At the risk of walking in the lion’s den, or Dr. Laura’s fan club, I’d like to propose that there are 2 sides to every story. Let’s look at it from Mr. Troy’s point of view, let’s call him Bob.
Bob considers himself a responsible man who genuinely loves his wife, Helen, and his daughter and his home life. He has been faithful to Helen for 8 years. Then one night he comes across this waitress – let’s call her Kathy. They become attracted to each other. He probably questions whether he should have an affair with Kathy. He finally decides to go ahead with the affair for the following reasons:
1- It would be a short love affair, and if Helen does not find out about it, it will be over in a few weeks when the hot passion wears off.
2- If Helen finds out about the affair, he can always explain that this was simply a short affair and Helen would understand and either tolerate it for a while, or ask him to stop. After all, Helen seems to be an open minded woman, having grown up with a gay Mom, and receiving love calls from Bob’s brother (see HelenTroy’s past posts).
3- If Helen, as an open-minded woman, tolerates the affair for a while and lets Bob exercise his freedom as a human being on this planet, everything is fine. If she doesn’t tolerate it and make his life miserable, he would try to get out of the relationship with Kathy as best as he can – and that would be the end of that. No big deal in this day and age. But no-one is giving enough time to Bob to get himself out of a miserable situation.
What went wrong was that (1) Helen found out too soon about the affair – before it could die from a natural death, and (2) Kathy claimed she was pregnant.
If Kathy is indeed pregnant, then a mutually agreed abortion is an option – and Bob immediately gets a Vasectomy. Kathy would probably not want to see him again. And if he starts another affair later in life, at least he won’t cause pregnancy if he does not use condoms.
Meanwhile life goes on, both Bob and Kathy become older and learn to be less jealous and give more space to each other. The daughter can grow nicely with her parents, who respect each other’s freedom. As the daughter grows up, she will most likely show less sign of HATE for Bob as a human being – unlike the participants on this thread.
I am not trying to be a troll here. All I am trying to say is that there are 2 sides to the story.
Now, please be gentle with your attacks… I know this is the Pits and I am facing a vicious audience. But is there anyone here who can see things from Bob’s point of view? I don’t think he really wants to live his family and take a one way ticket, disappearing to a far away island for a few years. But the way you all are ready to see him grilled – the far away island may be his only option.