I am disturbed that I have found so much enjoyment in imagining these combinations as I read the thread.
Mustard, gum drops, corn flakes
Oreos and milk don’t taste good together!?
Dear God…
Grape jelly, boiled hotdog, and sardines.
Vegemite, head cheese, and caramel syrup.
Anchovies, strawberries, and mayonnaise.
Pineapple, clam juice, and Spam.
Pickled beets, Brie, and miso.
:shudder:
With this thread, we really do need a barfing smiley!
Saurkraut, mint jelly, tomato soup
First of all, obviously you can’t include ingredients you don’t like at all - otherwise there’s no point to the game.
I’ll now review some of the answers, but I can’t review ingredients I can’t stand or have never tried.
I don’t know specifically about limburger cheese, but melted cheese on brussel sprouts sounds pretty good.
Wouldn’t buttermilk and cranberry pancakes taste good?
I’m not sure how you’d combine vanilla ice cream and lemonade, but I’m not sure it would taste bad.
While I can’t stand orange juice and toothpaste, I don’t think toothpaste really qualifies as an ingredient.
You’ve never put jelly on ice cream?
Would maple syrup on canned or cooked peaches be so bad?
I think this thread makes baby Jesus cry.
YES!
pickled herring, peanut butter, blue cheese.
Check out the last recipe on this page:
What, you never heard of Green Goddess salad dressing?
Whiskey, soy sauce and chocolate ice cream.
I am so freakin’ weird. In 90% of the combos listed, I can easily imagine two of the ingredients tasting good together.
About half of them I’ve actually eaten…and enjoyed it.
I can say that here in college we sometimes run out of food, and I have eaten a peanut-butter, mustard, and cheddar cheese sandwich. It wasn’t too bad…
International entry: Lutefisk, haggis and Vegamite.
Now where’s that barfing smiley?
Hmmmmm… I’ll give it a go. How 'bout liver sausage, cotton candy, and pickled okra? Or habanero hot sauce, buttermilk, and shoo-fly pie?
[sub]Ugh. I don’t feel so good right now…[/sub]