Oh yeah, I “slipped up”. That like even means anything - that was in my claiming post, not some extra NETA or something. If I were lying, why would I even need to add a detail to cover this?
IS has it right. Peeker is semiconfirmed because the results said Town. If he is BH, then he is an alpha BH. Same with the Original Sinners. Or, he might have been sinfected. Or, he might be Town.
Meeko, do me a favour. Stop assuming I’m Lord of the Scum for a moment, and read my amn posts. What I have quoted above is the biggest stretch to fit a preconceived conclusion I have seen in the game. Don’t go looking for facts to justify a flawed opinion - let the facts lead you to a correct one.
NETA: I don’t know why peeker’s Role PM mentions that thing about the alpha Sinners, but I can guess. My Cop powers are great at detecting BH, but terrible at finding Sinners. I assume that someone out there has a balancing ability, good at finding Sinners but bad at finding BH.
BH are returned as BH.
Original Sinners are returned as Original Sinners.
Sinfected are returned as Town.
Town are returned as Town.
In Peeker’s case, since he started off as Town, he will be read as Town. His power role has no relevance to mine. I can’t comment on any other investigative roles, whether or not they exist, of which I know nothing.
Oh please. People have been saying that there are most likely 4 BH in this game for Days. Balance-wise, it makes sense. And I believe Chronos used the phrase LyLo before he died, so yeah, great scum slip.
NETA: Check Thing Fish’s post, 1258 Chronos’ at 1745 and 1830,
Not to mention my own at 2007 where I established my estimate of 4 BH. That puts us at LyLo. This wasn’t some comment out of the blue - I was leading on from my claim post. The Town seemed to be largely in agreement of this fact, which was why we agreed to a mass claim in the first place.
We are currently waiting for Paul to claim, I believe. Paul…you there?
I’m torn between believing AllWalker and Rysto(or neither, actually).
It seemed likely to me that AllWalker was telling the truth, but mostly because he claimed first. If Rysto had claimed first, I would have leaned toward believing him naturallly. Anyway, I think AllWalker’s PM is very genuine looking, but I would not consider it impossible for him to have written it himself. However, AllWalker seems very certain there are four scum in the game, something that he have only speculated about…and something I’ve never been sure about.
Tough call for sure.
What is everyone else thinking about this conflict? We do need to continue claiming, by the way. We should not totally let this distract us, even though it does seem that at this point in time, today’s lynch will most likely come out of this conflict.
I still want to see everyone else’s claim and I assume you will want to see mine, so Paul, get going!
The part where you say that if you convert to the Sinners, when investigated you will show up as Town. That is the basic definition of an alpha-Scum - Scum who when investigated gives a false reading as Town.
Is this why you voted for me? If not, care to elaborate? For crap’s sake, I am vouching for your non-BH-iness - you could at least provide an argument I could address. In the meantime, look over my role PM carefully - it explains everything there. And look over Rysto’s carefully - and ask why his PM seems incomplete.
Please. You are complaining that I did not explicitely state my previous assumptions, made 2 posts earlier, were still in effect. This whole debate, like most in Mafia games, is based around clutching at straws. If I missed an implied “probably at”, then perhaps comma placement should be on the agenda.
Meanwhile, your PM is simplistic, reads like it was fabricated with maximal simplicity to cover its fradulence and, of course, contradicts what I know. So yeah, I am going to have an issue with what looks like a truncated list.
