TWD is a good show, very tense, but lacking in any humour. I noticed an accidental joke while reading the comic, and it then occurred to me that neither the show nor the comic ever have a wisecrack or a funny comment.
I know that in a zombie apocalypse I’d be cracking jokes. They virtually never do. Would that totally ruin the show?
That would improve the show immensely. Give the characters a little more depth, the actors a little more to do. When you’re under pressure, humor helps vent it. I wouldn’t make it a non-stop giggle-fest, but some ribbing and joking in-between battles would be natural.
Because it would make the characters actually have to do something besides fuck up, emote and do product placement shots. But yes, I agree, a dash of real humor would greatly improve the show, which is so serious and unrelentingly grim as to be fairly called “leaden.”
While I don’t think the acting on The Walking Dead is as bad as some have opined, good comedy is much harder to write and/or perform than decent drama (even if it’s just for a line or two). It also might be too much of a temptation for the writers to use the laugh to relax the audience just prior to a big scare. I hate when that’s done in a movie – and a television episode doesn’t have any time to waste. I do think situational “inside jokes” between the characters (along with the audience) could be effective.
I love the show, but I do think they need a character like Sawyer from Lost, always ready to give some nickname or make some sarcastic remark about the situation. It really wouldn’t take much to make Darryl into that, methinks.
Between, as in the weeks and months in-between their unnecessary, flailing, poorly prepared-for battles. If no one is friendly enough to have a laugh in all that time, I would question whether I’d accidentally sealed myself IN with the zombies by mistake.
They should not want season after season of constant pressure. They need variety, something to make those moments of fear and horror stand out in contrast. I don’t claim to be a great storyteller, but I would think this is something fairly basic to the craft. Still, this does not preclude their not wanting to ease the pressure.
That may be the point. I know I’ve encountered the theory (maybe here on the SDMB, maybe even in the show itself somewhere) that the “walking dead” the title refers to are actually the human characters.
I get a lot of humor value out of how the writers try and out-gore each episode. I mean, come on guys. Some of the zombie killing scenes are just so over the top that I have to laugh. I know that the characters aren’t participating in the humor value the way we, as the audience, do, but it’s enough for me. I’ve never felt a lack of character-to-character humor was missing in the show. I pretty much like it the way it is.
There’s been some kidding around between Daryl and Carol. One scene I remember was when they were up on the perimeter of the prison and Carol asked Daryl if he wanted to fool around. He sort of laughed it off and said “come on, I"ll go down first” and she said “even better”.
Maybe not laugh out loud humor but I think it’s in there, especially in the slower episodes when they aren’t fighting for their lives.