I will give ya’ll a hint since I will be away for a few days…I was lying in my PMs 
Oh you slippery fellow, you!
I already figured that out, ya bastard.
–FCOD
You know, it sure would be a shame, if some outsider was able to deduce the correct answer.
I would guess it was something like:
A 2 day late APRIL FOOLS!
You know. I think I’m enjoying this game more than the players. Is that possible?
Idle, Do you have any concerns over me posting (more) guesses?
-Meeko
The guy who broke Haggle, and is trying to break into a game he didn’t even sign up for.
No offense to you, but I’d be pretty upset if you post anything that affects the outcome of the game. I don’t mind if you post guesses for posterity, but Idle please don’t validate them.
Next time sign up! 
–FCOD
Flying: Frankly, I think If I were playing, I would have less fun with it.
Why else do you think I am asking, rather than going on ahead?
Not saying I will act on it, but you do have to admit, it would be an interesting outcome if an outsider could do it. Then again, what if I’m not an outsider?
There is breaking a game, and then there is BREAKING a game. I will only do so much for this game. You have seen nearly all of it.
I’m enjoying the game immensely. If only people would actually participate. Besides Paul, Naf and MtS, that is.
I think it would be interesting if an outsider guessed it first…as long as it wasn’t confirmed until after one of the actual players guesses it.
–FCOD
In the meantime:
Cookies
BillMC
NAF
pedescribe
Paul
Picker
sinjin
MadTheSwine
Archiveguy
FCoD
Cookies
BillMC
NAF
Archiveguy
Paul
Picker
sinjin
MadTheSwine
pedescribe
FCoD
Cookies
BillMC
NAF
Archiveguy
Paul
Picker
sinjin
pedescribe
MadTheSwine
FCoD
Cookies
BillMC
NAF
MadTheSwine
Paul
Picker
sinjin
pedescribe
Archiveguy
FCoD
Cookies
BillMC
NAF
MadTheSwine
Paul
Picker
sinjin
Archiveguy
pedescribe
FCoD
Any of those right?
BillMC
Cookies
NAF
Archiveguy
Paul
Picker
sinjin
MadTheSwine
pedescribe
FCoD
BillMc
Cookies
Picker
NAF
Pedescribe
ArchiveGuy
Paul
sinjin
MadTheSwine
FCOD
BillMc
Cookies
Picker
NAF
Pedescribe
MadTheSwine
Paul
sinjin
ArchiveGuy
FCOD
BillMc
ArchiveGuy
Picker
NAF
Pedescribe
Cookies
Paul
sinjin
MadTheSwine
FCOD
BillMc
ArchiveGuy
Picker
NAF
Pedescribe
MadTheSwine
Paul
sinjin
Cookies
FCOD
BillMc
MadTheSwine
Picker
NAF
Pedescribe
ArchiveGuy
Paul
sinjin
Cookies
FCOD
BillMc
MadTheSwine
Picker
NAF
Pedescribe
Cookies
Paul
sinjin
ArchiveGuy
FCOD
–FCOD
Picker, I think you are a dirty lying liar.
–FCOD
Does anyone’s story bit mention anything about a store?
–FCOD
Paul’s does.
Or, well, he says it does. He has lied once.
Yeahhh…he’s a liar.
He told me his was “He tried to light the torch but the matches were wet.”
–FCOD
He (Paul) told me:
“He decided to go to the store to pick up some batteries.”
That was after he said his was just “The End”.
I can say that I have not lied to anyone, except for purposefully keeping myself last on my first guess. So I’ll wager your last batch of guesses are all going to be wrong, FCOD.
I totally believe he is a liar in most cases. But I got picker and Pauls lines independantly, and I am fairly certain that they hadn’t gotten each others lines when I got each of theirs.
So maybe it’s a co-incidence that they both match up, but they do seem to match.
Nah, go for it.