Stupidest Argument Someone Around You Has Made

A friend once told me that her great-grandfather the pig farmer ate a half pound of bacon and three eggs every morning, he smoked, he drank and he lived to be ninety. Therefore, that was a healthy way to live. When I mentioned that it was very likely that her great-grandfather got more exercise than she does (farming pigs and all) and that he was not exposed to nearly as many chemical influences in his day-to-day life, she said hotly, “That has nothing to do with it!”

I dunno, but I think she might be wrong.

Whenever anyone says, "Because God is/was on our side.

This is especially directed towards athletes. I don’t care very much for religion, but I know this much: The absolute last thing that God will/would do is choose sides in a fucking athletic contest.

Well, do of my friends were having this long argument… but both of them were right. It was like something from a nightmare. They just wouldn’t stop.

Thats supposed to be “two” not “do”

Me: You can’t prove God exists, nor can you prove he doesn’t.
Girl: That’s not true. You can prove he exists.
Me: Can you prove God exists?
Girl: Yes.
Me: How?
Girl: Read the Bible.

That was her entire response. After sharing this with my dad, and us both having a good laugh over it, he joked:

“You can prove Cthulhu exists!”
“How?”
“Read the Necromonicon!”

Like everyone else, I’ve heard hundreds. Couldn’t pick a worst, so I’ll just post my favourite.

I have a dear friend named Steve. He’s sweet and usually a good friend. But I avoid discussing anything too intellectual with him, simply because I don’t want to wind up laughing.

For example, he considers himself a scientific rationalist, except his science ends with Isaac Newton. He rejects all of Einstein’s work and all quantum mechanics as “new age stuff.”

Once we were discussing time dilation in relativity, and Steve argued vociferously that time dilation did not exist, that time was a constant and dilation an illusion. I asked him why he believed that.

“Time only appears to slow down as you speed up because you’re getting closer to the clocks.”

To this day, I still don’t know what he meant.

Anyway, he’s since turned his attention from science to economics. He’s discovered Ayn Rand, and thinks she was the greatest thinker to have ever lived :smack:

Derleth-if she is paranoid, delusional and almost schizophrenic, I think that would be the main reason WHY you can’t really reason with her. Her mind doesn’t function that way.

So it’s more fun to just make up more crazy theories!!!
Oh, one time in Child Development class, we were discussing televisions shows we had watched and reviewed for class. One girl did a Christmas special. She gave it a negative review:

“See, the characters talked about God and stuff.”

Teacher: “And?”

“Well, what if their parents don’t want them to believe that?”

D’uh, moron, then they’re probably not going to celebrate Christmas, or at least they can explain that to their children.

Guin: I realize that she isn’t working on the same frequency as the rational world. If she were, she wouldn’t be her.

And yes, I do have fun listening to her crazy ideas. :slight_smile:

We were playing some sort of game in historu class, that involved picking a certain item that began with a cartain letter.

The topic was Fruit, the letter was F. We had to get a fruit that bagan with the letter F.

Me: Fig

Her: Figs aren’t fuit, they are cookies.

Me: No, that’s a Fig Newton, they have jelly made from figs inside of them.

Her: Whatever, at least im not a some kind of smart person.
By the way, we were in 10th grade at the time.

Sadly, the winner for me belongs to my sister. She’s young and impressionable, and was hanging around some Creation Science types.

she comes in, I am watching “Walking with Prehistoric Beasts”
Her: What is that?
Me: It’s a prehistoric animal.
Her: Like a dinosaur?
Me: No, something that lived between the time that dinosaurs lived and before mankind.
[pause]
Her: Well, I believe that dinosaurs and humans lived at the same time.
[incredulous pause]
Me: Uh, ok. Why?
Her: Because of the Bible.
Me: First of all, the Bible doesn’t say that. Second of all, you can believe that, but it’s not true. If you look at the evidence…
Her: Don’t argue with me. It’s my belief. You can’t argue with a person’s beliefs.
[surprised pause]
Me: Okaaay… let’s just drop it.

(She later recanted after trying to deny this conversation.)

Is your Dad dating my Nan? My Nan has said pretty much exactly that to my Mum and me - except using the Brit “trolleys” rather than the US “carts”. My parents and I have got very good at keeping a straight face. I love my Nan to bits, but she does have a slightly malfunctioning logic module, and a dodgy brain-mouth connection.

I went travelling with three friends after leaving Uni. You know how, if you spend the entirety of every day with the same people for two months, your irritation threshold drops due to all the times you’ve had to bite your tongue for the sake of peace? The end result is you argue over really stupid stuff rather than the issues that have actually got your goat. After two months, I witnessed two friends have a stand up, rage driven, “Why can’t you understand?” type argument over holiday allocations. It went like this:
A: “20 days is three weeks holiday, because 20/7 is three weeks.”
B: “But there are weekends you fool. Four five-day working weeks are 20 days.”
A: “But you might not take your holidays in whole weeks. What if you only took off 20 Wednesdays? Then you’d have had three weeks holiday.”
B: “…! No one would ever do that!”
A: “They might.” [Trans: I am clearly wrong, but there is no way on God’s green earth that I am going to admit, particularly to you, you bastard.]

The story that immediately comes to mind:

In my wife’s small hometown in the heart of the Midwest, I went on a quick grocery store run for her mom. On the way out, my sister-in-law said “oh, can you pick up some whole milk for (her then-1-year-old son) Justin?”. “Sure”, I said. Even though I had never used the phrase “whole milk” (ignorant suburban spawn that I am), I assumed it meant what I thought of as “Vitamin D” milk - the stuff with the full fat content - and I figured I would ask someone at the store.

Sure enough, there was an older fellow loading new cartons onto the shelves at the store when I got there. “Excuse me” I asked, after checking cartons of Vitamin D milk, but not seeing the word “whole” on them, “but is this Vitamin D milk whole milk?”.

“Yep” he replied. Satisfied, I grabbed a carton and proceeded to walk away. Unfortunately, my mentor continued to dispense counsel - he said:

“It’s ‘ho’ milk because it’s ‘homogized’!”

I paused, realizing that any coaching he had given me was now out the window, “uh - excuse me?”

He looked at me with a somewhat exasperated look, then patiently picked up a carton of Vitamin D milk. Pointing to the work “homogenized” on the carton, he said "It’s ‘ho’ milk because it’s ‘homogized’, then - I kid you not - gesturing to each syllable of the word, he pointed three times and said slowly ‘Ho-Mo-Gized’!

I was stuck - I wanted to get the right milk for my nephew, but didn’t want to offend this guy. I desperately looked at the cartons, trying not to guffaw and trying to find some reference to the word “whole”. Since I hadn’t left, the man said indignantly “boy, what do you need?!” Shame-facedly, I grabbed the carton again and made off with it, trying not to burst out laughing. At the check out, I quickly asked the checker “uh, is Vitamin D milk ‘whole’ milk?” “Sure!” “Cool.”

I paid for my food and got the heck out of there.

Oh, if only that were true. If only.
Daniel

I’m a bit ashamed to admit it, but think I know what he’s talking about. This is relativity as described in the fine scientific docu-drama “Young Einstein” starring that master thespian Yahoo Serious.

Actually, now that I think about it, it’s the OPPOSITE of how it was described in that movie. Imagine moving backwards AWAY from a clock at the speed of light. “Young Einstein” postulated (to his girlfriend, Young Madam Curie of course) that since you are keeping up with the light from the surface of the clock, you will only see the image of the clock at a single unchanging time, and hence “time has stopped”.

Ask your friend if he also knows who first split the beer atom to make carbonated beer.

"I quickly asked the checker “uh, is Vitamin D milk ‘whole’ milk?” “Sure!” “Cool.”

That would be even funnier if the checkout person had the same reasoning on it being “ho milk.”

Dairy Mary

My brother and youngest sister (9 years age difference) were arguing about something, as sibs are prone to do. Bro, reaching the limit of his patience, said “Quit acting like an idiot!”

Sis, thinking to skewer him, retorted “Who’s acting?”

And the spectators had a good laugh.

Oh my god! My stapler is alive! I mean, it’s not a lizard, so it must be alive, right?

Not really an argument per se, but still worth remembering.

When I was in college, I was a member of symphonic band, and we went on a tour of the state. Instead of staying in motels, we stayed at people’s houses. 8 of us stayed in the large house of a furntiure salesman the night after our last concert that day.

We were all together talking, when the guy’s southern belle trophy wife asked us, “What was that weird song y’all played that had all that poetry and stuff?”

We told her it was Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night, based on a poem by Dylan Thomas. She asked us what it was supposed to be about, and we told her the author was expressing regret over his father dieing, etc.

She responded, “Well, I never could understand that there Bob Dylan, now I know why!”

Not really an argument, but the most stupid comments I’ve ever heard. I’ve told this one before but am too lazy to look it up.

I had this cow-orker named Kim who was extremely map and directionally challenged. This conversation happened shortly after she moved from one suburb to another. Observe:

Kim: In which direction do I live now?

Me: You live south of Minneapolis.

Kim: And I used to live east of Minneapolis.

Me: Nope, you lived to the west.

Kim: No, it was the east. I remember because that’s where the sun sets.

<stunned silence>

Me: The sun sets in the west.

Kim: No… Oh wait, I know why I got confused. It sets in the west in Minnesota, but in Florida – where I’m from – it sets in the east.

<more stunned silence>

Me: Kim, the sun sets in the west no matter where you are on the globe.

Kim: Okay, maybe it doesn’t set in the east all over Florida, but on this beach near where my parents live, it sets in the east.

<I faint dead away>