Unless, of course, the doctor has been ID’d by the mob and had been protecting him/herself these last two nights.
In which case the doctor should randomly choose between himself, pimaspinner, and possibly BM.
I did, you missed it. Today it appears I’m casting no vote but somehow managed to live. Guess I’ll see whether I was right to trust chrisk.
Hmm, NAF1138 missed it too. Post 2021.
So I did.
Here is the proper vote
14- JSexton - (FCoD, Suburban Plankton. Rysto, sturmhauke, zuma, ArizonaTeach, StarvingButStrong, Menocchio, Blaster Master, Queuing, Fretful Porpentine, pimmaspinner, Pygmy Rugger, Pleonast)
7- Fern Forest - (brewha, JSexton, kat, lakai, glee, Malacandra, Augecheek)
2- Flying Cow of Doom - (hocow, Monkey Mench)
1- MadTheSwine - (Autolycus)
1- pimaspinner (Storyteller0910)
My bad, I did miss it. It seems moot at this point since it looks like you’ll make it thru the day.
If BM and FCoD are both scum, there’s a chance that FCoD will and maintain that he survived by being the miller. This will only work if the SK and/or Vig fail at their kills. If FCoD survives and three other people die, we will know the scum is at work. Mafia does have to kill every night, right?
This is all pretty pointless anyway. I’m pretty comfortable trusting BM.
No, the Mafia doesn’t have to kill every night. Only the Vigilante has to kill every night.
–FCOD
If there’s only one two (or less) kills tonight, and FCOD survivies, then it could mean that FCOD and MB are both mafia and withheld their kill.
However, for that to be true, pimaspinner is either in on it too (nearly impossible, FCOD wasn’t on our radar and likely would not have been lynched tonight if not for pima’s claim), or got incredibly unlucky to ping BM as the vig when he’s scum claiming to be vig. Even if that is the case, we still managed to get the mafia to not kill one night, which is a major coup for us.
If FCOD survives, he, BM, and I are in the same boat. Not 100% confirmed town, but very likely and should probably be treated as such
::Checks current vote count:: YIKES! What did I miss by going to bed!
::Calls Evelyn Wood::
Yippee! A plan with like, logic and agreement and all the trimmings!
Unvote FCoD.
Vote JSexton.
Vig kill FCoD.
Frak. Stupid early-morning meetings.
Claim time. I am the Doctor. Night one, chrisK protected himself. Night Two, Mad theSwine, and there was one less kill. Last night, I self-protected again, and there was one less kill. I think the mafia had an inkling that I was the doc, and tried to kill me. (I don’t think they felt terribly threatened by my analysis.)
Correction: I supported your plan to test Cow immediately. You may have missed it, since it was the last post on the page.
Frak. Stupid early-morning meetings.
Claim time. I am the Doctor. Night one, chrisK protected himself. Night Two, Mad theSwine, and there was one less kill. Last night, I self-protected again, and there was one less kill. I think the mafia had an inkling that I was the doc, and tried to kill me. (I don’t think they felt terribly threatened by my analysis.)
Vote Jsexton
Be prepared for a another role claim. I’m guessing he is gonna claim Doc.If that happens, I think the real doc should stay quiet.
JSexton at 17 votes.
Fern Forest at 7.
Everyone else seems to be out of the running at this point.
6 hours and 30 minutes left before nightfall.
Ok. chrisk could have used that strategy to try and find the detective for protection purposes.
The rest… I don’t buy it. My vote stands for now. Why would chrisk protect MadtheSwine? Why would the mob tag JSexton as the doc? What are the odds that the doctor, as played by two different men, would target two different people and be right both times?
I guess the “safe” strategy would be to move on to Fern or Plankton, but I think the line of claims has at this point outstripped my credulity. My vote stands.
Oh, and you can end the day early with 27 votes. (I am discounting **Smitty ** and the lynch victim from the unanimous vote count.)
[wimpers] Make it stop. Make it stop![/wimpers]
I have no idea what is going on. I just find it unbelievable that the ONLY people that the town can agree on being suspicious are townies with privileges. Sheesh.
You know what plan most appeals to me right now? We nuke this town from orbit and let God, er, the GM sort it out.
And I am positively relieved that, Monday being one of our ‘late’ days, it will all be over by the time I can read this board again. Cowardly, but true.
Finally, just in case I end up being the new nominee for lynching, I’d best get my claim in now: I am the Great Pumpkin!
Sigh, why o why? Is this game always like this?
Not that I really see enough of us getting back in time to stop this but here goes:
Unvote JSexton
So do we believe him? Well let us see what we have:
Zuma and Pleonast are Masons.
Blaster Master is Vig.
Pimaspinner is a Beat Cop
FCOD is a miller
Menecchio is either citizen or Godfather.
JSexton is the Doctor.
Hmmm, either way the town loses someone important tonight. The question is, do we believe all of these people?
If we choose not to believe JSexton and it turns out he was telling the truth, we will lose the beat cop tonight.
If we choose to believe JSexton, and don’t lynch him, whom does he protect? Himself or Pimaspinner. I would say Pimaspinner because unless the doc always protects himself, he will die at some point tonight.
So I have a question. Since so many roles are out there already anyway, and the Mafia know themselves (8 we think), and there are 27 players left. 19 of whom the Mafia might not know. 7 people have claimed. Leaving a field of 12 “unknowns”. Is it worthwhile for the other Beat cop to claim, the GA protects them both for the 1 time, JSexton protects himself? Giving us another 3 nights of info to start with. As well as each beat cop getting a 4th night of info, and 1 beat cop getting a 5th night of info? Then the masons start off the vote, knowing who they are, and hopefully we can get scum? Will this let us win? Or WTF do we do now?
What a crappy time to have such a large role claim. Only 6.5 hours to go until end of the Day, and you have 7 votes to lose :eek: Hopefully people can get to their computers at work and check the thread in time. JSexton may be suspicious to a lot of people, but don’t we have a history of -testing- role claims first? I do not know how to test a Doctor effectively though. All we can tell him is to protect himself, or the others in a random choice extravaganza. And that doesn’t tell us a whole lot unless he chooses right. And it still isn’t guaranteed. We do have a Cop though, if they want to try and confirm?
That said, I shall vote FernForest and try to slip another target up there to take some of the heat off of a possible Doctor.
When does the day end if this countdown does stop?