You are married. It’s a good marriage and you love and trust your spouse.
Then one day the cops come to your door with a warrant for your spouse’s arrest. The crime is a terrible one, and there’s a lot of evidence. Your spouse says it’s all some kind of mistake and the crime would be completely out of character, but there is no easy explanation for the evidence. The evidence is enough that if the accused were a stranger and you were on the jury, you’d have no problem thinking the person guilty. But it’s your beloved spouse, whom you trust.
You can either believe the evidence, or put your trust in your spouse.
Which one is more likely for you?