Scum mafia: On Cecil pond [Game Over]

I feel I would be remiss if I don’t ask here.

Can I help you on anything Digger?

Two hours to go. Are we really going to lynch DiggitCamara?

I’m not loving this. I realize the case against Rysto is kind of on the weak side too, but are we really at a state where we are sure we don’t believe DiggitCamara’s claim?

To me, the most troubling parts of his claim are:

  • His game play seems more like someone trying to avoid getting killed than someone trying to get killed.
  • He hasn’t said what would happen if storyteller tried to eat him.

The most troubling parts about killing Diggit are:

  • We have a dearth of town power roles.
  • His claim pretty much hangs a ‘lynch me’ sign on himself. Something I don’t think scum would really want to do.

I’m of the opinion that Diggit is more likely telling the truth.

I don’t believe Diggit. The only power role from the town that we’ve seen is storyteller’s handicapped vig role. And the masons who are also handicapped to some degree by not being able to communicate. It just seems that this very strong role without any handicap is out of place in this game.

Too much wine in the “lynch me” sign for me to get a read on. I wouldn’t put it past scum, but that does seem to be the weak link.

My vote is going to stay on Diggit – I really have too many problems with the claim.

His role PM seems to imply he would just be eaten - I don’t think a role just immune to one of two (known) kills that likely. On the other hand it might be to prevent to them from proving there powers (until one was confirmed at least otherwise just there words).

But this is thing I would expect a town DiggitCamara to have mentioned (‘I didn’t claim to let Storyteller test me, since I wouldn’t survive that’).

On Rysto’s point of lynch or lose at Summer Four with six scum: yes that seems not that likely - five scum with Red Skeezix as optional six could work though (since he could win with them).

Dude: you keep asking “D’oh” questions like this one .

For instance, you asked

Well… I did try to keep my power hidden (thus useful) to the last minute. If I had kept it hidden it would have gotten me lynched and not useful at all. D’oh!

You yourself say

I, like everyone else, have no other source of information than my PM. Thus, I thought that everyone who read my PM would assume the same thing I did. D’oh!

Well, basically I disagree with how far you have gone against Sach. I don’t think that Sach’s play has been nearly as blatantly scummy toDay as you’ve claimed and so I dislike voting with you. So no there is nothing you can do I still think Sach’s case is the strongest it just isn’t as strong as I initially thought.

But when storyteller claimed, wouldn’t you wonder? Wouldn’t you ask Chronos?

I’m also baffled by why DiggitCamara hasn’t moved a vote onto Rysto.

Of course not. It’s completely straightforward: I can’t be outcompeted by scum.

And I’m not changing my vote because, right now, you and **Rysto ** are tied. Both of you are 2 votes away from me, so changing my vote wouldn’t even tie Rysto with me. And, like I said, between you and him I find you to be far scummier.

Ugh. I’m trying to F’in help you.
(1) Rysto is 2 votes from you, I’m three.
(2) You don’t have to unvote me to vote for Rysto.
Sheesh.

Fine. Die. I don’t care.

Oredigger voted you sach - it’s 5-3-3 by my count. Why should a town dual vote in defense (and is the side effect of it putting Rysto ahead of you important)?

No, I meant have kept it hidden until the actual last minute and trying to convince us of someone better to lynch so that a) you as supposed town would survive and could use you power and b) perhaps an scum would be lynched instead.

You had the whole game to think about it and when you claimed could have tried to show you did. What was your game plan? Did you try to get targeted by scum? Didn’t you consider under what conditions claiming would be worth it (instead of ‘here is a redacted claim. Let’s discuss if it’s useful’).

Because on the slight chance that Spawn votes for Rysto, DiggitCamara would at least get a shot at living.

With the implication that a scum Diggit would have done that by now as he would have nothing to lose. Classic wine - it does make me want to unvote and vote Rysto and you and let the spawn /dice decide :rolleyes:.

The Spawn votes for Meeko and Oredigger

Final vote count:
Spawn 9
DiggitCamara 5
Rysto 3
sachertorte 3
Meeko 1
Oredigger 1

[del]1: special_ed[/del]
[del]2: ComeToTheDarkSideWeHaveCookies[/del]
3: Drain Bead – Spawn (1740), Rysto (1740)
4: Oredigger77 – sachertorte (1858), Spawn (1858)
[del]5: storyteller0910 [/del]
6: Meeko – sachertorte (1752), [del]Diggit[/del] (1752-1797), Spawn (1797)
[del]7: Mahaloth [/del]
[del]8: Freudian Slit[/del]
9: USCDiver – [del]Spawn[/del] (1753-1822), Rysto (1756), DiggitCamara (1822)
[del]10: Alka Seltzer[/del]
[del]11: peekercpa[/del]
12: Natlaw – Spawn (1782), DiggitCamara (1812)
[del]13: Zeriel[/del]
14: DiggitCamara – [del]Rysto[/del] (1761-1794), Spawn (1761), sachertorte (1794)
15: amrussell – Diggit (1788), Spawn (1850)
[del]16: KellyCriterion[/del]
[del]17: Red Skeezix[/del]
18: sachertorte – Rysto (1814), Spawn (1814)
[del]19: fluiddruid[/del]
20: TexCat – Spawn (1760), [del]Natlaw[/del] (1783-1824), DiggitCamara (1824)
21: Rysto – Diggit (1781), Spawn (1781)

The Pondies killed the Spawn again, and nobody was surprised.

A Spawn is dead

DiggitCamara tried to claim to be a special species, but most of the Pond thought his claim smelled like rotten eggs. “That’s just what Kelly tried to pull”, they said. So they tore his cell membrane apart, and, wait, what’s that stench? Apparently that rotten egg smell wasn’t from the claim.

DiggitCamara, a Chemosynthete, is dead

It is now Winter 6. Strategy discussion should be put on hold. Summer will come this Saturday, on schedule. There are currently no Spawn in the pond.

What’s the vote count at this point?

Effing simulpost. Not that it mattered–I wasn’t planning on unvoting Rysto. Ugh.

Damn.

Well, at least we have a good place to look for scum toMorrow.

I’ll take a used alcohol swab in a dirty glass.

Well, the Pond decided. I’m not worthy.

Go Pond!

I’d like to be spoilerized, Chronos

Oh, balls. Sorry Diggit.

**I have no fucking comment at this point. **