Song ID needed

I have this song I haven’t heard in at least 7-8 years stuck in my head. Its a rock-pop song, it was on the radio (I think, it could have been a tape) in the early nineties and/or late eighties. The only lyrics I can remember are the chorus: “Ain’t it a shame, it’s just the same, that song” (“that song” might be "that’s all or something in that vein.) and in part of the verse “I’m looking at you, you’re looking at me.” although maybe my memory has crossed two songs.

I’ve put all these lyrics in google in various permutations without finding the song I’m speaking of. I realize that this is very vauge, but any help is appreciated.

Just did a few googles…could you be thinking of “That’s All” by Genesis? (See here for lyrics.)