Mahaloth 3 (glee 10, DemonTree 77, Dizzymrslizzy 78)
Dizzymrslizzy 1 (storyteller0910 34)
DemonTree 2 (storyteller0910 34, Prof.Pepperwinkle 49-64, Mahaloth 73)
glee 2 (Prof.Pepperwinkle 42-49, Mahaloth 73, DemonTree 77)
storyteller0910 2 (Prof.Pepperwinkle 68, SunUp 80)
Okay this is real WIFOM reasoning here…
Unvote Mahaloth
Because the two people Glee and Demon I trust the least are also on him. So by deductive reasoning Mahaloth is probably town.
Glee has the same situation…. Demon and Mahaloth on him Same situation. I don’t feel comfortable with either vote pattern.
So I’m going to go with my gut and of the three.
Vote Demontree
Oh dear. Our odds of winning just went down: I don’t know if Mahaloth is scum, but I know I’m not.
I’m trying to decide if your vote is suspicious or not. On the one hand, most likely there’s only one villain, so you’d have no direct reason to want to save Mahaloth. On the other, if he’s generally seen as more suspicious than me, it might be preferable to keep him around to deflect attention tomorrow. I think that’s enough to merit a vote.
Vote Dizzymrslizzy
If I do die next, I wish you all better luck in voting tomorrow. 
I’m sorry, it’s not personal, just logic right now.
I suspect the scum lies between the 3 of you.
I’m most suspicious of Mahaloth but I don’t like that his only other votes are the 2 other people I believe could be scum.
glee has the same situation.
I am Town, and the suspicion on me is telling at this point.
I’m suspicious because of the last minute switch from a more to a less suspicious person. But no one really has any idea - in a couple of hours you’ll all have to start deciding this all over again.
I looked at the votes again and didn’t see Mahaloth on you…. My logic thusly fails.
Unvote Demontree
Vote Mahaloth
But yeah I’m going to be stuck in the same place tomorrow if I’m wrong and it stinks.
vote glee
For minimal participation after being called out for it.
Wow, you guys sure like making the moderator re-write the end of Day reveal, don’t you?
Mahaloth 3 (glee 10, DemonTree 77, Dizzymrslizzy 78-82, 86)
Dizzymrslizzy 2 (storyteller0910 34, DemonTree 83)
DemonTree 2 (storyteller0910 34, Prof.Pepperwinkle 49-64, Mahaloth 73, Dizzymrslizzy 82-86)
glee 3 (Prof.Pepperwinkle 42-49,88 , Mahaloth 73, DemonTree 77)
storyteller0910 2 (Prof.Pepperwinkle 68, SunUp 80)
This is currently a tie between Mahaloth and glee.
Can someone please briefly summarize what they see as the case against Mahaloth? Because I really don’t see it and it feels incredibly scummy that this is happening right now.
For me it’s that both Pardel-Lux and AotN said they were suspicious of him, and we know they were town. Not particularly substantial, but nothing is. And he’s said he’s a minor character, so less of a loss if we’re wrong.
But the fact that Angel went to check him and it was redirected to a Villain shouts to me that he is probably Town.
“I thought I refuted the first accusation:
My posting record is:
Act I 19 posts (including one replying to 5 different posters)
Act II 15 posts (including one replying to 5 different posters)
Act III 4 posts (including this one)
Considering I’m a newbie and that there is obviously a group of players here who know each other well from many games of Mafia, I think I’m more than doing my bit.”
I voted for him because Angel investigated him.
But does a redirector usually know the target? Especially a town one?
If Pardel was a redirector, and wanted to redirect an action to Thing, then he wouldn’t have known the target was Mahaloth or what Mahaloths alignment was?
He wouldn’t have even known what action he was redirecting.
and Angel checking Mahaloth isn’t her being suspicious as much as clearing the air on someone we always have a bit of suspicion on plus he was a runner up vote day 1
For me, it was the vote on Prof day 1 for pushing another player to play.
I quoted the interaction above. Add to that the sudden run up on LH on day one. It could be town v town but it’s all I have right now
I don’t get how I’m scummy for what Angel did.
But only 7 posts today.
Has glee claimed a role yet?
He claimed to be Travers, a minor character, right at the start.
Yeah, me neither. Glee and DemonTree appear to be pushing the responsibility for their vote onto a dead Townie, which in most circumstances I’d find extremely suspicious. Here, the fact that both are in their first ever game mitigates it a bit, but the fact that Angel thought Mahaloth was suspicious is not really evidence against Mahaloth: she was trustworthy, not infalliable.
Of Mahaloth and glee, I think I’d rather see glee banished today.
vote glee