Stupid liberal idea of the day

Since it’s clearly needed again:
“Abolish ICE” does not, in any way, equal “Abolish border enforcement”.
That interpretation is straight up intentionally misleading bullfuckingshit.

Abolish ICE is much, much more popular than defund the police. They’re not comparable.

The way we do the job that ICE is supposed to do needs to be thoroughly reformed. The job that ICE actually does is a job that we need to stop doing entirely.

We already have nobody doing the job that ICE was created for.

Absolutely zero disagreement from me on that statement. You are not wrong.

We need someone to enforce out borders, and I don’t care if that someone goes under the name “ICE” or not. But if the Dems do the sort of house cleaning that organization needs, and forces out the unqualified, incompetent, and out-right criminal, I’m not sure there’s going to be a practical difference between “reform” and “abolish.”

I know that.

The 58% of voters who think that open borders is a mainstream Democratic position clearly do not.

I think it would be helpful if we didn’t pick slogans that seem tailor made to confuse voters about where we stand on this issue.

Don’t tell John Lennon that…

There are plenty of people who seriously think that both are a good worth working for, and not because they’re anarchists. I don’t think I agree with them, necessarily, but I do think seriously about the basic point of whether the police as an institution can actually be reformed or the issues and suffering borders cause… Just ask the refugees who drowned in the Mediterranean about that…

Should we take serious political advice from a singer? Based on a song that displays a grade school level of political analysis?

Why?

Name one.

Of course it can. Policing is all in all a net positive, even in places where it has serious flaws like the US. And it’s much more of a net positive in places where those issues are lessened, like much of Europe.

The solution to that crisis is to abolish borders?

[Citation needed]

Thank you for demonstrating my point. The fact that people who share your attitude are out there is precisely why I’m no longer comfortable with terminology like “Defund the Police”. It’s a nice slogan so long as we are all on the same page about policing. If some of us actually want to get rid of the police, it stops being so neat.

Are you proposing that the Republicans stop pushing that erroneous idea?

No, really, citation needed. How many murders do the police prevent, versus how many people they kill? How much theft do they prevent, versus the amount they seize themselves? Give numbers, please. Last actual numbers I saw, they were not, in fact, a net positive. The police in America are so bad that no police at all would literally be better than what we have right now.

Now, of course, what would be even better yet would be to have an organization in each locale that were dedicated to serving and protecting the public and upholding justice. Someone should invent something like that.

You literally can’t give statistics for something that would have happened but didn’t; not without the power of precognition. Setting an impossible standard is a not a good faith argument.

Are there any stats on how many murders the police claim they prevent?

We don’t have statistics. We can’t even know how many police shootings there are each year.

How many police shootings a year? No one knows

It’s difficult to make objective declarations without statistics, which is another reason why these discussions frequently end up as emotional arguments.

Honestly, having no body of people empowered to enforce laws would be a complete fucking disaster. I appreciate that our police are overmilitarized, overviolent, and almost always appear in the wake of a bad thing happening, rather than before the incident, but we can’t make them go away without replacing them.

The existence of a bad police force means most people obey the law just to stay out of their way.

You’ve made this claim about “Abolish ICE” is a prerequisite for winning a Democratic primary and it has been countered before:

At high water mark of outrage over ICE Democratic voters were split between reform and abolish messages when offered both. Again when most immediately angry in the current news cycle.

Repeating something doesn’t make it any less incorrect.

Among general voters Reform is the clear winner.

This is an opinion on which we disagree. I’m not claiming it as fact – just, in my experience as a close watcher of primaries, passion and anger will beat supposed pragmatism on issues like this. And in my understanding of the polling of Democratic voters, “abolish ICE” has a clear majority support.

Some polling examples:

All of these polls have Democrats supporting “abolish ICE” well into the %70s.

Again. When offered the option of reform … instead of having to choose abolish or support, as in your polls presented … at peak anger times … then abolish and reform are even among Democratic voters and reform wins in the general population.

The public overall is behind the reform option, and given that virtually no one actually wants to abolish the (in fact legitimate) functions of ICE, messaging the reality helps make getting it done more possible. Even if “reform” ends as up redistribution of its functions.

We have huge public support for reining in the abuses of ICE, creating divisions between those who are all that page is counter to actually getting shit done.

There are some progressive purists who will vote against someone who advocates significant structural reforms and moving money back from it to other priorities, like healthcare affordability, but won’t say the magic “abolish” word. But in my strongly held opinion that word is not going to be the litmus test for most.

Which is probably why “abolish” supporters want to downplay or even rhetorically eliminate the possibility of “reform”. Since “support” supporters are very unlikely to ever adopt the “abolish” position, the major competitor for the “abolish” movement is the “reform” position, not the “abolish” one.

I think that those people are extremely vocal online, but in reality they make up a minuscule portion of the electorate.