By the way, for those reading along who don’t want to check out the other thread, Stone (and, it seems, Dog’s) Chain O’ Stupid goes something like this:
-Several years ago, I got into an argument with Scylla where I pointed out, with copious cites, that America had tortured/“abused”/“extraordinarily rendered” dozens of people to death. For my trouble, I was called a traitor. I objected to this.
-Later, I would point out (numerous times) that the fallacies of composition and division are often used by bigots/racists to both construct and justify their irrational worldviews.
-Then, there was a thread in GD which talked about an American Jew who set out to make a thoroughly dishonest ‘documentary’, cherrypicking drunken Americans in Jerusalem in an attempt (in the words of his compatriot) to draw conclusions about “the American Jewish community”. That, while trying to conflate American Jews with Israelis and Israeli policy and politics. For obvious reasons, people objected and Elv1s, in one of his rare moments of lucidity, pointed out that the American Jew who set out to ‘show’ what badguys American Jews are is a self-hating Jew.
Stone, then, apparently having stayed in a Holiday Inn recently, thought he could open his yap without sounding like a fool.
First he alleged absurd shit like calling someone a self-hating Jew was anti-Semitic (!!!) because it meant that you were saying Jews have to be hating someone, anybody, at all times. And that you were somehow slandering all Jews, or something.
He’s now gone on to babbling about how identifying self-hating Jews is “denigrating someone’s ethnicity for having a dissenting opinion”. Of course, he refused to look at whether or not the label is ever accurate and a vile fuck like Bobby Fischer would qualify, being someone who is Jewish and hates Jews/Judaism/Jewishness.
Of course, after his flood of pure liquid stupid, he refused to actually create a cogent argument, merely stating that i was calling people “traitors to Judaism” and that “It would take a exceptional aptitude for obtuseness to misunderstand the link.”
Somewhere around there that slug of a thinker decided that I’d somehow evinced hypocrisy (since, obviously, someone who tells the truth supported by dozens of cites about American torture and objects to being called a traitor is exactly the same as an American Jew who sets out to create a bit of deceptive propaganda in order to show how bad American Jews are)… and, naturally, that such hypocrisy was used so that I could engage in “discrediting those who want Israel to follow the principles of law and equality.”
At which point Dog, the idiot, decided that by George, if he couldn’t argue his own way out of a paper bag in order to justify his shit-stupid OP, then maybe someone else could! Of course, along the way Dog also evinced the reading skills of a (slow) fifth grader and alleged that my posting was somehow incomprehensible. His inability to understand simple English means either that I suck at conveying my ideas… or that he’s a hair’s breadth away from being functionally illiterate. Something tells me I’m not all that horrible at slinging the lingo.
Or, as I was very tempted to say in GD “That post is a mirror. If a monkey looks in, no great philosopher looks back out.”
So, that pretty much brings us up to date. Stone is fucking stupid and has a bad habit of getting his dander up when his neurons start flickering madly; he doesn’t quite understand why he’s taken offense, merely that he should be as difficult as possible in prosecuting his grievances against the offender. Dog, of course, is just kinda quietly pathetic most of the time except when he emerges from his hole (with a ‘splorch!’ noise, I would wager) to gnaw on my ankles.
Such is life.