Why did you break up with your ex?

I think most people say, “it just didn’t work out” because they don’t want to have to go into the sordid, gory details on how their relationships went awry.

I’ve only had a few serious relationships myself, and in all but one I was the dump-ee. In the one where I initiated the breakup it was abrupt and ugly. My girlfriend had become less affectionate, we weren’t having sex anymore, and she began to take advantage of me because I had money and transportation and she didn’t. The lazy bitch hardly ever worked, and whenever she wanted something or wanted to go someplace she called me up and asked me to take her there (and in many cases pay for what it was that she wanted). She began criticizing me for the stupidest things and we got into lots of shouting matches because of this. She was also appallingly dishonest and expected me to do the same. She got mad at me once because a store over-refunded me by five dollars and, being the honest guy that I am, I gave it back to them. She told me that I should have kept it and let the employee deal with the consequences and learn from his/her mistake. Okay, whatever. :rolleyes: I could go on with dozens more (and less mild) examples on how she turned my life into a living hell, but I know some people don’t like reading long posts here.

The final straw came when I was helping her move across town to a new apartment. It was late at night and one of the neighbors from the downstairs complained about the noise we were making, so I told her about this, hoping she’d take the hint that we should either be quiet, or come back and finish in the daytime when other people aren’t trying to sleep. Instead she snapped back and me and told me to go face up to the guy and tell him to back off. I told her I wasn’t going to do this and that we should respect his need for quiet. At this point she called me a wimp. I lost it and I screamed “F*CK YOU!!!” in her face and left her to finish moving her stuff into her apartment. I never did see her again. Why I didn’t break up with her months sooner than I did I’ll never know.

I’ll just limit my comments to the two longer relationships. Both of these relationships lasted 5-6 years.

#1 got the axe for discouraging me to go to school. He seemed to have little desire to improve his lot in life and was content to have shelter and a meal or two a day. Talk about what we would do the next day, next week or next year didn’t interest him much. He had a degree and I was suspicious he wanted me barefoot and pregnant. He’s a nice guy and we still talk occasionally. He claims he’s still pining for me (some 15 years later). I don’t believe that either. He’s currently living in a shanty, occasionally working and mostly goofing off, much like our time together.

#2 got the axe for excessive alcohol intake. I told him that his drinking was becoming a problem for me and when it got to be too much of a problem I would leave. I left. He called drunk begging to get back together, admitting he had a problem. I told him if he would go to ONE AA meeting I would come back. He sent cards, messages, flowers and messengers to persuade me to come back. I just asked him if he went to a meeting yet. He got another girl instead. He called to say she didn’t even drink! Later he said she had come over with her own bottle of Schnapps (sp?). I guess Schnapps is more of a dessert than alcohol. I never talk to this one and have no desire to.

Breaking up with both of them was harder that the flip comments above indicate- these two are from a very long time ago. In the end, though, I made the right decision and have no regrets. Both had great qualities and are good guys, but not right for me.

I’ll just limit my comments to the two longer relationships. Both of these relationships lasted 5-6 years.

#1 got the axe for discouraging me to go to school. He seemed to have little desire to improve his lot in life and was content to have shelter and a meal or two a day. Talk about what we would do the next day, next week or next year didn’t interest him much. He had a degree and I was suspicious he wanted me barefoot and pregnant. He’s a nice guy and we still talk occasionally. He claims he’s still pining for me (some 15 years later). I don’t believe that either. He’s currently living in a shanty, occasionally working and mostly goofing off, much like our time together.

#2 got the axe for excessive alcohol intake. I told him that his drinking was becoming a problem for me and when it got to be too much of a problem I would leave. I left. He called drunk begging to get back together, admitting he had a problem. I told him if he would go to ONE AA meeting I would come back. He sent cards, messages, flowers and messengers to persuade me to come back. I just asked him if he went to a meeting yet. He got another girl instead. He called to say she didn’t even drink! Later he said she had come over with her own bottle of Schnapps (sp?). I guess Schnapps is more of a dessert than alcohol. I never talk to this one and have no desire to.

Breaking up with both of them was harder that the flip comments above indicate- these two are from a very long time ago. In the end, though, I made the right decision and have no regrets. Both had great qualities and are good guys, but not right for me.

The significant ones…

#1: Didn’t know what to look for in a girlfriend and there turned out to be very little chemistry between us. And I moved to a different part of the state.

#2: I didn’t fulfill what she was looking for in a man. I didn’t respect myself enough and put up with any bullshit she gave me, which helped her to lose respect for me. In the end, I discovered I liked relationships that weren’t so abusive.

#3: Seemed really immature given that she was quite older than me. Reinforced by the fact that she totally went ballistic when I told her I didn’t think it was working.

#4: We stopped making an effort to make it work. We were both tired, the passion was gone, and both depressed due to outside factors, but that unhappiness fuelled our mutual dissatisfaction.

#5: She finally decided to marry her fiance.

#6: She turned what I thought was a casual encounter in to a full-blown relationship, which came as a surprise to me since she lived in a different part of the country than me. Was just a bit too hyper-intellectual. (Read: I felt like a dope around her.)

#7: Another long-distance thing I wasn’t looking for. I couldn’t find a job in the part of the country she was not willing to move from. Also, she was a little needy and immature.

The one that probably hurt the most was when I FINALLY realized she was never going to leave her husband.

Well, the last one never really had the chance to develop into a real relationship per se, but it’s also the only one where I’ve been the dumper instead of the dumpee, so it’ll have to do.

There were actually loads of reasons why it didn’t work out. The most obvious, but ironically the least significant, reason was that he lives in England and I don’t, and neither one of us had the resources or willingness to change that. (Actually I’d love to live in England, but I am totally broke, and my career options, at least in the field I want to be in, would be virtually non-existant. So it’s not an option for me.)

I also just wasn’t in love with him. I was very comfortable with him, and cared for him a great deal, but there was no spark for me. He was so head over heels, and given my track record with those folks that I was head over heels with, I figured I’d give it a chance and see if the spark wouldn’t develop over time. It didn’t.

He also had loads and loads of insecurity and neediness issues. Even though he denied it when I talked to him about it directly, I always got the sense that it wasn’t me that he wanted, he just wanted some girl, somewhere, who he considered “safe” (hey, I’m 4000 miles away, I can’t hurt him, right? :stuck_out_tongue: ) so he wouldn’t have to be “alone.” He also seemed to have this glorified image of me in his head which actually had nothing to do with who I really am. So this was really the dealbreaker, more than anything else. I couldn’t shake that sense of being an object or symbol rather than a really real person to him. So after a while I decided my instincts were crying out for a reason.

There was also the fact that I had to break up with him THREE TIMES before he got it. This pretty much served to verify that I was doing the right thing. That, and the fact that when he finally DID get it, he turned into a petty childish asshole (“I’m going to tell you who you really are, and it doesn’t matter what you think you are, you’re wrong and I’m right.” :rolleyes: )

That said, he eventually apologized, after having several weeks of no contact at all to realize that I was seriously PO’ed and would not have anything to do with him unless and until he realized what a jerk he’d been. So we’re talking now, although calling us “friends” at this point is still a bit of a stretch, since I really don’t feel like I can trust him anymore.

Blah.

She remarried. I figured it was time for a divorce.

#1 - lived together for 3 years, engaged for 2 years.
I didn’t like his ex-wife always turning up, didn’t like his new girlfriend (“no, really baby, I’m just helping her over a rough time”), didn’t like the constant drug use, didn’t much care for him as a person.

#2 - Together for 3 years (ah, a trend), engaged, had the dress picked out and everything - he moved to NC for a job and promptly picked up with an ex-girlfriend who would answer his phone when I called. (“no, baby, really, she’s just here to help me wrap your Christmas presents, I swear”). That was too bad, because I really, really liked him.

He broke up with me. :slight_smile:

I never get to break up with anybody because I am Miss Fix-It! But I do like the place he and I are now. He makes a better friend than a boyfriend, and we still have tons of fun. But now I’m allowed to do whatever I want! (And by whatever I want, I mean see whoever I want. And bug him!)

I have no idea. It happened last night:

5:30 D arrives
5:31 Engage in passionate making out
7:30 Decide to go eat
8:30 Arrive back home
8:31 Engage in passionate making out
9:30 D informs me that she likes me very much, that she’s had a crush on me since we met and that she considers us a couple (would be hurt if I saw others) and thinks about me all the time and has so much fun when we’re together and it feels so good and is not ready to be in a relationship.
9:45 Bruce_Daddy shows her the damn door.

Needless to say today I have a bad case of whiplash and a hangover today. I’m counting the minutes to 5:00 because I need a cocktail.

Hmmmm…found out I was Wife #2 and not Wife #1. Found out he lied about where he was from. Found out he lied about how old he was. Found out he lied about having a younger brother. Found out he basically made up everything I thought I knew about him.

And people wonder why it took me so long to learn to trust men again. :wink:

Most of 'em, it’s been a realization that we weren’t compatible, for one reason or another. The one that wasn’t was a sort of generally dysfunctional relationship - we really weren’t compatible but neither one was really willing to admit it to themselves - me because she was the first relationship I’d had in several years, she because I was the first guy she’d dated who wasn’t a burnout, emotionally abusive, or otherwise damaged. Things finally came to a rather unpleasant and best forgotten end that nevertheless took about a month to fully play out.

He beheaded my cat. I decided not to stick around and find out what was next.

:eek:

Found a note she had written to her man on the side…

Lawyers were called and divorce was filed. A great time was had by all.

tisiphone, I second Incubus’ :eek: Thankfully you got out of that one.

Can you tell us the story?

My last one, who is the only I will mention due to her being the only one in many years, was ended due to two reasons:

  1. We lived 50 miles apart and that doesn’t work for me. I work full time and she was in college full time (including night classes), so we really only saw each other on weekends. It felt like every time we actually got to see each other, we really had to make it count. It got kind of frustrating. And with her in college and me in the working world, it really felt like we lived in two different worlds. I felt like I was dating a teenager sometimes and that bothered me.

  2. This will sound bad, but she was (and probably still is) suffering from depression. Basically, I’ve suffered from it for years and years and literally started dating her 3 weeks after I decided to get help. It was just too much for me to handle at the time - spending so much time with someone who is depressed while I myself am trying to crawl out of the hole myself. In the end, I felt it was best for my mental state to distance myself from her.

That’s pretty much it.

I was just thinking of my exes last night, after I found a photo album full of photos of me and one ex.

My reasons.

  1. This guy was my first love. We dated for three and a half years. I didn’t chuck him, he chucked me. Why? Because he had been cheating on me. I didn’t know about it, and it had been going on for a long, long time (about three to four months). During the break up, when I called him a lying sack of shit, he turned towards me and said, “hey baby, at least I’m honest.” Heh. You’re outta here boy!

  2. Well, with my most recent ex I broke up with him. We only dated for about a year, and we had a few problems. We argued a bit, and he was emotionally immature about some things. I had no ill feelings towards the guy though. He’s a sweetheart and a great guy, just not the guy for me. We still talk sometimes, and he will come over for a coffee or something. I briefly (and I mean very briefly) dated one of his friends. The ex was very cool with that. We’re better as friends.

Those are the only two exes worth mentioning. The rest of them were silly little high school flings.

I felt walking into a restaurant with our children and seeing him feel up his girlfriend was excessive. As was his temper tantrum when I changed the locks.

Of course I can’t ever be sure, but I swear happy camper is her. The date on the post is just right, the plans that will never be™ match, the reasons for the breakup are pretty much what I thought as well.

http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=178490&highlight=six+flags

The long and short of it is that I could tell she just wasn’t interested in me at all. A shame, I really liked her.

We’re still not friends, by the way. Went to her housewarming party at her new place a week ago and realized that I’m still angry as hell at her, four months later.

Issues of my own? Yup, got 'em…
-Ben