Hillary forking 3 is on its 46th page. Holy fucking shit. Is there any thread that beats it?
Easily. The “a” thread and “Lord of the Rings by different Authors” both ran far past that figure.
I was going to suggest the “If LOTR had been written by someone else” thread, but the latest Fork thread is even longer. Ike locked it on page 41.
Didn’t the a thread make it well into the hundreds?
The Most Replied to Thread: a (107 pages)
The Most Viewed Thread: If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!? (470,233 views, as of this post)
I keep wondering what there is to say about Hillary and Barack that could require 2,271 posts. But, I don’t wonder enough to actually read any of those posts.
You should reopen it.
(Go ooon. You know you want to 
)
For interesting viewing… the table of who posted in the a thread…
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/misc.php?do=whoposted&threadid=158752
edit: And the biggest contributor even has a sig to show it!
I’ll summarize it for you:
We are Right. You are Wrong.
Asshole. Bitch.
WAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!
Good times, good times.
Despite being around for both of those threads, I never posted in them. Hell, I never even opened the Lord of the Rings one (and probably not the ‘a’ one, either, bui maybe I did.)
Several of the Mafia games beat the 46 page mark.
my thoughts exactly
I never opened the LotR one either. Although, I’m surprised I didn’t post to the ‘a’ thread. Seems like the kind of mess I’d contribute to. 
Top five in each forum, by replies.
Highest in MPSIMS:
The Game Room:
The Pit (feel the anger baby):
Great Debates:
What about General Questions???
Well, I didn’t expect GQ to be the breeding grounds for long threads, but here you go:
Half of these long threads dont even go past 30 pages on my account, because i have it set to 200 replies a page. Maybe I should switch back to 50 per page, so i can get the full feel of long threads.