A Farewell to Kings is my favorite and in my opinion the most thoroughly consistent album. I think it fits perfectly as the transitional pivot separating Fly by Night from Signals and thus perfectly exemplifying the ideal 1970s-era Rush (yes, I know Signals came out in 1982).
Though I enjoyed Rush in the late-1980s, I did not identify with the post-Signals albums, except Grace Under Pressure, which is still as much early Rush as later Rush. The Rush of the 1990s I know not at all.
But A Farewell to Kings, man, that one would make it to my desert island.