"Take Good Care of My baby" = about adoption or a lover?

Okay, Bobby V’s hit song from decades back, “Take Good Care of My Baby,” is a really pretty song, one I liked when I first heard it on our (now officially) Oldies station in the middle '70s. But, here’s the thing - I thought it was about adoption.

While I’m not adopted, a really good friend had been. I knew from what my parents told me back then that a child given up for adoption is b/c the birth parents just weren’t able or ready to have kids. Hence, when I heard the song first, at about 7 or 8, i thought, “Well, it’s a guy who had a baby, and he’s telling someone else to take care of her b/c they love her and he just didn’t do a good job - hadn’t been a true parent.”

As I got into my teen years, I realized the numerous different ways to refer to lovers, and that some guys, for odd reasons, referred to them with terms such as “baby,” and figured it was about a girlfriend he hadn’t been true to.

Now, however, I wonder - some of the other thigns I hear in the song just sound so much like the things you’d say about real babies. I mean, “Once upon a time that little girl was mine” is one thing, but you hear talk of never letting a little kid see a cloudy sky, not a lover who should be ont he same level as you. Same with making a rainbow all around them. I even wrote a piece of fan fiction on fanfiction.net called “Take Good Care of My baby” about adoption.

So, what do you dopers think? Is the song about adoption, a lover who the singer was untrue to, or is it one of those that is classic because it could be either, and the writer was just talented enough to make it that way.

I vote lover.

Well, you have to remember that attitudes toward women and relationships have changed a LOT since that song was written. Women weren’t supposed to be equal partners, at least not in the way we think of it now. They were supposed to be taken care of and made happy, and in return they took care of their men and kids and made them happy. Referring to teenagers as little girls was pretty common, as well as calling your sweetheart “baby”.

So yeah, it was meant about a girlfriend he’d done wrong, but it can also be interpreted as being about adoption.

The adoption angle never occurred to me. I always assumed it was about a girlfriend/lover.

Your interpretation would have never occurred to me, and looking at the lyrics, I’d have to still say it’s about a girlfriend. I think hearing it as a child you thought of the literal definition of the term baby and it’s still guiding your impression of the song.

Next you’ll tell us you think Dianna Ross and the Supremes were referring to an infant when they sang baby, baby in the song Where did our love go? :slight_smile:

Eric

Well with the line “and if you should discover that you don’t really love her, please send my baby back home to me” it should be obvious enough it’s a lover. If it was a real baby they can’t love, they aren’t going to ask for it back.

I think

“If I’d been true I know she’d never be with you” is the giveaway.

Lover.