I noticed that. I looked askance at it, as well.
Not at all surprising coming from that poster (I Love Me Vol. I).
Last time I did that there with a newbie who appeared to be on the edge of the fuzzy line, I got massively excoriated.
the general purpose of this thread is to note established Dopers
There doesn’t appear to be anything in the OP which states or implies that.
There doesn’t appear to be anything in the OP which states or implies that
Read (or at least skim) the thread. It’s evolved into what I described.
And, as others have already noted, when someone posts a “look at this new poster’s idiocy/weirdness/trollishness” post in this thread, there is nearly always a reaction of “we have a different thread for that.”
But there’s also been some pushback to putting every slightly odd newbie post into the trolls thread and potentially scaring off a decent poster.
The poster in question was extremely obvious and the troll thread was the right place for them. But I’m OK with mentioning a new poster in this thread when it isn’t such obvious spam/trolling.
It’s evolved into what I described.
I’ve followed the thread from its inception; I don’t see evolution, it’s just that most
of the posts are about long time posters.
There’s always the option of leaving a new poster alone (until they demonstrate
their unsuitability for the board).
I thought it was more along the lines of posters who are normally cool and reasonable having an uncharacteristic brain fart. That said, I don’t think any thread has had more drift and hijacks so it’s difficult to criticize.
Our Goal: If you have a beef with a poster, or a poster’s post that is absolutely Pit-worthy, but not worth it’s own thread, no need to clutter up the Troll thread unless you think they’re an actual troll. Perhaps it’s a long time poster (without a Pit thread) who’s put their foot in their mouth. Perhaps they’ve said something that for anyone else, you’d consider it in character, but think they were drunk/high/off their meds!
Bolding added just now by me. Yeah, the emphasis is on known figures who are acting out of character, who DON’T already have a Pit thread.
Note, I don’t own this thread more than any other OP, and I’m speaking to my own intent as a poster, not a Mod.
You may now disagree with me, won’t be the first or the last time for that.
Last time I did that there with a newbie who appeared to be on the edge of the fuzzy line, I got massively excoriated.
There’s no fuzzy line this time. There’s absolutely no innocent explanation for this poster. Posting a phone number for strangers saying there is something “crazy” to tell them is almost as blatant as a request for someone to help a prince get their gold out of Nigeria.
And I’ll note they’ve returned to the thread, though I don’t expect a satisfying explanation for their earlier stunt. Maybe something like “I was being silly” or some other attempt to blow it off.
They’ll probably post a link next time.
Popped up again 35 minutes ago.
@Locrian, curious why you seem to think that poster is for real. It’s obviously a scammer.
I’ve managed to completely miss this poster.
You haven’t missed much: try tinydancer555
Here’s a link to the thread. I’ll put it in code tags so it won’t backlink here, though it also won’t be clickable, so you’ll have to copy-and-paste.
https://boards.straightdope.com/t/hey-everyone/1035095
I’ve put a hook over here so we can continue the convo where the consensus seems to suggest it belongs.
I’m going to “formally” open a convo here on tinydancer555, a newbie that’s pinging lots of troll / scammer radars. They’ve already gotten a multi-post and multi-poster shout-out in the “What were you THINKING” thread, with most commentators there saying that convo better belongs here. So far it’s been mostly cagey non-committal one liners. Plus an attempt to post a phone number that was quashed by reports to the Mods.
Follow that lead or not as you will.
I’ll add one that does belong here. In my rabies thread, a long time poster stopped by to drop a random racist joke about “yellow fever”. What was he thinking?
That he wanted to expand beyond being a pissant about acronyms? Because if it were only that, he’s already got a pit thread:
ILMVI, please, for the love of DOYC, stop derailing threads to gripe about acronyms (or, for that matter, legalese you don’t understand). I have gotten so sick of you disrupting threads over your pet peeve that I have had you on ignore for months now (honest: that’s the only reason, I can’t stand your moaning about acronyms). But apparently even that’s not enough. Because every time you drop a squat in a thread over someone’s use of an acronym (and so frequently in situations where its meaning…