Thanks all for your comments. As a parent, it can be difficult to find a mirror against which you can hold your parenting choices.
A couple of responses:
Larz - you say (paraphrase) you do not lie, you just tend to disclose as little as possible. IMO, witholding info you know is relevant and of interest to another party is the easiest form of lying. Look at it another way - if your parent went through the whole “20-questions” exercise trying to ask exactly the correct question that would force you to disclose what you knew they wanted to know in the first place - then would you be accusing them of prying or nagging?
Severin - you asked why we have our kids get up and finish their chores before a certain time. There are at least 2 main reasons for that. One is that we are sick of being the music/chores cops. My kids are generally good kids, but they do tend to procrastinate. (I assure you, they inherited that from me.) We spend several hundred dollars a month on music lessons - which the kids strongly maintain they wish to continue. We have said that we will continue to support their music, but that they must practice regularly. And we are sick and tired of it being late in the evening, and maybe the family wants to go out, or watch a movie, and one of the kids says they didn’t practice yet. We refuse to have to remind them daily to do what they know they have to do every day.
Similar with chores. I’m out of the house and at my job before any of the kids are awake. IMO, when I get home 10 hours later, I shouldn’t have to ask my kid if he mowed the lawn, or remind them to make their beds, etc.
The second reason may be sort of philosophical - and I can certainly imagine folk disagreeing with us. We think there is some utility in kids getting used to having to get up at a certain time consistent with the rest of their family, and most of society. For example, we place a high importance on the family eating dinner together. That is the one place where we make sure anyone can bring up “important things” and make sure they are heard. If a kid wakes up at - say 2 p.m., it is less likely that they will want to eat dinnier at 6. If their entire waking and sleeping schedule is vastly different from the rest of their family’s, I think that increases the distance between them. And as the person making the money and paying the bills, I will not allow a kid to dictate the household schedule. I will not allow their “convenience” to cause me “inconvenience.” I’m probably not being too clear about this - but let me know if you do not get the gist of what I’m saying.
Other elements of this “philosophical” aspect - we don’t see a “need” for anyone to sleep so late. Absent a night-time job, a nocturnal lifestyle strikes us as a luxury. Which is fine for someone living alone, but not to the extent that it imposes upon others. Face it, folks - 9:30 isn’t exactly the crack of dawn.
Another more minor element - some of you may have noted my “Luddite” tendencies. At a basic level, sleeping very late is “un-natural.” The product of excessive energy use. I’m exaggerating somewhat here, but I do not see an inherent benefit in adopting such a lifestyle. Something strikes me as desirable about living in a manner that somehow reflects the natural passage of time.
Like I said, let me know if you want me to expand upon our choices. I’ll stop here before writing a treatise.
Thanks again. Keep the input coming
I’m not suggesting that our choices are the only legitimate ones, just offering what seems to work for us. I always find it frustrating when I here parents complain about their kids, and throw up their hands saying “What can we do?” Well, there’s generally a whole list of things you could do. But first, you have to get off your ass …