That’s a good question. I’ll answer it.
Historically and realistically, no, they should not.
I’m one of the most entertaining posters in the pit. I’ve got verve, flair, and even some spunk, which I’ll be glad to spew all over your mom’s face if she’s lucky. Now, this of course rubs certain posters the wrong way. Mostly those posters are the ones who get mistaken for the coat rack at parties. Because they are boring automatons whose painful earnestness and conservative midwestern senior citizen social values bore the shit out of anyone who is relevant. Seriously, it’s like the annual post-Christmas dinner old people table, where everyone feels the need to discuss in detail the kids these days, that awful “rock” music, and the consistency of their bowel movements.
The whole reason this forum is here is so that people can call each other out, take off the gloves, and go to town without having to pay attention to the ol’ Marquis of Queensbury. Unless they want to call someone a cunt, but that’s another matter.
So when you want to get on and share the story about how your precious kitty Mr. Snugglekins went to the vet and a mean lady said he had poorly defined coloration, you have two choices. You can post it in MPSIMS and get sympathy from other desperate cat fanatics going “there, there” as you metaphorically cry on their shoulder via the wonders of modern telecommunications technology.
Your other choice is to post in the pit. A place where banning the word “cunt” is an outrage to many. A poster in ATMB got warned for “your mother wears combat boots”. That should display to even the most obtuse the difference in poster expectations between the various forums.
When you post your little rant in the pit, you’re taking a risk that people will think that your rant, and therefore you, are boring, stupid, and a host of other adjectives, none of which have positive connotations. If you have a rant about smokers or fatties or faggots or rednecks or hobbits or teabaggers or wine corks (wine corks, for the love of christ!) you can expect that some people are going to be annoyed or offended because you are being a racist, or a wuss, or a snob, or a philistine.
One way to defuse the reaction is to make it interesting and entertaining. That way, at least your meaningless gabber will have some beneficial impact on the world. Because, at the end of the day, let’s face it – no one on here is saying anything meaningful or novel, and if they think they are, then they need to join the National Brotherhood of Massive Hubris Union Local 419.
So, no. People cannot expect to get anything better than my posts. Because all the craft in the pit is being drowned by shit like the OP or crappy ‘rants’ that are composed of nothing but profanity. Talking about “meaningfully contributing” in the pit is pointless, because that isn’t the goal, nor is it required. The pit is for entertainment. GD is for debating. MPSIMS is for… I don’t know, I just imagine fat people with fibromyalgia talking about their cats and having snuggle parties. GQ is probably the only place where it’s not just a bunch of basement trolls yammering about their pet peeves.
So if you want “meaningful contribution”, post your pale imitation 95 theses on the church door, not next to the urinal in a bar in a shady part of town, or at least don’t be all surprised and upset when the dirty limericks people scrawl on your screed are obscured by stains from people pissing all over it.
ETA: Oh yes, and please feel free to link to other “meaningful contributions” in this thread. I mean, aside from the goat-fucker bit.