It occurred to me while watching “The Island of Dr. Moreau” with Michael York than I have never liked him in anything. I’m sure he’s a perfectly nice guy, it’s just something about the way he acts that rubs me the wrong way.
There are quite a few others whose names I can’t quite recall at the moment, who are competent actors and who have played a wide variety of characters – most of whom are loathsome – but two that stand out in the “give me the creeps” category are Zach Grenier and Zeljko Ivanek.
Catherine Zeta-Jones. Can’t explain it…is it her voice? Her manner? Her eyes? I don’t know. But something about her is like nails on a chalkboard to me.
Ashton Kutcher. I pretty much dislike every character he’s played. With one exception: I really enjoyed No Strings Attached and I liked his character in that movie.
John Travolta. His worst performance IMO was as a General in A Thin Red Line. Utterly wrong and unbelievable in the part. Have to admit that I liked him in Blow Up though.
I’m sure I’ll catch hell for this, but I can’t stand Bill Murray. Hated him on SNL, hated him in just about everything I’ve seen him in. I might like him in The Razor’s Edge, from what I’ve heard. I did like him in Groundhog Day, possibly because in that film, at least at the start, he’s supposed to be an annoying character.
But, nope, didn’t care for him in the Ghostbusters movies, or Caddyshack, or Stripes, or even Lost in Translation. I could’ve done without his segment in Zombieland.
Christian Slater and John Cusack. Never saw either of them in a movie I liked. Their presence in a movie has been enough to make me skip it for decades now. I think I dislike Slater more, as even a still photograph makes me want to punch him in the taint until he bleeds from the ears.