Unless you are a Miller in which case we still don’t know.
If he’s a miller I would hope that he claims miller and doesn’t just go quietly. Miller’s are town. In fact, in my opinion Miller’s should always claim Day 1 right out of the gate, but that’s just me.
@Z, I know they are. I don’t know what to say about that one. Like I said, I do have the power to stop the lynch which I think would be a power that would never be given to scum. It doesn’t rule me out as third party, but I am not expecting to make it to endgame, so I don’t know that it matters. Hell, it might not matter anyway.
Mahaloth could I get a restatement of the town wincon? Sorry, but not having it in my PM kinda blows since I can’t reference it easily.
It’s my understanding that Millers aren’t always told they they are Millers. Couple that will an investigator who isn’t always right and it makes it a bit more fun.
BTW, what’s you’re reasoning for claiming Miller right away. ISTM that could be seen as a (risky) scum move.
**FWIW, that Role as posted [[Not saying that Diver is the role he just posted]] screams “Hated Townie” to me, meaning that Diver needs one less vote than normal. **
Also, I wonder if he would tie with anyone, or if he would automatically break the tie, just by being hated… just a wag on that last part.
I’m getting very suspicious of Oredigger. He roleblocked Joey, there was no nightkill. Last night, he blocked NAF. Not because it would help the town (like blocking joey again would have), but because it would help himself. Consider: NAF has some stuff going for him. He first admitted to no wincon, strongly indicating Power Towniness. He has a Lynch Stopping power, rarely given to anything but town. Furthermore, he specifically went against the facts of the Dawn Post in order to justify his reasoning.
I’m wondering…what if Oredigger’s a cultist? Think about it–he hasn’t touched the same person twice, even when it was beneficial to do so. He made it his first priority to build town cred. NAF would be a good choice for a recruit, since he’s got a wide variety of powers. And the color fits–he could be a Madame, looking to build a troupe of whores. Or a succubus, hoping to mark everyone in the town (after all, there’s been marks of supernaturalisms). I’m not saying we should lynch him today–not when USCDiver’s a better target. But maybe toMorrow, it would be a good choice.
Anyone to second that Cucuy might be a third?
Pede, does this help you? Should we switch?
Note: the last two he’s are Oredigger, referring to his cheery claim that the doctor was awesome, despite the specific description of story as “ordinary Crimson Thorn”. This struck me as an attempt to justify his blocking decision.
Meeko, I saw your post. I highly doubt Oredigger’s scum, given that the scum already lost a prostitute. I’m just not sure he’s town, either.
Creative.
As in, non “standard”
as in, non linear.
As in Third Party.
**
Mahaloth, is there a faction known as DOOM in this game? **
Yeah, F4. I know, but at least this way, I get to ask, and make my thoughts known, at the same exact time. Town, take note of my question, please.
This just strikes me as odd and as " off " .
**
Elaborate please. **
Good luck, Meeko.
I assume it’s been delivered by now, but good luck anyway.
On the upswing, if I get my job before the next game, that might influence my post count.
We can all hope.
**I posted it around Day Two or so. Anyway:
Town wins when it kills off all the Crimson Thorns.
**
No comment.
That shouldn’t really be odd to you. The best thing for a vanilla town player to do is to get nightkilled: it means that another Town player doesn’t get killed, and hopefully, it means your death has prevented a cop/doc/mason from dying. Getting lynched is suboptimal, obviously, as it means that the town hasn’t hit scum, but its a lot better than forcing a power role to claim to save themselves, right?
Obviously, you have responsibilities to search out scum as a vanilla townie, and it’s fine and dandy to make it to endgame, but an unconfirmable (Miller) townie just doesn’t have that luxury, usually.
**FTR: I am willing to bet, that ONE DAY, you will make a win con, where if Town says the magic word, the duck will come down, pay 100 bucks, and win the game for town. **
He said we have to kill all the CTs. FOr what its worth, that means that the third party players (if any) can’t win (or win with us, which I’m fine with) if we just kill all the normal scum off.
I thought about blocking Joey again but if the CTs get to pick their killer, which is the only way I know a role block would work, then why would they pick Joey again? I didn’t think I could get lucky and pick whoever the killer would be. So I though about where I could accomplish something for sure, blocking NAF for the reasons I already outlined.
By the way I didn’t go against the Dawn post because Maholith said that Story choose who to kill. It was a reasonable assumption that if the dead CT is the one choosing then his lynch might be a reason for getting the choice.
At best, this needs a few commas. At worst, 
Italics mine.
:dubious: It says no such thing.
Um, quotes are already in all italics but I’m with you here. The Dawn color says nothing concrete about what happened. Some of you are making a lot of assumptions about last Night, bordering on PIS.