The OTHER School Shooting

OK, it’s not hard to understand why Dopers are focused on Northern Illinois University – seven dead, a couple dozen wounded, Mr Bus Guy’s daughter five minutes away from being one of the victims. (And I can imagine how that’s shaken her and him up!)

But there’s another school shooting story that has barely penetrated the consciousness of anyone here, based on posts – a link to it as part of a GQ answer. And that one really gets to me for a reason I’ll explain.

First, a real fast and objective-as-possible summary of what happened: In Oxnard, California (Ventura County), an eighth grader was shot in the head – twice – by another eighth grader. In class, in front of 20 other students. It happened in O.E. Green School – either a middle school or a junior high school, depending on which news report you read. The victim was Lawrence King; the alleged shooter Brandon McInerney. Both boys were either 14 or 15, again with reports giving each boy either age.

Lawrence openly avowed being gay, and dressed what I think is termed “femme” – high-heeled boots, wearing lipstick, nail polish, mascara. Though some news reports termed him a cross-dresser, the details are always what I’ve just given, not girls’/women’s clothing. So I’ll leave it to the gender-classification analysis wonks to define what that’s called. Classmates reportedly said that Lawrence and Brandon with a few other classmates had been in an argument the day before, relative to Lawrence’s sexual orientation. And that Lawrence’s being gay and how he dressed “skeeved Brandon out.” Lawrence had not lived with his parents but in Casa Pacifica, a local home for abused and neglected children. However, based on things people are not saying, it would be unwise to jump to conclusions about the parents – they were devastated by the killing, and according to a woman I know who I found out is friends with the mother, there were issues nobody was willing to make public leading to that placement.

At this point, Lawrence is completely dead – news reports earlier had listed him as brain dead but on life support while the family decided to donate his organs, which was done and the body removed from life support. The county prosecutor has said she will probably charge Brandon as an adult, with murder and use of a firearm in a homicide, and as a hate crime. There are lots of details not being given here.

One student at that school wrote in a comment to the L.A. Times coverage that he and his mother had sought to have the school install metal detectors, but that it had refused “because it didn’t want the kids to feel like they were being locked up.”

You can imagine the sorts of commentary this is getting, with every agenda imaginable being brought in. Questions that get to me: What was the atmosphere Lawrence had to deal with? How did Brandon get a gun and bring it into school? What caused him to kill Lawrence, and why? What might have prevented this, ideally without undue regimentation of anyone, and why wasn’t whatever that turns out to be done?

Now, what brings it home to me: As I’ve mentioned casually a couple of times, Barb and I are engaged in writing in a shared universe (amateur fiction, not book publishing). The plot line for one of our stories has us borrowing characters from a couple other authors to work with our own – SOP for that author group – an one of the ones we’re due to use is a gay early teen boy named Lawrence – who has gender identity issues and crossdresses from time to time. In other words, a fictional character who matches the victim here in name and sexuality/gender terms – differences of hair color and state of residence seem negligible. I’ve had this kid who’s been killed’s alter ego running around inside my head; I know how he acts and how he talks – I’m due to be writing about him. That’s really unnerving.

And, of course, there’s a second boy lost here, too. Brandon is not likely to see the light of day as a free man until at least middle age, if tried as an adult, and may be spending his entire life behind bars. What made him do it? What could have stopped him? What could have stopped him from wanting to do it?

No, it’s not a standard Pit rant. I haven’t vented righteous angerr at anyone. I haven’t resorted to scatology or the vocabulary for peculiar sexual practices. But dammit, I know that dead kid; he’s been running around in my mind, interacting with my characters. And I’m left with a sense of “What a waste!” For both boys.

Okay, tell me what I’m saying wrong here – that’s the chief purpose of the Pit these days, right?

Why didn’t we hear about it? Because it was one kid killing another kid over an idiotic reason. Even in the sad, strange world of 24 hour news, that’s not big enough. And it probably never was. I remember a pre-teen girl killed another pre-teen girl here around 15 years ago because the dead girl “flirted” with the killer’s boyfriend.

I feel sad for the family of the dead boy and I hope the kid who killed him goes to prison for a long time.

This is the first I’m hearing of this shooting. My initial reaction was anger about a disgusting hate crime against a group that it’s still OK in places to hate. But of course, I’ve filled in the blanks in my head, to get into that state of righteous outrage against the oppressors I’ve so quickly constructed in my head. Why is it so easy and automatic to assume sinister, hate-filled agendas? It could be the case here, but a complicated personal explanation is probably more likely. It seems too easy to build hatred in my heart; it’s a habit, and a disturbing one.

I’m sorry you feel a connection with the case, Polycarp. Let’s hope that there is something left in the shooter that can be fixed, and that it will be allowed to be fixed.

There was also one in Memphis One on one school shootings don’t seem to garner as much attention.

I heard about these, but only because some news agency was listing “four school shootings in one week”. I didn’t get into the details because I didn’t really have the time to follow all the links when I saw it. But I’m not sure these count for what we think of as “school shootings”. They were more like murders that happened to be a at a school. And I think they happened there because it was the easy place to find the victim.

And believe me, I’m not saying these don’t count. Here we have four more young people whose lives are either ended or changed forever. I don’t know how to prevent this. I won’t say we shouldn’t keep trying to figure it out, but I’m afraid that as long as humans are humans this kind of thing will happen. People hate and people fear and people want to hurt. I think about all we can do is keep trying to teach our children better, and keep trying to spread ripples of our own.

In one of Katherine Kurtz’s Deryni books there is a message from one of the characters that says (approximately), “Humans kill what they don’t understand.” We have to keep trying to teach that understanding, while making it clear that even if you don’t like him you don’t have the right to hurt him. Sounds completely ineffectual, even as I write it, but I don’t have any other answers. All the laws in the world don’t keep this from happening. People find ways to get around restrictions all the time. Places like the Dope help, because they let us walk in each others’ shoes, but there just aren’t enough of them.

I agree with thirdwarning. While I do believe that actions must have consequences, I hope that we can be far-sighted enough to take the opportunity to learn the possible causes of such a reaction and then hopefully can take steps to reduce the chance of recurrences.

But it still sickens me. I can’t imagine what goes through the mind of someone who who would decide to do such a destructive thing.

especially ones involving blacks…

I tend to waffle between, “There must be some reason we just don’t know about” and, “Some people are just bad.” I do lean toward the first, but sometimes it’s just depressing, you know? It still makes me sad that such young lives are being ruined. I guess that’s why loving your neighbor is a commandment, right? Because it’s so darn hard sometimes.

Portage High School just missed out on a shooting. A teen’s coworker reported a fellow teen that had a fight at work and then was saying the next day he was going to be killing people at school.

Two years ago we had two teens that tried to poison people. neither were related cases, but in each case the family had tried to get the teen mental help. The system said sorry they don’t qualify for free services. They both ended up poisoning people and going to jail. People that need to have counseling for mental imbalances, really should be a priority service all the time.

Polycarp That’s sad :frowning:

Yes its sad. But I also find it heartening that a teenage boy feels comfortable in coming out infront of his school mates and express himself in the manner he wishes to. Unheard of in my youth.

Sure sounds like a hate crime but shooting someone publicly in a school without intention of killing himself suggests the perp has other issues than just hate. Clearly one fucked up kid.

Well, in the other school shooting thread I asked if someone had any statistics on school shootings on the US compared to the rest of the world; as a means to see if the US rate is normal or abnormal (hunch points to the last). This way you can start to see if it`s a cultural thing or a universal human trait, so to speak.

I didn`t get any reply.

Well, it’s sure not common in Australia. Does that help? :dubious: Obviously you’d need to work it out per capita, too, since our population would be swallowed many times over by the US.

I can’t find any statistics about it, after an admittedly cursory search, but it’d be interesting to know.

You have one now.

Not so heartening when you see that he was beaten up on about a weekly basis by some of those school mates.

Or that nobody in authority at the school did anything about it at all, though it had been going on for months.

Sadly enough, I’ve heard about it plenty. Oxnard is just down the coast from here. It’s a bit of an odd town, a gang ridden beach community nestled between idyllic affluent communities such as Camarillo, Ventura and Malibu (well, quite a bit down the coast, but it is the next town). Pretty much all the killings I hear about in Oxnard are latino gang or drug or both related. Brandon McInerney is 14 and being tried as an adult with the special allegation of a hate crime. Personally, I have my doubts about penalties for hate crimes, as murder is a pretty friggen’ horrible thing to start out with. The alleged perpetrator is just a kid in middle school, but it sounds like he’s had a violent home life. This doesn’t mitigate the awfulness of the crime. I’ve become a bit inured to this crap as there has been a rash of juvenile murders (albeit “gang on gang”) in my normally paradiscal town of Santa Barbara. It makes me sad.

I’m curious, have any oppressed gay high schoolers struck back with lethal force?

I didn’t see that. Certainly would change my expressed feeling. Have a cite?

It’s difficult to say for sure, since often the shooters are killed in such cases, and afterwards the family reacts with threats of lawsuits if anyone were to print that.

My impression based just on news stories about this is that it may be becoming a common reaction – many of the incidents of school shootings seem to ‘ping the radar’ a bit like this.

But we had one here that was almost certainly that. This is based on personal information from children who were students at the school. The shooter did not shoot indiscriminately, but only shot 2 specific boys. Both were well known as bullies at the school, not just anti-gay, but anti-immigrant and racist as well. After shooting those 2, he just put the gun down and waited for the police to arrive.