SDMB Fantasy Football DYNASTY League: Year 18

“Everything really wrapped up nicely. Hmm. Much quicker than usual.”

Yeah season ending surgery appears to have been confirmed 3 hours ago.

Well I was pretty happy with my quarterback situation entering the season. If Dart is healthy, he seems like a legitimate top 12 fantasy quarterback.

The problem is that “if.” Now I’ve got Jordan Love as my starter with Baker Mayfield as backup. I had Daniel Jones but released him in the offseason because four quarterbacks is simply too many.

No regrets. I kind of like Love, although he struggled last week against the Jets and has a short week tonight. Plus multiple OL starters injured. But going forward I mean, I feel good about Love as my starter and don’t feel a need to look for trades. (Unlike the real life Giants, who better be looking for a trade!) A little shakier on Mayfield as my backup; hopefully he can pull it together.

In other injury news, my top four receivers are all listed as questionable, not out, for week three, so fingers crossed. I entered the draft with only five wide receivers on my roster, so I spent all three draft picks to bring that total to eight. My top pick, Stribling, is out on IR for surgery, expected to miss 10 weeks.

EDIT: Saquon is also questionable. My team is a mash unit walking into week 3.

Things are getting a bit out of hand.

Players on IR (7):
RB Jadarian Price
RB Travis Etienne Jr
WR Alec Pierce
WR Omar Cooper Jr.
RB Trevor Ettenne
WR Ricky Pearsall
WR Chris Brazzell II

Players Out (5):
QB Caleb Williams (indefinite)
QB Jayden Daniels (indefinite)
WR Jalen Coker
WR Caleb Douglas
WR Pat Bryant (indefinite, likely to IR)

Just delightful.

Garbage-time Saints TD puts me over the top. Nice to wake up to a win when I thought I lost.

It’s just the fantasy gods restoring balance. I had a very similar situation last week where I just barely stole the win on Monday night, so it seems only right that I’m on the other side this week.

Congrats on being 4-0! EDIT: The only undefeated team remaining!

Championship rematch this week between Hamlet and I sitting at 50/50 currently. I’m not going to repeat my “every 5 years” championship pattern this year. Once Achane went down I can’t even really field a complete team, 6 guys on IR and most of the rest of them not very good. At least Denzel Boston was a good pick.

Brian Thomas Jr is pretty much officially a bust but I was lucky enough to snag Parker Washington off the waiver wire to basically replace him 1:1. Huge game for him today.

Officially saved my season with a 0.3 point win, although our entire division is now 2-3. It’s hard to believe I’m tied for first after starting the season with my worst 3-week stretch ever.

Just proves that old adage once again… “never trust a fat west coast kicker on a Monday night when fantasy redemption is on the line”

Everyone knows the week 5 rematch after a championship game is the real championship and I have prevailed.

Sunbelt usually has at least two contender and often sends the wildcard but this year is a down year for everyone. Four way tie at 2-3 and our highest score is lower than everyone’s score in the northeast division. My only realistic shot at the playoffs this year is being in a weak division that someone has to win

Oof, looks like I took two zeros last week. Leaving points on the table like that won’t do me any favors in the division. I’m already almost 100 points behind Jules, and he’s not even leading our division.

There’s only one wildcard team, so there’s no way that Mundi, Jules and I can all make the playoffs at the same time. I have to pull ahead of at least one of you.

The problem is you guys are scoring too many points. Even with my two zeros I scored a respectable 136, but would have been a nice 156 if I had made the logical substitutions before kickoff. And that would have still lost to both of you, with Jules scoring 163 and Mundi 176. Like, WTF?! lol.

I have DJ Moore starting at W/T, who appears to be a game time decision at 4:25 ET. If he doesn’t start I intend to replace him with Quentin Johnston (ugh), who also starts at 4:25 ET. Probably be asleep at the time so I needed to declare here. (DJ was one of my zeros last week.)

The timing is interesting. I also have Malachi Fields on my bench, but the Giants play at 1:00pm. I do not want to start Fields; Johnston is my first choice. But hypothetically…

Fields wouldn’t be a valid conditional sub, right? Because yahoo would lock me out of starting Fields at his kickoff, and I’m expecting DJ to be ruled out two hours later. I’m pretty sure I remember this right that we only allow conditional subs that would be possible in real time.

Does anyone think we should allow time traveling conditional starts, as long as we declare in the thread before any relevant kickoff? On a scale of 1 to 100, I think I’m at like a 51 for / 49 against. Anyone have a stronger feeling either way?

The value I could see is if one of your top guys is a game time decision but plays on Monday night. It might be nice to be able to declare a 1:00 Sunday player as their conditional replacement, as long as you posted in the thread before the Sunday 1:00 kickoff.

I’m more or less in the same situation.

Mike Evans is a game time decision in the Monday night game, so I’d like Brandin Cooks subbed in if he’s scratched.

But I don’t have anyone else on my bench I’d be interested in starting in his place, so I’m not sure how I feel about the time traveling sub. Like you, I’m pretty close to 50/50 but leaning no.

I’m very curious to see where all the Northeast teams land in total points at the end of the season. There’s a real chance all four of us end up in the top five.

You’re correct that conditional starts are only for roster changes you could make yourself if you were here. So the Moore / Johnston conditional is valid but you can’t sub in someone with an earlier start time.

I don’t know what happened, but this morning at 11:03 am (after learning Tyler Warren was out), I dropped Mike Gesicki, picked up Tyler Higbee, and put him in as my starting TE. I just checked, and somehow Warren is listed as my starter rather than Higbee. If possible, please swap out Higbee for Warren.

I always like to help in situations like this, and from your actions (picking up higbee at 12:03) it’s obvious that you intended to do what you say, but we had a discussion last year with several people objecting that whenever I do an ad-hoc move not specified in the rules (like the conditional player swap declared ahead of time) that it’s unfair because previous owners in a similar situation may not have asked because they didn’t know such help might be available. So I agreed / resolved to not to provide that sort of help as commissioner except as we’ve defined as a rule (like Ellis’ request today).

Speaking of which, since Moore is out, I’ll swap in Johnston.

Omni didn’t even bother to set a full starting lineup, and he might win if he had just started the obvious, highest-projected players. What’s the penalty for openly tanking? If an owner never showed up, we would at least ensure they had a full lineup, right?

Fortunately, we haven’t had to determine a punishment yet because people have generally followed the requirement that you have to try to win every game. It is indeed a problem that @Omniscient left three starting spots with out or bye players. Can Omni promise reassure us that he’ll manage his team every week going forward?

As far as an anti-tanking punishment goes, I think the most logical punishment would be a loss in draft position (going further down in the order) or loss of picks - but if we reach a point where the owner is that inattentive or potentially deliberately tanking, replacement would be an option too.

Obviously I hope it doesn’t come to that, and it hasn’t yet come to that in our league history, but I will remind everyone that you’re required to make a good faith effort to field your best roster every week. Even if the season is hopeless for you, it’s a competitive factor - if you’re giving some teams a free win, that destabilizes the competitiveness of the league.

And to answer your other question - if there were an extended unexplained absence, we could at least start the best projected team for a player until they get back or get replaced.

Let’s slow down a bit on the tanking accusations. I’m 2-3 and my entire fucking team is on IR.

Judkins was a game time decision. I wasn’t really monitoring his status because my other healthy option at RB was Brashard Smith who doesn’t get any snaps and a Trevor Ettienne who just came off IR and was a third stringer and wasn’t projected to get any snaps. I suppose the optics would be better with an active player in the lineup but literally it made no difference and to activate Etienne would have required me to drop a player.

Bateman started today but was ruled out early aggravating his injury.

Not starting Cooper over Harris is a big miss but it wouldn’t have made a lick of difference this week and it’s Coopers first game back from the IR so it was by no means a certainly that he’d do anything. I wasn’t going to drop a player to pick up a kicker in a week where I had practically no chance to field a full line up of starters.

If I painted a target on my back because of the draft fiasco, so be it. Do what you have to do.