The Great SDMB Movie Poll - Semis, 3rd Place and Final

We’ll keep the Semis, 3rd place Matchup and Final in a single thread. Voting in the Semis will remain open until 1200 EST on Saturday October 24, when I will post the polls for the 3rd place matchup and the Final.

Match 1
  • Raiders of the Lost Ark
  • Monty Python and the Holy Grail
0 voters
Match 2
  • The Godfather
  • Casablanca
0 voters

Voting for the semifinal will close in about 4 hours.

This is it. Voting for the Third Place Match and the Final Match will close at 1200 Noon EST on Monday October 26. Results hidden until polls close.

Third Place Match
  • Monty Python and the Holy Grail
  • Casablanca
0 voters
Final Match
  • Raiders of the Lost Ark
  • The Godfather
0 voters

Just a little bump to keep this on the radar.

Another bump. Still not many voters with about 18 hours to go.

Less than 4 hours until the reveal!

Holy Grail edges out Casablanca for 3rd place, and Raiders of the Lost Ark beats The Godfather as Dopers’ favorite movie of all time. Here is the full ranked list of the 256 entrants in the Great SDMB Movie Poll:

Rank Movie
1 Raiders of the Lost Ark
2 The Godfather
3 Monty Python and the Holy Grail
4 Casablanca
5 The Empire Strikes Back
6 The Princess Bride
7 Back to the Future
8 The Shawshank Redemption
9 Young Frankenstein
10 Airplane!
11 Dr. Strangelove
12 Blazing Saddles
13 The Big Lebowski
14 Pulp Fiction
15 The Terminator
16 Ghostbusters
17 Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
18 Stand By Me
19 The Martian
20 The Maltese Falcon
21 Lawrence of Arabia
22 Groundhog Day
23 Jaws
24 The Great Escape
25 The Sting
26 Aliens
27 One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
28 The Fugitive
29 The Hunt for Red October
30 Naked Gun
31 The Bridge on the River Kwai
32 Planes, Trains and Automobiles
33 The Fellowship of the Ring
34 The Shining
35 The Blues Brothers
36 This Is Spinal Tap
37 Rocky
38 Spirited Away
39 Kill Bill Pts. 1 & 2
40 Good Will Hunting
41 Citizen Kane
42 The Incredibles
43 Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home
44 Office Space
45 The Treasure of the Sierra Madre
46 Clue
47 Seven Samurai
48 2001: A Space Odyssey
49 Master and Commander
50 To Kill a Mockingbird
51 Best in Show
52 The Bourne Identity (2002)
53 The Fifth Element
54 Schindler’s List
55 Das Boot
56 Project Hail Mary
57 The Godfather Part II
58 Unforgiven
59 For a Few Dollars More
60 Forbidden Planet
61 All the President’s Men
62 Fight Club
63 Breaker Morant
64 Animal Crackers
65 Toy Story
66 Star Wars: A New Hope
67 The Return of the King
68 Beetlejuice
69 Goodfellas
70 My Cousin Vinnie
71 Galaxy Quest
72 Breakfast Club
73 Fargo
74 Animal House
75 Apollo 13
76 The Magnificent Seven
77 12 Angry Men
78 The Dirty Dozen
79 Harvey
80 Rashomon
81 The Producers
82 Saving Private Ryan
83 Inception
84 Double Indemnity
85 Rain Main
86 The Exorcist (1973)
87 Inglourious Basterds
88 12 Monkeys
89 Grease
90 North By Northwest
91 The Quiet Man
92 The Caine Mutiny
93 A Room With A View
94 The Usual Suspects
95 Shaun of the Dead
96 The Birds
97 Grosse Pointe Blank
98 The Rocky Horror Picture Show
99 The Silence of the Lambs
100 Support Your Local Sheriff
101 Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure
102 LA Confidential
103 Slap Shot
104 On Golden Pond
105 Leon: The Professional (AKA The Professional)
106 Almost Famous
107 The Matrix
108 Sleuth (1972)
109 His Girl Friday
110 Wallace & Gromit: The Wrong Trousers
111 Endless Summer
112 The Apartment
113 The Longest Day
114 The Thing (1982)
115 The Adventures of Robin Hood
116 La Femme Nikita
117 The Deer Hunter
118 The Hangover
119 Wait Until Dark
120 Repo Man
121 Goldfinger
122 True Grit (2010)
123 The Cocoanuts
124 My Man Godfrey
125 Moonrise Kingdom
126 Arthur
127 What’s Up Doc?
128 Return of the Living Dead
129 Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan
130 Apocalypse Now
131 Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
132 A Clockwork Orange
133 Tootsie
134 Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, 1971
135 It’s a Wonderful Life
136 Taxi Driver
137 The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
138 Christmas Vacation
139 Top Secret!
140 Top Gun
141 Little Shop of Horrors (1986)
142 Wallace & Gromit: Curse of the Were Rabbit
143 Vertigo
144 Notorious
145 King Kong (1933)
146 The Third Man
147 Silverado
148 You Only Live Twice
149 Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
150 Captain America: The First Avenger
151 The Abyss
152 Touch of Evil
153 Sixteen Candles
154 Tombstone
155 From Russia With Love
156 In Bruges
157 Princess Mononoke
158 Witness for the Prosecution
159 The Oxbow Incident
160 Rat Race
161 Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy
162 Murder by Death
163 Clash of the Titans (1981)
164 Dumbo (1941)
165 Some Like It Hot
166 Pretty in Pink
167 Contact
168 Rock and Roll High School
169 Silver Linings Playbook
170 Weekend at Bernie’s
171 Reservoir Dogs
172 Gran Torino
173 Trainspotting
174 Les Misérables (2012)
175 Bruce Almighty
176 Charade
177 The Searchers
178 It follows
179 Pygmalion
180 Little Shop of Horrors (1960)
181 Breathless (1960)
182 A Good Year
183 RocknRolla
184 The Descendants
185 The Drop (2014)
186 Stalker (1979)
187 Who’s Harry Crumb
188 Persuasion (1995)
189 The Little Girl That Lives Down The Lane
190 The Package
191 Free Solo
192 Big Wednesday
193 Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
194 Bull Durham
195 The Emperor’s New Groove
196 Help!
197 Hot Fuzz
198 A League of their Own
199 Poltergeist
200 The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
201 Father Goose
202 Bad Santa
203 Road House (1989)
204 Papillon
205 Zulu
206 The Best Years of Our Lives
207 Evil Dead 2
208 The Cabin in the woods
209 To Have and Have Not
210 Braveheart
211 All That Jazz
212 Hobson’s Choice
213 Cold Mountain
214 Yankee Doodle Dandy
215 Snatch
216 Sideways
217 Greyhound
218 Before Sunrise
219 Top Hat
220 Winter’s Bone
221 Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels
222 Amarcord
223 Phantom of the Paradise
224 The Wages of Fear (1953)
225 Naked Lunch
226 Mildred Pierce
227 Spaced Invaders
228 The Castle
229 Bottle Shock
230 Beat The Devil
231 Bikini Beach
232 Kiss Me Deadly
233 Strange Cargo (1940)
234 A Midnight Clear
235 North Dallas Forty
236 Paul
237 Dinner for Schmucks
238 Lost Highway
239 Out of the Past
240 Locke
241 The Outfit (2022)
242 Invasion of Astro-Monster (AKA Monster Zero)
243 Layer Cake
244 Mostly Martha (Bella Martha)
245 The Gray Man (2022)
246 Old Henry
247 Persona
248 Madagascar II
249 Kongo (1932)
250 Queen Christina
251 Come and Get It
252 Oscar
253 Anger Management
254 Kiss the Blood off my Hands
255 Swordsman II (1992)
256 Last Year at Marienbad

Not the winner I would have chosen, (in fact I think I voted against it in all the last 4 rounds) but congratulations to Raiders.

Thanks for doing all that work, @Thumper668. It was fun and frustrating in equal measures for me. I would have actually been disappointed to learn that my favorite films were shared with more than a handful of people.

That’s a pretty good description of the entire exercise for me as well. I was a little disappointed in the turnout in the final rounds, but nothing in the results really surprised me too much. And of course over the ~month it took I thought of several different ways I could have done it better. But it was a lot of fun and I’m glad y’all hung with me to the end. :slight_smile:

If not for the limitations of this forum the best approach I can think of would be to put all of the nominations in a single (select one) poll and keep halving the list for subsequent polls. I would also do them all “blind” like those last two.

I didn’t realize blind polls were an option until the final or I would have. If I had it to do over again I’d limit it to 100 nominations in a single ranked-choice poll, but I’m not sure Discourse is capable of that.

Once upon a time… A coworker/friend/tennis partner said a disc jockey/friend gave him two tickets to a movie that he couldn’t use and asked me if I wanted them. It was the public premier of the movie for the state. He said “it’s supposed to be good”. So, I went to the movie, without any information on the movie, including the type of movie. It was Raiders of the Lost Ark. I still remember my reaction to the opening scene.

A ranked choice poll or one with multiple entries battling it out might result in a more accurate result, but that isn’t really the goal. The fun of polls like this is the discussion, the weirdness of comparing two completely different movies, arguing not only why your favorite movie is awesome but also why some other movie sucks. That doesn’t happen without the one-on-one matchups.

It’s easy to lose sight of this when it’s your favorite movie getting knocked out and meanwhile two substandard movies are matched up. But really, that’s part of the fun. It would be boring otherwise.

And a big thanks for running this.

That’s probably my favorite comment on any of these threads. Thank you.

And thanks again for giving me the shortcut for multiple polls!

Very interesting—I’ll add my thanks to that of others.

I’m one of those who lost track of the process and didn’t vote in all rounds. But it was still a fun effort.