[QUOTE=storyteller0910]
Look, I’m not sure what the point of continuing this discussion is anymore, but the fact is that you are wrong about this. There is a third alternative: that the Mafia sees no good reason to night kill Queuing because the town appears to be on the verge of lynching him just about every day.
This may not be the case, but it is a possibility. That you continue to ignore the existence of this third alternative is frankly dishonest discussion.
[/QUOTE]
I didn’t say it was the whole story. Frankly I don’t see the point of continuing this discussion today either. I’ll resume it tomorrow if I’m still alive. We all have less than a 1/5 chance of surviving the night at this point (if the SK is still going after town.) If I get taken out tonight, I hope you guys at least entertain my theories.
Kat’s posts (sorry for the unconscionable delay … I’m still working on it but wanted to get this in before nightfall)
My opinion FWIW: I think she’s town. She’s been helpful and her thinking always sounds quite reasonable to me. Of course, she wasn’t one of the more active posters, and since I have concluded that the remaining mafia are (probably) not among the more active posters, I wouldn’t say she is entirely clear of suspicion. Just mostly. Look for the rest of her posts tomorrow.
Day 1 starting p. 7 …
358 - FOS Smitty for casting the third vote for Auto
362 - trusts Rysto, CaerieD and nesta; “jury’s out” on Auto;
365 - inconsequential
Night 2
539 - supports 12-hour countdown
Day 2
595 - “In the original Werewolf thread, someone (damn, do I want to go look and see?) said that a shortened day is more beneficial to the wolves than the town;” “Since I didn’t get to vote last time due to the timing, I’m going to paranoid-ly (is that a word) get an early vote in and vote for chrisk.”
596 - clarifying above post
600 - jokes about Menocchio being Godfather
604 - troubled by
this line of reasoning results in her suspicion of Blaster Master
630 - discussion of Queuing’s suggestion of countdown period (point of favour) and request for experience (point of disfavour); reserving judgement for now.
Clarifies suspicion of FCOD "cuz you’ve got DOOM in your name, of course.’
Accuses Blaster Master of being sketchy with his trust lists
670 - doesn’t think Auto is scum
671 - “Damn lousy coding. Grrrrr…”
678 - nacho request of my earlier incarnation
689 - clarifies that millers block people, not roles; unvotes chrisk
713 - vote Pleonast based on his pressing for trust lists
771 - says blaster Master deliberately lied in his own trust list
779 - accusing Blaster Master some more
829 - “If you don’t have any other good Mafia suspicions, vote for the disruptive/unhelpful players…” provides (what I consider to be) satisfactory reasoning
835 - Defends the above reasoning with Auto as an example, pointing out that she doesn’t mean to imply that Auto is beng disruptive
837 - inconsequential
879 - inconsequential
893 - [in the context of a discussion about Pygmy Rugger saying that three posters said they’d be away when they said no such thing], points out Pygmy Rugger’s activity thus far (day 1: no contribution; day 2: vote for chrisk/JSexton, drinking posts); asks for explanation
I don’t buy this. Most of the “sides” that have been drawn up so far have been town vs. town. (For the record, I do think Aguecheek is scum, but it’s perfectly possible for a townie to think this and be wrong.)
[QUOTE=Pygmy Rugger]
Glad to see you got all Kat’s triple digit post counts laid out.
[/QUOTE]
To my credit, I’ve read up to 1446 and she hasn’t posted again yet in Day 2. This thing is LONG.
**Cowgirl ** you will have to wait to finish that. Sorry to stop you mid analysis, but this round is over.
*And, another day closes on the little port town of Doperville.
The gallows has become a regular fixture of town life these days, and most people wake up in the morning expecting to be wrongly lynched by the day’s end. Life has gotten rough for the town, mob rule is getting worse, and it seems as though there is no one who will be able to survive the insane Serial Killers attacks. But after much debate the town decided to put Aguecheek’s claim of cop to the test.
“SO WHAT!” they shouted. “If he is a cop he is awfully bad at his job, he only gets things right 50% of the time!”
Some fought back and said that a bad cop was better than no cop, but this minority viewpoint lost out, and Aguecheek walked to the gallows with his head held high, knowing he did his level best to help his team. He died with dignity and a smile on his face.*
Can I keep the badge? Huh? How 'bout the nightstick?
Guys?
Ah well, two nights of dead townies rather than dead Mafia. I’m happy with that. To paraphrase others who’ve gone into that long dark night ahead of me:
Hey, what do you know? My scumdar isn’t completely useless after all.
I have to compliment Aguecheek on his role-claim, though. It had just enough truth in it to confuse the town, and made late enough in the Day to force us to make a poor choice.
[QUOTE=NAF1138]
Now that we are down to many fewer players, I was thinking about taking a day off of the day cycle. What do y’all think?
[/QUOTE]
Fine by me.
