US military in torture scandal

I am not surprised about the actions of the soldiers, as this sort of thing pops up all over, especially in war.

I agree that the soldiers involved should have been immediately arrested and brought back for public court martials to try to lessen some of the sting this is going to have internationally.

One thing I do wonder about are the photos of the “oral rape” on the site linked to earlier. Not that I think there aren’t soldiers who would do this, but I am a born skeptic. Something about some of them strike me as knockoff porn that someone forwarded over to try to get people even more mad. Not clearly so, but enough to make me wonder. Although I would suspect that if that’s really the case we’ll know soon enough, as someone somewhere will have seen it in both places and comment on it. Some of the other photos look suspicious too, but I think that’s more poor quality of the camera and so forth.

But overall though, people everywhere need to know that these actions are not something human beings should do to each other. If we are soft on these soldiers just because they are ours (for those of us on the board who can claim them in some way) we just tell the next set of people that it’s perfectly fine.

Especially with all the people like New Iskander and others out there saying the same things. It needs to stop sometime. These kind of evil thoughts and rationalizations need to be stomped out.

Nope, but you can’t eliminate people like Saddam by acting just like Saddam or allowing your agents to act just like Saddam. If that’s how you act, then even when Saddam is gone, you’re stuck with some new outfit that behaves just like Saddam. If that’s how you’re going to do things, we’d be better off, both monetarily, and in terms of bodycounts if we had done nothing at all.

Wow. so many strawmen…

First off, we are not talking about what happens to Saddam. I think we can rest assured that Saddam will not be recieving this treatment. So put away your little revenge fantasy. These guys are not Saddam. Got that? We’re talking about what happens to prisoners of war.

POW’s are not to be beaten. They are not to be tortured. The US has always said it agrees with this. There is simply NO WAY you can justify this kind of treatment. The soldiers and contracters who have done this are viscious thugs. Because only viscious thugs are capable of this kind of behaviour. They should be punished severely.

WE DO NOT URINATE ON POW’S!!

It is not just the soldiers who should be punished. It is the commanders. All the commanders. It is a chain. It has a top. His name is George Bush.

The blame does not stop there, but the legal responsibility does.

Ultimately it is you and I (the citizens of the United States) who are at fault, because we allowed it to happen. The price of democracy is that you are responsible for the actions of your government.

Stop this war now.

Tris

Here’s some more on the Arab reaction:
http://juancole.com/

As the post notes, one of the most troubling things is the (almost certainly groundless) rumor that this happened in part because Israeli security forces were called in to add their own special insights into the torture. This is pretty silly, but to the Arab street, our shrugging off of the sorts of tactics the Israeli army sometimes uses basically puts us in the same camp as them, and they of course are willing to believe the worst as soon as the Israelis are mentions.

Worse, most accounts describe hordes of intelligence people coming in and out of the prisons on various errands and unknown business, often with it not being clear who they were. In this atmosphere of confusion and impunity in the prisons, concocting anti-us propaganda with a veneer of truth is going to be like shooting fish in a barrel, because it becomes impossible to effectively deny or disprove to the public.

From this article:

WTF??!!
This is disgusting. My true only consolation is that our Brainless Leader decided to return our troops home this month. We had no business there and I object to them staying there.

Heads should roll, but I will be surprised if they do.

Except our own, of course.

Tris, thank you for your posts in this thread. I hate to be the guilty liberal, but you’re right, it’s not just them, it’s us. Who among us could guarantee we wouldn’t possibly succumb to the inherent pressures (towards evil) of being in charge of a group we feel superior to.

War is hell.

Huh?

Dominican Rep.

A.K.A. The Country with the Stupidest President EVER.

Thanks for clearing that up. I thought you might have been referring to some other Brainless Leader. :slight_smile:

For once you’re right. And that answer would be a resounding NO. As Shayna said in the first response to the first time you spouted this crap, condemning the man then wanting to perform the very same actions for which you are condemning him on him, makes you not only a hypocrite but a sick fucking arsehole too.

Saddam is a POW the same as a lot of the men in Abu Ghraib which means he too has the right to not be urinated on, electrocuted, tattooed with a knife, piled naked underneath his fellow POWs, given mock executions, etc. As these are illegal under the Geneva Convention, wishing these acts on him is morally reprehensible and really makes you no better than those performing the acts, whether they be 372nd MPC or Saddam and his generals.

The knowledge that there are sick fucks like you and the people of Fort Ashby (where most of 372nd MPC are from and where they are touted as heroes) exist in this world just show that The Straight Dope’s missionis proving unsuccessful.

Make of it what you will, but Brig. Gen. Karpinski says this story goes higher up.

It’s a shame when people define their morals and ethics by “the other guy did it first!” principle.

You know, if you can’t tell the difference between refraining for torture, and “air-conditioned spacious cells” and letting Saddam free, then the debate is WAY over your head.

Something tells me that we are going to pay for this in the form of another terrorist attack. If there was anything to enrage Arabs on the street, this will be it. They now have confirmation of everything they suspected, so we are screwed. Don’t expect the war on terror to be over any time soon now, because we’ll be paying for this shit for a long time to come now.
And to NI
For you suggesting that Saddam be electrocuted being equivalent to me wishing that Bush had to go to Iraq is not the same. The logic is twisted. There’s a difference between forcing others to risk their lives and torturing. Forcing someone to risk their life is sometimes necessary and desirable. Think about WWII, for example. Torturing is never good, and should be considered one of the things that civilized societies don’t do, like canibalism, or rape. The whole eye for an eye thing is okay, as long as you don’t cross the boundary for civilized human beings. I could equally wish for GWB to be impeached, but not for Osama to be put in an Airplaine and crashed into a building full of terrorists.

See? Its caused civilized society. We’ve been doing pretty well at being civilized, but any slip backwards should be discouraged and undesireable. Before humans used to enslave and kill other members of other tribes. I think everybody else gets that, except you. Although your more primitive instincts may react emotionally and think such a thing is just, they should certainly be caught by the more logical centers of your brain that are required to think out an intelligent argument.

On to more important things:

I think this is very important, and although this war is complete shit now, I certainly hope we actually learn something from this. But I am not sure if we will, because GWB has been the king of irresponsibility, and never admiting to mistakes. Wise people always admit their mistakes and learn from them. I sure hope we learn that although we have big guns and the most powerful military in the world, we can’t go around pissing people off, because it always comes back. You invade Iraq pissing all over the UN and the rest of the opinion of the world, you get little respect from the Iraqis.

People who did this have no respect for other human beings. They have no respect for the laws of civilization. When you hear of the British troops talking about the Americans, you begin to wonder if there isn’t something wrong with our society.

There is no possible good that can come out of Iraq not that will not require lots of lost life and further destruction. It will require us to not strike back an eye for an eye and for us to be as pacifist as possible. You can’t kill terrorists with bombs, you only make more. Why the fuck hasn’t Israel won its war against terror yet?

One one hand I agree that we should get UN troops in as soon as possible. If we stay there we are just going to keep digging ourselves into a hole. However I do believe that with a new president, or shit, at least a new philosophy and a clearly thought out plan that involves some serious thinking on what we want to accomplish and what is possible. If (please God don’t let it happen!) GWB gets reelected I hope he will fucking taking responsibility for his actions considering how he doesn’t need to get elected again.

I get the feeling that we don’t know jack-shit about what is going on there and even less about what should be expected and how to do it. All of the main people are in the greenzone and are corrupt playing power politics and sucking on the big spigot of US taxpayer money all the while people are dying and devolving into the lowest form of human life unpunished and underinvestigated by this “what, me worry?” press and society. :mad: The whole is a colossal waste of time, money, life, international prestige, and every single resource put into it. And every day the president talks about sacrifice and how there are no more rape-rooms. That’s really about all he has left now, because the torture is off the list although I wouldn’t be surprised if there was raping going on because nobody takes any responsibility for a goddamn thing in our government any more. If its bad press, its hidden away and that’s good enough because politics is all that matters. At least the news is starting to focus on the huge clusterfuck that is Iraq now.

This now confirms that unless we do some serious thinking, and taking responsibility for what the hell is going on there, then we are headed the way of Saddam. Its true. We will have replaced Saddam as the opressors of the Iraqi people.

I just wish FOR ONCE that someone would take fucking responsibility!
WHERE ARE THE FUCKING GROWNUPS??? :frowning:

Are we absolutely sure that the photos are genuine? The British ones are being questioned (wrong dress, wrong guns…).

:eek:

Holy shit, you’re thick.

On a to-the-bone cynicism level, I have to say, you are an impressive specimen…of what completely amoral, disgusting, offensive species, I am not certain, because I can’t think of one low enough on the food chain I’d want to insult by the comparison…but impressive, nevertheless.

Apparently most of the people IN them don’t deny the events happened. That’s pretty good evidence.

True, yet it did surprize me from the British (and not only because they had already one abuse scandal a few months ago.)
In my opinion the general and severely medianised demonisation of “all Muslims and all Islam” plays also a great role in this behaviour.
Once it was “communism” (and we all know enough about behaviour of the US army in Vietnam) and now it is “Islam and Muslims” inviting to look at those “brownies” as untermenschen.

But the most surprizing to me is the shocking fact that they find taking pictures of this - and even up to the point of including picturing themselves in triumphant behaviour - is seen as something absolutely normal.
Why does this make me think of pictures of the heroic colonizers of the “New world” standing in front of slaughtered bizons (not to mention the Indians). Or pictures of English colonizers in India, on the Tiger Hunt. Or pictures of colonizing EU’ers on the hunt in Africa. The same mentality drove those US soldiers to take these pictures.

A.I. (of which I am not a fan, by the way) is completely right: These are no seperated incidents at all.
In my opinion a lot of the US Heros overthere are brought into a line of thinking that sees Iraq as one very large wildpark deprived of human life other then that of their own.
Killing the savage monkeys became normal (no need to ask a question, just shoot them and if they still move after being shot, shoot again and feel proud and good that you killed one). Chasing them upto in their very homes, dragging them out together with their females and jung, surround their cities and bring on the bombs in “revenge” for the killing of a few of The Superior Human Race. That are things you find absolutely normal when considering yourself to be the Most Excellent Examples of the Superior Human Race.
The wildlife specimens that have the doubtable “luck” to be captured alive are put in the Zoo and are shareware for experimental sadism.
Nothing wrong with anything of that… Why should it be? Take some pics for the family at home for telling the grandchildren later about the Heroism in the midst of local dangerous wildlife.

Every maltreatment of prisoners is a violation of the Geneva convention.
In my opinion there is a difficulty with these mercenaries in that they form a private army that operates under its own rules. Yet if I recall well (didn’t go back reading my references) such mercenary army is bound to the local laws. Which brings up an other difficulty, because what are the local laws?
Since there was a UN resolution that gave the invaders temporarely local authority, these contractors would be operating under their laws. Which is the law of a nation that signed the Geneva Convention.

Sadly enough I must say that I think that many of the other soldiers in Iraq would tend to behave about the same. See above why. Add to this the well known abuses of the so called “Go-Pills” and it is very easy to understand how things escalate in no time.

Probably. Which brings on the question: How intense is the indoctrination and the brainwashing into dehuminize other people pictured as “the enemy of Our Great Nation” (read: nowadays Muslims and Arabs especially) in the US army today?
Next question: How is that situation in the rest of the USA?
(Read posts of New Iskander and realize that he is no single case at all. I read everywhere the same sort of posts and sorry to say so, but especially on US based Message Boards and this since several years in a row).

Salaam. A

If you’re making a point about viewing ‘the enemy’ in war and how this always happens to a defeated/occupied people, I’m sure you’re right. If you’re making a point more specific to a certain country, you’ll probably get flamed for it.

Time to summarize.

Wishing harm on Saddam makes me ‘the lowest form of life’.

Wishing harm on Bush is OK.

Case closed.