Okay, the first time I find Aguecheeck pushing for Queuing, it’s at the end of Day Two. He votes for Queuing in post 1530, after Queuing’s vote count has gone down to 5 (after hitting a high of 11, I think) and Gadarene’s at 14 votes, and about 7 hours left until Lynch Time. (Someone let me know if there’s a post prior to this in which Aguecheek speaks out against Queuing.)
At least 4 players announced their belief that Queuing was probably town after that vote by Aguecheek (and a couple before that vote as well), at the end of Day Two and beginning of Day Three.
Aguecheek goes after him again on Day Three in post 1702. A couple more people post pro-Queuing-as-Town sentiments. At this point, Aguecheek seems to drop the Queuing angle completely, posting about the people nesta had refused to vote for or FOSed.
He makes an insinuation in post 1945 about Queuing’s Mafia estimate. At this point, Queuing is not in danger of being lynched any longer, but it could conceivably be a warning to not be so sure of the numbers.
In post 2760, StarvingButStrong asked where the Queuing suspicions went. This is about the same time Queuing got into the Math Discussion with Malacandra and Lakai.
Then, suddenly, in 2798, Aguecheek’s jumping back onto the Queuing wagon. A couple of people vote for Queuing after this point. So, it’s possible that Aguecheek geuinely thought that Queuing was SK, but it doesn’t look like a “look-good-for-the-Townies” vote on an already-doomed Mafia. (And I didn’t even get up to the fake role-claim before I reached this conclusion.)
Anyway, since I compiled all this info, here it is for you all to read, in case any of it is actually helpful, or you’re really really bored while giving your “refresh” button a workout.
Oh, and vote Pygmy Rugger. Based on the whole Queuing vs Pygmy Rugger vibe I got Yesterday (game yesterday), which made me suspect, rereading it all after Nightfall, that one or the other is Mafia.
And yes, I did have to go through all of that effort, to get it straight in my head, because I can’t even remember what happened and how yesterday (real life yesterday).