life that God would want one to, but why would He set it up such that that is the only way to lead such a life? Does He have so little faith in humans that He has determined that the only way to lead a proper life pleasing to Him is to believe? Or are we back to the Jealous God of the OT? Or am I missing something here?
I guess that’s it for now. I’m sure I’ve missed capitalizing some He’s and Him’s, and I was a little fast and loose with my pronouns generally because I don’t fully understand how the Trinity is supposed to work for believers. I apologize in advance for both those oversights.