Straight Dope Nirvana: The Ultimate Ultimate

All right, let’s get down to brass tacks, no more f’n around:

  1. What is the greatest OP ever in the History of the SDMB?

  2. What is the greatest thread??

  3. Who is the most awesome-most poster ever???

Links to said threads would be appreciated!!!

Just to be fair, I’m taking myself out of the running for all three categories!!! :smiley:

Hmm, for the ultimate thread, I’d have to say it’s The Telemarketer Speaks. I Respond by Cervaise. Damned funny, that one. As for the others, I couldn’t hazard a guess.

I’ve enjoyed going back and reading Coldfire’s thread May 5, 1945 We Shall Remember/
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=23572

Aw, Vinnie, that’s too hard.
But for most improved poster, I’d have to say Ex Tank’s in the running.
From big mouth hardass to “mostly harmless” in pretty short order. :smiley:
Peace,
mangeorge

Thanks for the plug, Tuckerfan. However, even though I’ve grown to be rather proud of my rant, I’m not ashamed to admit it pales in comparison to two all-time classic threads: How to kill evil Nazi Groundhogs and Funny things said during love making/intimate moments.

As far as the greatest OP ever, I will forever and always have a soft spot for a monkey that I wish for. The first post is funny enough, but it’s the followup that makes it a classic.

Well, I’m a relative newbie here, but I have no doubt this is the most awesome-most poster ever.

Farrah? Yuck. :slight_smile:

I’d like to think I’m the ultimate poster, but I’m not.

<sigh> :rolleyes:

Sorry, bughunter. but I think we already had a poll for the cutest nickname. :wink:
Peace,
mangeorge

One of my all time favlorite threads, that I’ve sent to everybody I know (and received rave reviews in return) has been the Infamous Goat Cannon Thread, surely a classic in the field.

And, yes, Cervaise’s response to the telemarketer is another hoot of clinical dissection.

Generally consistent best poster? IMHO, that would be Fenris who shares a strong interest in science fiction, is very well read, has an intelligent point of view and rants exceedingly well when the situation calls for it. Enjoy his mastery in Iron Chef Part Quatro

Well, I don’t mean to point out the obvious, but, er, um, uh… I’m going to.

WallyM7 was probably the greatest poster. He was only hear for awhile, but he had an incredible post rate and those posts were high quality.

Far, far to many thread for me to pick a favorite.

well, I guess I’ll waffle a bit here – It needs to be broken down.

awesome-most, knows their shit and always adds something of value?
tomndebb.

awesome-most, most common sense, no BS?
tie between andros and jodi.

awesome-most, most repected?
Polycarp.

awesome-most, funniest?
Uke Ike.

awesome-most, don’t step on their toes or you’ll find yourself with a new asshole?
tie, neuro-trash grrrl and old style, more angry (he seems more calm as of late), pldennison. A nod to Mr Cynical (I still don’t like his new name.)

awesome most, “everyone gather 'rouund, he’s about to tell a story!”
Wally.

awesome-most, biggest fookin idiot?
fatherjohn, hands down.

awesome most, class clown type?
Whammo.

I could go on. But I won’t.

Bumpity-bump