Why are silent farts so evilly foul?

When someone exterminates all nearby life with their arse it is known as an SBD (Silent But Deadly)

Why are the silent ones so deadly?
Interestingly - it is still possible for the fart’s owner to revel in it as if it were the divinest scent on earth, despite it’s murderous power.

Are you actually looking for a factual answer on this??
BTW-My farts stink. I know they stink. They have never smelled good to me…Maybe I’m missing out…

I am sure one exists.

(I really am looking for a factual answer)

This doesn’t seem like a factual question to me. Apparently, standards have been loosened around here lately.

WAG…because they are almost pure gas. The loud ones are mostly swallowed air.

Probably the same reason a quiet engine feels more powerful than one with a blown muffler: it’s more powerful than you’d guess from the noise.

I am sure standards are as they always were. Why if I remember rightly - last time I did a search on ‘fart’ in GQ there were posts dating back a long way.

I am SOOOO glad the SDMB didn’t let me post what I was about to post!

(the 60 second rule blocked me)

Well now ALL of us want to know what you were gonna post. So let’s have it! :slight_smile:

I think it just seems that way because you haven’t received the audio warning and had a chance to brace yourself.

Alright, in an effort to ferrit out the truth, here’s my anecdotal evidence:

It’s not the silent ones that stink particularly, it’s the farts that burn your ass on the way out that really stink.

Ok, I won’t post it as-was. But I will explain.

I was about to post a witty reply to Herman Cheruscan’s post about a mispelled word. After I pressed submit I checked with MS Word, only to find out that the word was spelled correctly afterall. I came back to eat humble pie - and saw to my relief the ‘no more than one post every 60 seconds’ spiel.
boring eh. I bet you wish I kept quiet afterall.

I would say Reeder is nearest to the mark on this one. Noisy farts imply a large volume of gas: mainly swallowed air or methane from vegetable material such as brassicas or beans which are high-fibre and passing rapidly through the gut - both of which possibilities are relatively odorless. Quiet ones imply a small volume of gas, probably from decay of static protein material in the gut, which smells bad.

I always thought SBD farts were quieter because they have a higher moisture content. They slide out without the drag of a dry fart and because of the moisture, the smell in more concentrated. And you have a higher probability of skidmarks in your shorts too.

Um, cite?

Actually, never mind. I’m sure I don’t want to know where you picked up that idea. :lame winking smilie:

Oi, I know of what you speak, Lobsang.

It’s simply a matter of evolution. Over the eons, the forefathers of our species which emitted especially foul and mal-odiferous feats of gaseous prowess in an audible way were mercilessly slain, or sometimes (very occassionally) ostracized in such a manner that they would be unable to procreate further. Those lucky enough to posess the talent of emitting an uncommonly noxious cloud in a silent manner lived on, and passed the ability onto their offspring.

Today in our civilized world, we have come to the point where we might be proud of such a feat, and during social events such as the Superbowl (save for mixed-company), we might be apt to take credit for such a transgression. But make no mistake about it… the raised eyebrows, watering eyes, and feelings of discontent and unspoken anger are more a testament to the original feelings of destroying the malefactor than your ability to provide it without cost.
:sunglasses:

Between this and the **Velocity of Fart ** thread from way back… we dopers have an obsession with flatuence.

The bad smell of a fart is caused by bacteria, which have been dining and it is their waste that causes the methane and the smell. As stated a loud fart is usually swallowed air with possibly some methane mixed in. A small one is pure methane caused by those smelly little germs (a condensed version, you might say.) This also explains why shit smells so bad.

:frowning: [sup]Why did I feel it was necessary to contribute this piece of knowledge?[/sup]

Uh, Thanks kniz. (why isn’t there a nauscious smilie?)

I have yet to see anyone post a cite showing that loud farts are caused by swallowing air. Nor has there been one posted showing that silent ones are caused by methan gas rather than air.

Cite, please?