I’ll third Matt’s. We’ve been bying these on a regular basis for about 6 months now. They’re nice and soft and filled to the max with chocolate chips. The Peanut Butter variation are also very good. Ten seconds in the Mic and they taste and feel just like home-made.
Best cookie I have tried so far!
Archway Homestyle Dutch Cocoa . . . hands down. 
I’m a big cookie fan, though, so I also love Oreos, Keebler Fudge Stripes, Entenmann’s Soft Chocolate Chip, etc. And pretty much the entire Pepperidge Farm line. 
You Milano people need to put those down and try the REAL best Pepperidge Farm cookie: the ambrosia that is Mint Brussels cookies. I wish PF would push THOSE instead of making seventeen flavors of Milanos, which are quite so-so IMHO. I have a hard time finding plain Brussels, much less Mint Brussels, but the Milanos are everywhere.
Pepperidge Farm Mint Brussels cookies are DA BOMB!!
I love Rippin’ Good Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies. They’re too cheap to make the shelves at the high-end supermarkets, and since they’re not a major brand they’re rare at regular groceries, but when I can find them they’re mmm-mmm good. Best pack of cookies you can get for 99¢.
I’ve pretty much eliminated cookies from my diet. :rolleyes: However I still like them. I like Trader Joe’s triple ginger cookies. They have pieces of crystallized ginger in them.
Now on the subject of store bought cookies…I am one of the few people who think Oreos are overrated. The chocolate cookie is not very chocolaty and the filling is like sweetened Crisco.
Nutter Butter Peanut Creme Patties. Any other brand of cookie, I can buy and take home and eat a couple and forget it. With these, however, I end up eating just about the holw package within 2 days. So I have to make myself not buy them. They are too good.
What a great name for a band!
They could have songs with titles like:
“Why don’t we do it in the road . . . with chocolate chips?”
“Don’t you want somebody to love . . . smothered in oreos?”
“Don’t you want somebody to love . . . smothered in oreos?”
OP by lavenderlemon
Eewww…no! maybe someone I hate, though. (see my last post) 
Featuring the hit single, Dunk me in your lovin’ milk
I love Nutter Butters. Whole packets are gone in minutes.
Nah, all of y’all are wrong. The absolute best Pepperidge farm cookies are the Geneva ones. Dark chocolate on a short bread type cookie with walnuts sprinkled on top. Yummmmm. I can eat a whole bag in one sitting…
Keebler Fudge Shoppe Grasshoppers.
As far as I am concerned, the Girl Scouts are obselete. For many years, I tolerated their existence because they dispensed Thin Mints. But Grasshoppers are cheaper, and available year 'round. The Girl Scouts can now evaporate into a fine mist of earnest piety and civic pride for all I care.
Probably just a triple-post. Note the time difference is only a minute or two between…
My cookie’s a Pecan Sandie.
At the risk of offending the anti-Sam Walton crowd, Sam’s Club used to have blueberry white chocolate chunk cookies that were my favorites. Haven’t seen them in many years.
Currently, I’m going with any sort of Thin-Mint style cookie.
Not sure if this counts, but I love the packaged cookie dough rounds that you just place on the cookie sheet and bake. My favorites are the ones with the mini peanut-butter cups in them. Mmmm. I cook them three at a time in my toaster oven.
As for boxed cookies, I’m pretty partial to E.L. Fudge.
It was… COOKIE PORN! boom chicka wow wow Nah, it was just a double post.
Susie Derkins, your name is fantastic!
Final note: My mom makes the best chocolate chip cookies anywhere in the entire universe.
Nutter Butter Wafers with the pb cream inside. Not the regular peanut-shaped cookies, the thin crispy wafer ones.
Dare Butter Creme Cookies. So rich, they make your teeth hurt just smelling them. 3 will do me for one sitting, but my lord, they’re sooo good.
Unfortunately, I can’t find them down here. 
Or Pirate Peanut Butter Cookies; for which I cannot seem to find a link. Nutter Butters taste like drywall compared to these.
Unfortunately, I can’t get them down here.
w00t! I win a cookie!
Heh, I thought the name sounded familiar.
Susie, Calvin wishes you the best. Hobbes too.
I live about 45 minutes from the Rippin’ Good outlet store in Ripon, WI. Used to live just outside Ripon, in fact, and whenever anybody came to visit us we always had to take them to the cookie store. And just about every grocery store around here has a wide selection of Rippin’ Goods. Mr. S likes the Mint Cremes, refrigerated if you please.
Jealous yet?