http://news.yahoo.com/s/eo/18563;_ylt=ArakI.pwORmUKnv5o6jDNoG2GL8C;_ylu=X3oDMTA3YXYwNDRrBHNlYwM3NjI-
So I was thinking… wouldn’t it be interesting to not winkingly cheese everything up, and instead, to take the plot completely, utterly seriously in this flick?
I don’t know why “remakes” almost always go for the cheese.
In fact, I can’t think of a single tv-to-movie “remake” that didn’t turn the original into a cornball comedy. (Can you?)
Even in cases where the original was corny, intentionally or not, the “remake” has outcorned the corn. I’m thinking, for example, of My Favorite Martian. What they should have done with that was make some kind of utterly believable, almost serious flick about the Martian and the human from the TV show as they might be today, having lived as friends on Earth for forty or so years. The fact that the martian has literal metal antennae could take on, in this context, an almost darkly comic absurdist tone in its presentation.
I recognize the entertainment and artistic value of subverting the original show in a “remake” in some way, but does it have to be through the conversion of the show into a puffball of corn? Why can’t we “subvert” the old shows by making them believable in a contemporary idiom. (Thereby subverting whatever presuppositions underlie the original works which constitute them as, for us today, somehow cheesey or unbelievable.) That could be clever and interesting!
I think such a treatment might be interesting for Dallas as well, though the original wasn’t meant to be funny AFAIK. But I’m guessing it will be cheesy and corny and will play everything for laughs.
-FrL-