Yes, Kirk would most often simply say “Warp factor five, Mr. Sulu” and Sulu would reply “Aye, warp factor five” and hit the buttons – or something resembling that. This was of course in keeping with established seamanship practice of repeat-checking the order, but not requiring a command of execution. Similarly happens in aviation, where you are given the clearance to take off and you confirm you have been cleared to take off, and then if everything looks to be in order and safe just take off.
Yeah, think the command ‘thing’ started with Picard and ‘engage’.
It was more prominent in Discovery, which this show spun off of. If it inherited from anything, it was that.
In Season 3, Episode 8, it’s actually a subplot rather than a throwaway line.
As for Saru? Tilly has been workshopping suggestions when this week’s episode opens, including “execute,” “hit it,” and “manifest.” Nobody, it turns out, likes “manifest,” and Saru aptly points out that Pike already used “hit it.” Instead, Saru ends up doing a little bit of focus-grouping on the bridge itself, first saying “carry on” and then trying out “execute.”
I’d say this was definitely a callback to this episode.
I didn’t remember that. Maybe I’m successfully blocking most of Discovery from my memory.
ROFL, it is definitely an acquired taste, and there are certain episodes that I’ve probably expunged as well.
I don’t think it’s a coincidence that some of my favorite episodes were the ones with Pike in them.
I’m tickled to see #1 is being prosecuted by Mrs. McMurray from Letterkenney.
And the last bit of the last ep of Picard.
The joke is way overdone by now but they’ve written themselves in to make the catch phrase a big thing. It will be hard to return to the Kirk no specific catch phrase norm but future catch phrases will suffer from excessive awareness.
It’s definitely a thing now.
I could totally see the explanation for Kirk being, he was too cool for a catch phrase. Which fits the character IMHO.
Are Lanthanites a new thing in Star Trek? At first I thought Carol Kane’s character might be the same species as Whoopi Goldberg’s, but apparently not.
She was an El-Aurian, that species has come up in a few storylines on different shows and was key to the Generations film.
I’m familiar with most of the major Trek species (I’m a nerd) but the Lanthanites are new to me. I did a quick search and apparently Carol Kane’s character was the first one on screen, and that species has never even been mentioned before. They apparently created it for that episode.
A little late to the party. I thought the premier was fine. The fighting against the Klingons was way way too long. The ship combat is too Star Wars IMO. All this you need a catchphrase talk was stupid. Once again the internet turned a cute joke into something tedious. Beyond that I enjoyed it.
I thought Kirk’s was, “Second star to the right and straight on till morning”.
Would that be clearance, Clarence?
.
.
.
.
.
Roger, Roger.
That was Captain Peter Tiberius Pan, who fought epic battles against the Klingon known as H’ukh.
Tick
Tick
Tick
I thought episode 2 was excellent. One of my favorites of the series.
I thought it was very well-written.
The episode “A Quality of Mercy” is sort-of a remake of the original series episode “Balance of Terror”. Except this wonders what happens if captain Pike is commanding the Enterprise and fights the Romulans. It’s pretty fun to watch.
Episode 2 was great. It teetered on the knife’s edge of laying things on too thick but stayed on the good side of that line. One issue, and this is the fundamental issue with prequels, is we knew she would be absolved because we know she stays on as XO but that is a minor quibble.
spock’s outburst was humourous.
Is it just me or does the splash opening of the series remind anybody else of the “The More You Know…” graphic?