[QUOTE=StarvingButStrong]
Also, this episode made it pretty clear that either Terry can’t think ahead (unlikely) or he’s willing to burn his alliance members to improve his own chances. Consider what would have likely have happened if Terry had allowed Nick to win the Immunity Necklace.
The Casaya would most likely have targeted him, while the Lamina’s went after Shane. 6 votes Terry, 4 votes Shane – but Terry whips out the Idol and the votes against him go away. Result: bye-bye Shane AND the count goes to 4 vs. 5. Then they’d only have to swing a single vote instead of two.
Okay, maybe Casaya would have been alive to that option and go for the safety of voting off Austin…but by insisting on winning, Terry didn’t give Casaya a chance to make the mistake.
[/QUOTE]
This is an awful lot of needless complexity. Jeff has made it clear multiple times, including this episode, that the holder of the hidden immunity can use it to save anyobdy, not just himself.
After the vote was read, I mind-shouted “Use the damn immunity! You can boot Shane NOW!” When he didn’t, I thought about if I were in his position, and realized he probably did the right thing.
At the moment the vote was read, Terry had two immunities. If he had done the power play and booted Shane, he would have immediately been reduced to having none, and still been part of a 5 against 4 minority. He gave conversion the college try, and didn’t swing anybody, so why should he believe the 5 on 4 would go any different?
All in all, he’s fucked, but at least now he can try something different: offer the immunity to somebody. He should have done that in the first place by offering it to the “first one out” of the alliance of 6. (Especially after he won the immunity challenge.) So say to Bruce: “You’re getting kicked out first, second at the latest, after us LaMina schmoes get Pagonged. Switch to us now and I’ll give you the hidden immunity. That guarantees you make it to the final 5, and if you win one of two immunities that will guarantee you make it to final four. Don’t take th deal and you’re likely out with 6 remaining.”