I had a D&C several years ago following a miscarriage. I assume that I was given general anesthesia, because I don’t remember most of it, but I DO remember waking up before it was over, and actually feeling it. (Remember that I was somewhat in shock because of the miscarriage, too…)
While it was not the most pleasant experience I have had, it certainly wasn’t the worst, either. I had an epidural when my first child was born (prior to the miscarriage), and it truly did block out all feeling below the waist, even though I was conscious for the entire delivery. When my second child was born (the pregnancy after the miscarriage), I chose to forego any anesthesia at all. It was more painful than the D&C had been. However, the D&C was NOTHING compared to severe ear infections…
Here’s the TMI part (STOP READING if you don’t want the details!!!)…
I could feel the doctor scraping the inside of the uterus with the instrument. While it was uncomfortable, the discomfort stopped as soon as the doctor stopped scraping. I do remember moaning to let the doctor know that I could feel it, and he finished as quickly as he could after that point. Recovery afterward was uneventful, and completely painless, although they did keep me in the hospital overnight to watch for excessive bleeding.
I do believe that an epidural would be sufficient to get through a D&C, but it does require a good anesthesiologist who knows how to do it, which may be why that’s not normally offered for a D&C. (When I was in labor with child #2, the anesthesiologist actually came by our room to announce that she was leaving for the night, and if I wanted an epidural, I would have to say so right then, before she left.)
If you know other pain control methods, they might also work for the discomfort of a D&C. When child #1 was born, and with the miscarriage, all I really knew was really skimpy Lamaze for pain control, and it really wasn’t enough. (Yes, I took the class, but the instructor spent at least one session on the Pro’s of getting an epidural. I also think that until you have experienced something close to the prolonged discomfort/pain of labor and delivery, you really can’t be prepared for it.) After one birth and one miscarriage, hubby and I learned the Bradley Method for child #2, and it was a much more effective method for controlling pain than Lamaze. It did allow me to give birth to #2 with no pain medecine, but it also helps me get through virtually any pain (physical or emotional) that I’ve experienced since then.
If I had to do a D&C again, I would ask for an epidural, or do without anesthesia completely.