I’m with you Boss sexton
And just where are you getting this meat? HMMM? :dubious: Perhaps from Rysto’s rotting corpse? Boss sexton wouldn’t have started a campaign to kill the Alpha wolf had he been one himself.Only a fool or a werewolf would lie suspicion on **Jsexton **at this point and I don’t think you are a fool.One And Only Wanderers gets my vote.
just had a reread and I’m not suspicious of Jsexton anymore. If he’a a wolf then that Menocchio vote was inspired.
I suspect Rysto was targeted for being the first to vote Menocchio. maybe the wolves forgot the day start and thought theyd got themselves a seer
Also Ogre - are you mad? I hope the Seer lays damn low. They’re the most important resource we have.
unvote Jsexton
Um…I “stand up” for Wanderers where? Exactly? I’m quoted in Enginerd’s post about Wanderers, but that doesn’t make me implicit in any anything said in his post.
So misplaced, it never actually existed. 
And about Mennochio…watching a bandwagon go by and not getting on it, while rationalizing that action with general strategy on the random first day, is a bit different than passionately defending Mennochio’s honor. The timing of that particular WAG sucked, as he was rightfully lynched shortly thereafter. Which is what prompted my post that no one has responded to yet.
Somewhere in the wee hours of the morning, it all came to me in a flash! The werewolves, the townspeople, all of the strategies (so ridiculously transparent), and the perfect method to root out all of the evil-doers. Unfortunately, I was sloppy drunk at the time, and I can’t remember a damn thing now. except a vague notion that it had something to do with raisins.
Anyway, back to the lynching at hand…
I’m nowhere close to being ready to call someone out, but I have a few thoughts:
As was pointed out before, the fact that **jsgoddess **escaped the rope yesterday does not mean she is innocent. I need to carefully reread the first couple of pages of posts to see what I can find there, armed with the knowledge gained overnight.
**JSexton **seems awfully eager to stir things up early in the morning. And one item that caught my attention: he is the only person so far to have explicitly stated he is not a werewolf. I don’t know that I want to draw too much from that at this point, but I do find it interesting that he feels the need to defend himself at this point.
That’s all I have for now; I’ll be back once the rest of the town has shaken off its collective hangover.
Not necessarily. A Werewolf could try to lynch another Werewolf to get exactly that reaction. I’m not saying JSexton is a Werewolf, just that what you say doesn’t make him not one.
OK, I’ll respond…
I don’t think it’s so much a fine line as a big fat gray area. There are about half a dozen names that I would have thought would have come up before Rysto, so I don’t think it’s a matter of how vocal you are, but rather what you say and who you say it about. I don’t think there is any way to be “safe” at this point.
…which is useless, unless we get his/her discoveries. Somehow. Some way. Through channels. Whatever.
Yep, sure.
Since there seems to be a general sentiment that silence=doom, I would expect a werewolf to have made a fair number of posts, but not to have said much in them for fear of drawing attention. They would have to vote, of course, but would just do so as part of a bandwagon and without much fanfare. By that standard, my vote is: Kat. (For now.)
but it’s only day two. if theyre gonna come out, they can come out later with multiple confirmed statuses on people/
Ok, Jsexton votes for you, then a couple posts later you unvote him?
I don’t have any evidence to support him being a wolf, but if he voted for me I might view him a bit more suspiciously. Maybe that’s just me.
Do votes carry over from day to day unless changed? I thought we each vote once a day.
There are a couple people we haven’t heard from in quite a while, are they liable to be replaced as lurkers? What’s the rule on that?
you have one vote, but it can be cast, and then changed if you wish
I realize Werewolves are gonna vote for each to be deceptive and may have done so already,but to call out the Alpha wolf seems an awful bold(and stupid) strategy.
Votes don’t carry over - jsgoddess, for example, starts this day with a clean slate of no votes and not the 3 she ended up with at the end of the first Day.
You can change your vote during a Day, but you can’t vote for more than one person at a time.
And we’ve seen that JSexton is quite skilled, so we wouldn’t think he’d do that.
I don’t think he’s a Werewolf, but I don’t really have any proof for that.
I think you only need to vote once during the Day Phase, but people can vote and change their vote innumerable times until RT calls for the final vote. Some people vote early and often; some of us like to wait until the end.
I wonder this too. Part of me would like to go on with my decision to lynch the person with the lowest post count, a policy that will probably start being a bad idea once this game gets further along. I do think there should be some in-game penalty for hiding the in the shadows and not saying anything. Not taking a risk? OK, I’ll make it riskier for you by voting to lynch you.
Thoughts on this policy? I mean, granted, people were onto something when they voted for Menocchio, though I still think it came down to JSexton’s theory that the third person in the bandwagon is guilty. Seems like that could just as easily have been false. Did the people who voted for him really think he was the bad guy, or was it a lucky guess/ gotta vote for someone so this guy is as good as any kind of a thing?
I’m really not sure what to think at this point.
One thing I do know is that we haven’t heard from Miller in 10 days! The guy has almost 18,000 posts!
I guess a case could be made for lurkers being werewolves, but a case could also be made for overzealous posters trying to blend because they’re wolves. So, given the lack of any great evidence, I’m going to vote for Miller.
Ooops.
i really should be viewing this on a computer, not scrolling around on my little symbian phone. I did mean
Enginerd but mis read. Sorry old bean :o :smack:
Jsexton had nothing to do with jsgoddess’ bandwagon. Miller cast the first vote for her, and Jsexton never voted for her at all, although he did suggest that the rest of us should vote for whoever was already on a wagon.
I doubt that anyone who cast the first few votes for Menocchio is a werewolf, as losing the Alpha is a big disadvantage for them. The status of later voters is less certain (yes, I realize this includes me), as they may be werewolves who were covering their asses.
I am suspicious about One And Only Wanderers, for the same reasons already mentioned. But I prefer to wait before casting any votes.
Just FYI, these are the three lurkingest posters as of now. I didn’t include unfinished symphony because he (she?) was added after the first round, and seems to be contributing and not laying low.
Miller
Richard Parker
moonstarsun
You three are on notice for non-participation. Come out into the light!