Would "[race] only" as part of a personal ad turn you off?

Well, if I was 5’10 myself, I probably would.

Anything is possible, but I’m not going to go out with a bunch of white guy strangers just to see. I hate dating and the odds of there being a spark are too small that way. If I happened to know a white guy who I was attracted to, then great. If I happened to know a woman I was attracted to, then double great (might have better luck with them!), but I’m still not going to put on a dating site that I’m interested in meeting women too.

I do *really *hate dating though. I just want to fast forward to when you’re comfortable with the person.

I’m one of the people who ticked the “actually see it as positive” option. In my experience, looks (including racial characteristics) play a big role in sexual chemistry, and the last is a crucial factor in the durability of the human mating experience. If someone, for some reason, is attracted by a particular skin color/ nose shape/hair color and texture/whatever (i.e. all features that go to make up the various “racial” distinctions), I want to know about it beforehand. Whether I actually date him or not depends a lot on the other factors that go to define compatibility (yet another factor which make a man into a mate) – i.e. temperament, prior expectations, previous relationships (and baggage from thereof)… and whether he loves cats :-).

It would be a total deal-breaker to me.

The idea that this about attraction is absolute bullshit, as the broad category of “race” tells you shit all about a person’s appearance.

Are you telling me that there are people who are objectively attracted to people with coloring like Jessica Alba, but inexplicably repulsed by people with coloring like Beyonce? That there are people who only like Asian ladies who would be totally hot for a medium-skinned, double-lidded, somewhat Latin-looking Filipina, but unable to keep get it up for a medium skinned, double-lidded, somewhat Latin-looking white woman?

An “Asian” can vary in appearance from a blond-haired Uigher to a black-skinned indigenous Pacific Islander. “Black” people, especially in the US, vary from dark skinned to utterly and completely indistinguishable from a white person. “White” people cover ground from Norway to North Africa, and can be as light or swarthy as anyone else. And “Latino” basically tells you nothing about a person- they could be a straight up white dude from Argentina or a black dude from the DR. And while most people don’t fit into these extremes, in reality a good chunk of people from every “race” are a shade of brown and you’d never know what particular category they fall into by just looking at them.

So if it were actually about looks and the weirdness of attraction, they’d say something about the looks. People would state the colorings and builds they are attracted to.

But it’s not about looks or attraction, it’s about the whole set of baggage that comes with race. And if your dating is characterized by that baggage- be it focusing on another race or restricting yourself to your own- that’s pretty much automatically working with a lot of stereotypes. You are assuming an Asian lady is going to be like this, or a black dude like that, or an Indian girl like X, Y and Z. And of course, with the range of human beings in this world, that’s unlikely to be true and not particularly respectful to your perspective dating partners.

The reality is that within race, you can have a lot of mismatches. I’m a white girl who has a LOT more in common with someone who was raised in a low-income Latino neighborhood than with an upper-middle class white East-Coaster. A Korean adoptee from Missouri is going to have next to nothing in common with a first-generation immigrant Vietnamese person in San Francisco. Race is a pretty poor filter for finding people with a similar background and values.

And yeah, if you don’t have the balls to stand up to your racist parents (or you just automatically assume a mixed-race relationship is going to have all kinds of extra challenges, before you even know the person), even if that works in my favor, I’m not interested.

What? Who doesn’t? I don’t think anyone is attracted to ALL people of X race. It’s just one factor.

Exactly. So if your goal is to filter out people you are categorically not sexually attracted to, race isn’t a particularly good filter.

What it is good for is filtering because you don’t like the idea of dating someone of another race, regardless of what they look like or what their background and personality is. And I don’t think that kind of judgement falls under the innocuous “Eh, you like what you like” criteria that many in this thread are advocating. I think it’s at best small-minded.

Yeah, I mean, come on. I tend to find dark hair, skin and eyes most attractive, but I’d never write “No white guys” in my profile. First, some white guys do have dark coloring, and second, there are some who don’t who I find cute anyway. People who use the “physical preference” excuse are full of it.

Not me, it really is a physical preference. The root of that physical preference may be something else, just like any other physical preference…but that’s not conscious or a matter of choice, so I don’t know what else I could call it.

There is no physical preference that correlates neatly to race. None.

Even if you are absolutely exclusively attracted deep black skin and nothing else, you’ve got options across a chunk of of the world, from South India, across the Pacific Islands, into Australia. In the meantime, half of African-American guys aren’t going to fit your criteria at all.

I didn’t say black skin. I’m not into straight hair either.
If someone isn’t a black guy but looks kind of like a black guy, I might be attracted to him. If someone is a black guy but doesn’t look like one, then I won’t. I don’t see how that’s not a physical preference.

(Actually, I can have a bit of a crush on a man of any race. Dr. House, Daniel Dae Kim, Mario Lopez…but I couldn’t see being intimate with any of them. I just can’t. Maybe I’d be okay with it if I got used to it, but so far that’s never worked so I gave up. Presumably most men have better things to do than to date someone who hopes maybe at some point she might be able to want to bang him anyway.)

Well over half wouldn’t, of course.

We are saying the same thing here. Physical attraction preferences exist, of course.

But saying you are only interested in people from racial group X is a poor way to filter for these physical preferences. Saying you are only interested in race group X because that’s your only physical preference is a cop out. If a person is filtering by race, they should at least own up to the fact that that are filtering by race, and stop using “nuh uh, I’m just filtering for people I find attractive” as an excuse.

Maybe. I know you’ve said that dating is a numbers game. Just put yourself out there and see who you click with. And that makes perfect sense. But for me it doesn’t, because like I said, I hate dating. I can’t just give everyone (not literally EVERYONE, but you know what I mean) a chance! I only have so many chances to give until I can’t make myself do it anymore.

Baloney.

At least for me.

I’ve been cruising the internet websites for the past 2 months being newly single. I don’t even have the race “filter” on, so I get to see everybody other than gay males. So about every tenth to twentieth female is decidely “not white”.

Guess what? They as a very large general rule do NOT have the body type I am interested in even they had been dipped in Mr Jackson Oxyclean 5000.

Well, yeah, don’t date anyone you aren’t attracted to. Life is too short for that.

But if a person won’t even look at someone else’s picture, only and entirely because of their race, that’s something else. These are the cases this thread is about- people who say “don’t even bother to contact me unless you are race X.”

I don’t even think it’s weird to do searches by race. There are a lot of people to filter through, after all, and if you really like a light mocha, there is no need to sort through a thousand gingers and Scandinavians in hopes of stumbling across an exceptionally swarthy Italian.

But if you are stating straight up that in your profile that you are exclusively interested in a certain race and that nobody else should contact you, I am going to think there is a lot more going on there than looking for your type.

Would you like to tell us what your preferred body type is, so that we can post a full rainbow of attractive ladies who embody it? Unless you are exclusively into steatopygia or super turned on by pygmies, I’m really struggling to think of a body type that can’t be found in another race.

They don’t just want to attract whites, they want to attract like-minded whites. Deal breaker for me.

Exactly my thoughts.

:stuck_out_tongue:

Don’t laugh at me, Jamaroo.

wouldn’t it make more sense for you to just wear your “no fatties” hat in your main profile picture?

Actually, thats pretty much it.

If you are in my neck of the woods and can find a middle aged black woman that is :

Thin.

Educated or interested in the sciences.

Interested in one of the following:

Rock Climbing or cave diving.

Camping.

Scuba Diving.

Kayaking.

Astronomy.

Let me know and I’ll chat her up.

But good luck, my vast experience with these sorta hobbies is that I’d almost not know black people even existed bassed upon observation.

No, you don’t have to give everyone a chance. You should give a chance to guys you like, and if those happen to be primarily black because they are most frequently what you’re attracted to, that’s fine. But if you’ll ONLY date black men and “can’t” screw anyone who isn’t, even if they’re good looking in your eyes, the “Oh, but that’s what I find attractive” argument starts to lose air.

LOL. O’RLY? And all the middle aged white women you come across are fit, educated scientists who kayak and go rock climbing? Puhlease. I live in Illinois. Every white woman here isn’t into jack shit except fried everything and Jesus.