This comment had to make me contribute here…
I’d sort of get that when it was showing, well, maybe greatest scifi show, up to season 3. I was so excited to get to season 4, I think it was (perhaps it was end of season 2). Onto spoilers.
Oh they fucked it. They fucked it bad.
The huge interesting part was the seven set of cylons, and the mystery of the other set, the other fives, who we didn’t know. With the seven set, they’d die and rez on a rez ship, and there was tens to hundreds of each model.
So, assuming that also applied to the fives, when one dies, they would rez, and there would be more than one copy of each. So it would be hard to hide those inside the fleet.
But nope, they just ignored any of that crap, and not only did they make them unique, and also hid them on the ship in situations which really didn’t make a fucking bit of sense. Wouldn’t Adama notice his lifelong friend Saul Tigh hadn’t aged in the 50 odd years he knew him???
It was if they’d fired the original writers and got the rejects from Lost in, to change it into some sort of biblical story, with none of the mystery except some absolute nonsense about Starbuck which never got explained very well either (or the explanation was rot).
Yeah, so they’d get to earth and be us. Or something (I frankly can’t remember the ending, having long since hate watched it). It was same as Season 6 onwards of Game of thrones, increasingly ludicrous plotlines.
(I personally thought the story would have five group were in alternative ships also trailing the human fleet, but on the human side and helping them. Perhaps even dead seven group cylons out of range of rez ships might rez them in the five group ships, and perhaps join the fives as agents inside the sevens. It had so much potential for intrigue and suited the complex plotting up until then. But nope)
So I’d get what you were saying if we were hanging about in about 2006, waiting for the new season. But it took such a lad turn, I find it interesting that someone not only suffered the show going off a cliff, but still holds it in such high esteem.