I’ve only seen the Tiffany’s one online. I sent the link to my friend, whined appropriately and she told me about the Nordstroms one. I liked the Nordstoms one and the cheapy, impulsive purchase side of me came out and I got it.
Haven’t stepped foot in an actual Tiffany’s to see how they match up. That would be like a recovering alcoholic stepping into a bar. 
Haha I was in Tiffany’s last week ~ every time I walk by it I go in, if only to gaze at the Tiffany Diamond - it’s gawjuss!
sigh
I have the necklace that goes with #2! I say #2! Then you can lend it to me…
The silver from Tiffany has a different sheen than regular silver, and it is much more substantial. I say go for it and treat yourself!
I told my husband he’s lucky because my fingers are too small for rings and my wrists are too small for bracelets and watches. Of course that would mean more if on the rare occasions I got jewelry, it came from Tiffany’s instead of Wal-Mart. 
The first time I read your question I thought for sure that you, Lolo, were from LA. Every single person who can afford it owns at least one type of those bracelets. Maybe on the East coast they aren’t as popular. Some even have matching necklaces. Crazy trend. I guess the second one is the best (they are all very pretty) but I’d be looking for something more unique.
I got my girlfriend #2 for her birthday. She is very fashion concious and I figured that if she were going to have something from Tiffany’s she would want the name on it. I was right 
Anyway, get #2 because everyone will know where you got it and you can engrave the back if you like. The plain ones are just boring and the heart is too cutesy for most occasions. The round one is classy and goes with absolutely everything. (all according to Sarah…I have no taste:cool:)
I like those bracelets but they’re everywhere in NYC. I’ve seen 'em elsewhere on the east coast, too. However, I’ve never seen the bracelet trishdish linked to (with the round beads) and I like it a lot - I’d go for that one.