What happens if more than 2 players tie in the vote?
And
**
Vote Count?**
pedescribe breaks ties in this game by choosing one of the vote leaders at random.
Post 66 Fluff as game just begins
Post 71 More game beginning fluff
Post 88Stating that we vote to O or E and also who to lynch.
Post 90Responding to Joey noticing no editing restriction. Says he assumes no editing.
Post 96Respong to Freuding Slip. FS says no one will want to vote since voting for an execution will result in Sinification. Mahaloth wonders about the downside to Ostracization
Post 107Recommends not editing posts (This occurs before the infamous Angel/Newpaul post edit.) Mahaloth also repeats his questions as to the downside to Ostracization
Post 118Recommends Ostracization early on to prevent the spread of Sin
Post 120Clarification on the Sinners being able to Sinfect someone at Night.
Post 139Points out that I had 2 errors in my vote for Angel/Newpaul for the editing
Post 143Talking with meeko about the end of Day and how slow the Days move early on
Post 156Points out a few people who aren’t posting much. Recommends a Lynch the Lurker approach for Day 1
[Comments with Spurious about 'being on the list of low posters
[URL=“http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showpost.php?p=11090748&postcount=167”]Post 167](http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showpost.php?p=11090709&postcount=164)
Post 164Votes Spurious for his comment on Mahaloth’s list as well as Spurious’ vote to exectue Angle/Newpaul for no reason
Post 169Fluff
Post 172Replies to Justin who was responding to being identified as a low poster
Post 197Reiterates his opinion that Ostacization is preferred to Execution at this point.
Post 203Asks Meeko his opinion on O vs E
Post 204Clarifying his coding error in post 203 (without editing):smack:
Post 213Reiterates his support for lynch the lurker and also points out his reasons for voting Spurious
Post 216Has talked himself into voting for a lurker. He unvotes Spurious and votes for Captain
Post 219Defends himself from Thing Fish’s questions. Thing fish had thought it somewhat scummy that Mahalooth unvoted Spurious when Spurious took a good lead and cast a 1 off vote for Captain. Here is Mahaloth’s response:
Post 260Defends Angle/Newpaul from my vote. He says I’m pushing this post editing issue to hard by sayigng it’s possible that Angel/Newpaul wanted to set a precedent.
Post 289Asks for a vote update
Post 296Out of game
Post 311Some comments on the O vs E process
Post 313Comments on meeko asking if one can vote for oneself
Post 317ditto
Post 330Out of Game
Post 332Out of Game
Post 354Comments about the forbidden thread
Post 355Ditto
Post 374Agrees with Joey on Ostracization
Post 383Replies to me about keeping an open mind regarding the effects of Ostracization
Post 405Suggests people do post analysis of themselves and others as the Days go on.
Post 416Out of Game
End of Day 1
Post 417Ditto
Post 420Asks if Night strategy is allowed
Post 430Comment about the result of the Ostracization of George
Post 441Trying to clarify things for Meeko
Post 453Ditto
Post 463Fluff
Post 486Defends himself from Thing Fish. TF was accusing him of flip-flopping on the editing thing. Mahaloth had initially claimed to be against editing, but then defended the votes against Angel/Newpaul who edited. He stated he’d vote for any editors at this point.
Post 495Says he’s not a Sinner (gee thanks) Asks if Sinners can get someone through a Night Action. This is interesting. Here is what Mahaloth says now:
Here is what Nahaloth said in post 120
Did he suddenly forget about this?*
Post 497Thanks Allwalker for clarifying his stance on Sinner recruitment. Allwalker also had Mahaloth’s post 120 in his response, but didn’t seem to notice the contradiction.
End of Night 1
Post 508Apologizes to Telcontar for his death.
Post 516Asks about Telcontar being an Aegis and a purger
Post 524Clarifying Day end time for Meeko
Post 527Pondering what Telcontar may have done the previous Night
Post 534Wonders if a protected person knew that they were protected. *(this isn’t the first time he’s mentioned this, and it almost seems to be a little bit of fishing)
*
Post 543Saying Meeko’s idea that Ostracization must help Blackhearts is a stretch. Mahaloth supports Ostracization becuase no one was Sinfected and Spurious is gone.
Post 547Clarifies that he meant that no one was Sinfected by voting for execution.
Post 548retracts Post 547
Post 562Tries to calm Meeko down
Post 581More pondering about Telcontar
Post 584Trying to answer questions for Meeko
Post 586Fluff
Post 594Fluff
Post 602Asks if we just lynch now after the voice of God forbid us from executing.
Post 635Asks Angel/Newpaul to post the PM about being sinfected.
Post 636Asks for a current player list
Post 663Comments on Nanook’s lurking
Post 671Wants to think about lynch the lurker
Post 677Lists pros and cons re: lynch the lurker
Post 684Tells Freud/peeker that we can only lynch now.
Post 764His comments on paul’s roleclaim
Post 786This is one of the posts that made me think Mahaloth was ‘licking meeko’s balls’
Post 791Unimportant
Post 796Points out that Nanook and Captain are still AWOL. Tells Town we have 2 choices, lynch paul or lynch a lurker. Agress that lynching paul is wise (though in post 764, he was against a lynch of paul.)
Votes for paul
Post 802Back to licking meeko’s balls
Post 820States support for lynching Nanook, but keeps his vote on paul
Post 857Notices Nanook joined, wonders where Captain is
Post 865Questions me about the possibility of a Sinner’s thread
Post 878Agrees with me about the liklihood of a Sinner’s thread. Wonders how many Sinners may have started in the game
50 more posts in the next message. Exciting isn’t it?
Post 908Tells Thing Fish that ped wants use to vote in purple to remove people from the game for low participation
Post 910Asks if we want to replace Captain. Comments on Naoonk’s claim of low post count/high content
Post 912Votes to replace Captain
Post 915Tells meeko that he can still vote for Nanook while voting to replace Captain
Post 917Ditto
Post 920Asks Rysto what he wants to do in regards to Captain
Post 929Promises a review of Rysto
Post 930Mahaloth’s conclusions about Rysto: He posts content and he’s not appearing Scummy
Post 936Wants to have a system of figuring out who analyzes whom at some point.
Post 937Functions as Meeko’s timekeeper again
Post 940Fluff
Post 949More comments on assigning analyzations
Post 987Agrees with Rysto that Captains late return doesn’t excuse his absence
Post 1059Defends himself from Meeko’s accusations. Meeko had accused him of being a bandwagon voter (meeko appeared to have not done so) and Meeko had also accused him of using their friendship to avoid suspicion (???)
End of Day 2
Post 1062Asks for a final Day 2 post count
Post 1064Unimportant
Post 1066Fluff with Meeko
Post 1078Encourages Paul to dis-sinfect Angel
Post 1079Agrees that the people who didn’t vote are not helping out
End of Night 2
Post 1090Asks if paul’s death means he was telling teh truth *(As an aside, pedescribe has confirmed that paul was telling the truth. Had paul lied, he would not have been able to sub in for Angel because he would have had knowledge that Angel shouldn’t have and other players didn’t have)
*
Post 1093Claimns his vote was bought
Post 1120Still wonders if paul was honest. Also wonders is Special and Meeko are Scum Masons
Post 11291. Thinks Angel is asking anyone ensinned to come forward. 2. Denies being ensinned 3. Asks if anyone esle wishes to comment 4. Reminds us he cannot vote.
Post 1133Fluff
Post 1136Comments about Angel’s post restriction
Post 1147Clarifies that he thought Meeko and Special might both be mason traitors.
Post 1150Read this oneMahaloth claims that he wishes he never voted for Spurious. He also points out that he voted for Captain. He then says he didn’t believe paul, that’s why he voted for him, but that captain was the better lynch. Ends by asking if we still have lurkers.
This pings me a bit. He got off the lynch of a Townie and through a one off vote on a Sinner. He then voted for someone who claimed to be very anti-sinner (paul) instead of voting for a Sinner (captain) who he claims was a better lynch. Perhaps his Day 1 vote was for Town cred in case Captain got killed?
Post 1187More of the same
Post 1206Agrees with me that there are probably more than 1 Sinner
Post 1207Asks Angel to clarify the vote for Rysto
Post 1228Out of Game
Post 1230Unimportant
Post 1237Votes Peeker over the editing thing
Post 1238NETA
Post 1247Comments on Nanook saying Mahaloth over reacted
Post 1248Defends his vote for peeker(Freudian)
Post 1257Unvoted peeker because his vote was bought (does he not get a posting restriction?)
Post 1273Wonders why peeker called Meeko a fisher
Post 1289Thinks Angel is trying to tell us that she posted in the Forbidden thread
Post 1293Asks Angel if she lied about praying
Post 1296Asks Meeko for reasons Meeko is voting for Chronos
Post 1333Thanks me for reminding everyone that Blackhearts cannot change their won condition
Post 1336Indicates that if he could vote, he would be voting for Angel, though he doesn’t say why.
Post 1339Asks for a vote count
Post 1347Unimportant
Post 1374Tries to calm meeko down
Post 1382Ditto
Post 1386Fluff
Post 1397Comments that he still hasn’t gotten instructions on who to vote for
I don’t see a direction this is going in Ed.
Um, yeah, in retrospect, I’m not clear what I was on about with post 747.
But as I said, I wasn’t trying to make a case in that post, just calling attention to the fact that I felt there was a case to be made. Maybe, as Rysto said, it looked smudgy to do it that way, but it would have been worse to just say “Hey, I think peeker’s scum and I’ll tell you why later?”, no? Maybe it would have been wisest to say nothing for the time, but I knew I wouldn’t be around again until late tonight and I didn’t want to just vanish entirely for over two days.
WRT to your smudgy rhetorical question at the end, obviously “skimming” has a pejorative tone that I wouldn’t want to claim, but yes, I did a reread (with heightened suspicion of the three non-me paul voters) and found some stuff that I didn’t notice the first time. If that’s a scumtell in your world, then vote away.
I chose that word because, so far as I could tell, your criticism of Freudian Slit was mostly based on her alleged skimming, which makes it seem rather odd that you’d be doing the same thing.
Bah, I’m feeling paranoid right now… I should probably just go to bed and take another look tomorrow morning.
Discussion of post 747 snipped because I just addressed it.
First paragraph: What? Why would you vote or not vote for someone based on whether they have the Seed of Sin at some particular moment? If they are Town, they can just pray to remove it. Besides, Angel’s vote for paul tells me she is almost certainly not a Sinner, but that doesn’t mean she can’t be a Blackheart.
Second paragraph: I’m just going to refer you what I said (post 468) the last time you tried to smudge me about this:
*Anyway, if anyone is thinking that was scum gloating on my part, I would ask you to remember that I was publicly opposed to the Spurious lynch back when he only had four votes. *
You’re making no sense, Rysto. I will keep my vote where it is because I suspect (although I have no comprehensive data on this point) that OMGUS votes made while drinking at 1:15 am tend to not have a pro-Town effect, but…wow.
Hi, guys, I’m just checking in briefly.
I got my “vote” pm regarding my bought vote.
This is a bought vote.
I’ll paste it below:
" pedescribe pedescribe is offline
Guest
Join Date: Mar 2008
You are voting…
for Angelpaul. "
So, I vote Angelpaul
AngeloftheNorth (5): Joey P, Allwalker, Nanook, Meeko, Mahaloth
TF (1): Rysto
Nanook of the North (1): Chronos
Allwalker (1) AngeloftheNorth
Peekercpa (1): TF
Pede, could we get an updated player list at some point?
Vote Peekercpa
It’s not really for anything Peekercpa did but more how Freudian Slit was acting. She didn’t seem to want to participate.
I wasn’t really trying to go in a direction. I just wanted to take a look at someone.
I also didn’t want to post my conclusions until after people had a chance to read it.
My conclusion is: While Mahaloth has done some things that seem slightly suspicious, I see no really strong things against him here. If I had to guess, I’d say it’s probable he’s Town, but I’m still slightly suspicious. The voting seems a bit odd as does the forgetting that Sinners can Sinfect at Night (was that fake ignorance, something anti-Town players do sometimes?)
**Re: vote count
Did I miss **peeker unvoting Mahaloth?
Depending on whether or not he did, we have either four or five nonvoters. Lame.
I have no comments for the public regarding my opinion of paulwhowasanAngelandwillshortlybeaghostagain’s alignment at this time.
(die scum die!)
Look, a miracle! The Sun is standing still in the sky, instead of setting! Surely, this must be a sign from God.
It must be the Equinox, or something.
Where is an egg I can balance end on ?
Peeker unvoted me when he tried to split his vote into four parts…which was weird.
But it could add yet another element of strange into the game, and we’d get to see how good Pede is with fractions.
NETA, I do find it interesting that with all the voting and unvoting he did, he never did register a vote.
Asking to vote for myself doesn’t seem as bad anymore.
At least, that was with still an integer.