This thread is a companion piece to the thread talking about the most beautiful actresses of old Hollywood.
IMO, Tyrone Power tops the list. I don’t think anyone else could quite compete with him, unless maybe a young Cary Grant.
I know right. He was a beautiful man. I’ve just recently paid attention. I watch many old movies, not sure how I missed him.
I don’t think I’d ever really looked at a picture of Power before. Very handsome man.
But, daaaaaang, Cary Grant. 
Check him out in Blood and Sand. There are a trio of Hollywood’s most gorgeous in that movie: Tyrone Power, Rita Hayworth, and Linda Darnell.
Tyrone Power in matador pants is a sight to see.
Errol Flynn had his issues but gee whiz, he was a good-lookin’ man.
Power and Darnell are like a master class in good looks in MARK OF ZORRO, where, what, either of them is going to have eyes for anyone else?
If your ever in a lifeboat with him you better row!
Well… too pretty for me. I’m basing this on how I’d feel if I were to put on his face. Mine’s a toss up between Darren Macgavin and Telly Savalas.
I forgot - I only recently saw Gary Cooper in a silent film. I didn’t realize he started acting so young, and he was pretty jaw-dropping. This image is from about the same era, I think.
There’s a pic of Paul Newman shirtless and smoking a cigarette. It’s how I learned I was gay.
I once saw a still from an old western of a hunk in a tub that I dreamed about for years. I regret never reverse image searching it to see if I could find out who that guy was.
This one? Yeah, he’s verra handsome.
How about Boris Karloff smoking?
[townspeople] Randolph Scott! [/townspeople]
I like him, sorta:D
Keaton’s handsomeness has always been underrated, probably because he wasn’t a leading man. But he sure was gorgeous.
There are some pictures of him as a young man where I do think he looks quite handsome. Unfortunately, a lot of pictures of him feature his trademark deadpan expression, which may, to some, make him look less attractive.
Also, he reminds me more than a little of how my father looked when he was young. 