In my opinion you could have argued a bit harder (and you really didn’t get told by the mod you were a Miller?!), but that probably wouldn’t have helped much. The reaction to your defense could have helped though.
Perhaps this counts as spoiled, but at least one of the claimed vanillas should have commented on your posted PM. Heck, anyone should have considered the possibility more carefully, but even CatInASuits mention of your deciding vote to lynch scum didn’t get any reaction.
It reminds me of Not-So-Simpletown were a claimed mason was lynched and no-one cared, but that was because there was no ‘town’ at all there.
I find some PM posting allowed and the others not really annoying. Especially cucuy telling he couldn’t even tell if/what for answer he got whether he knows he fails and a while later just telling it anyway.
Hello? Mod confirmed Miller? And JoeyP did confirm he got a passionate Night and it’s not like he had a chance to claim by Oredigger since he claimed in the sixth post after Dawn Day Three (less then two hours after).
NAFs tracking of JoeyP makes as much sense as blocking him: why would scum pick the most suspicious guy to make a move (unless he has a power himself). All the investigation were better spread out over more people.