Would you have sex with a person who has herpes?

I was reading the thread on herpes in the pit and it got me curious. If a potential sexual partner reveals to you that s/he has herpes, how likely are you to agree to sex with him/her?

I know it’s a terribly personal question. In order to avoid some “It depends” answers, I’ll offer a few different scenarios (assuming you’re single):

  1. You meet a person that you find sexually attractive. You’re not looking for a relationship, but you aren’t averse to casual sex and this person seems to be up for it. After establishing that this interlude will be only casual, the person offers that they have Herpes Simplex Type 1. They’ve gotten cold sores on their mouth before, but they’ve never had any sort of outbreak on their genitals. They don’t have any outbreak at the present time. Would you likely say yes or no?

  2. Same situation as above, but this person has Type 2. They’ve had outbreaks on their genitals before, but they are taking Valtrex. They don’t have an outbreak presently. Would you likely say yes or no?

As an alternative, imagine either situation, only this time you are “falling for” the person. You haven’t had sex yet, but you are basically smitten and would love to see the relationship continue. Would you likely say yes or no to a sexual relationship with them?

Good question…

I would say it all depends…

HPV1, oral…did they warn me before we got to kissing? If not, then all bets are off and I would be peeved but not too upset…I have never had cold sores [other than chanker sores from my braces getting bashed against the inside of my mouth in sports in school, or biting myself.] I have most likely kissed people with HPV1, because most people ignore cold sores and don’t realize they are herpes…If someone offered me oral sex and mentioned that they had HPV1 but no active cold sores anywhere, I would have to pass on the oral, but go for regular sex with precautions[and I always used rubbers when I was not monogamous]

HPV2 genital - I would be raving pissed if they told me after. If they told me before, I would think about it, and again, I would not say no outright but have to think about it for a bit. As I said before, I used condoms pre-monogamy, but I would rather not have the gift that keeps on giving.

As to getting into a longer relationship - it all depends on how smitten I am for the person. I would probably say that I would have to have a much longer nonsexual part of the courtship before deciding on #2. I would really have to have something serious for the guy if I am going to get into a longer relationship, with a greater chance of contact when they are active.

[or girl, since under the right circumstances I could go either way.]

…No, in most cases, I’m afraid.

I’ve nver had cold sores…canker sores on the inside of my mouth, but never a single cold sore.

The only case I could see if I was really falling in love and i had some idea he was, too.

Ew, no.

To me it’s not worth the risk, however small, for a casual encounter. And if I was informed after anything happened, I’d be seriously PO’d.

Keeping in mind that I’m not much into casual sex anyway.

If a serious long-term relationship were a possibility, I’d think about it–but I’d definitely wait longer to start having sex than I would with an STD-free partner.

HSV-II: You couldn’t pay me to do it.

Considering there are a lot of people out there who are NOT honest about their sexual past and health, I think it says a lot about a person who is honest and respectful and brave enough to tell someone they’re interested in that they have herpes, or any other STD.

To me, this says a lot about that person and it would raise my level of respect for them, and I would definitely consider starting or continuing a relationship with someone like that.

I think I read a statistic that says 1 in 5 adults in the US has this disease, so it’s a lot more common and prevalent than people think. Personally, I wouldn’t risk missing out on my soulmate for such a superficial reason.

You know, it is 1 in 5. And since I’m obviously that one in this group, I’ll go ahead and say that a potential partner having herpes would not deter me from the relationship.

Senario #1–Absolutely! Cold sores on the lips are nothing. I’d be surprised that they bothered to mention it. I’m sure I wouldn’t. (Would this be wrong? I don’t think I’ve ever had one, so it hasn’t come up.)

Senario #2–I’d probably have to think about it. If I was near a computer, I might stop and look up the odds of getting an infection while she’s on Valtrex and not breaking out if we use a condom. I suspect it’s pretty low. And since I (given my understanding of the senario as written) would have been willing to have sex before such a revelation, and since I think it only makes sense to assume that people aren’t telling you everything, and could be infected, why not? (I know this isn’t very good logic–you could make exactly the same case for sex with an HIV+ partner–but herpes really isn’t all that serious, and it’s about as logical as I’m likely to be when I’m horny!)

FTR, I’m not much into casual sex, but I thought I’d try to answer the question as asked.

No.

I appreciate the honesty. I’ve gotten cold sores occasionally since I was in third grade or so…I’ve no idea how I contracted it. I just wondered how people would react to this confession.

Um, no.

I’d like to say something.

One time long ago, I got some kind of infection that I thought was herpes. It was after I’d begun a relationship with a wonderful woman who (now I know) truly loved me, and would have probably told me if she’d had herpes. So I went to a clinic and got a test, and they said something like “it’s inconclusive.” I couldn’t belive that they couldn’t give me a definitive answer. Anyway, they gave me Alcyclevoir (spelling, please?) and it seemed to work, and for quite a few years after that I kept a supply of that drug, and took lysine regulary.

That was fine, but I did something horrible as well. I accused this wonderful person–in one moment of desperation-- of infecting me with herpes. I’d assumed that the infection I had was indeed herpes. Now, I know it wasn’t. I regret so much now that I hurt her so. She was perhaps the sweetest, kindest, most intelligent woman I’d ever known. But I was so freaked out because of all the HIV/public health warnings out there that I was paranoid. My ignorance (and lack of proper information) led me to hurt this wonderful person. What I had was probably some other kind of infection that resembled herpes. It has never returned. My anger was that she’d given me an infection that I would keep forever. In fact, she’d given me nothing.

Unforntunately, I didn’t have time to learn that lesson when shortly after that I went to live in the Caribbean and soon after my arrival I somehow ended up with a woman there with no condemn. I said, “I have no condem.” She said, “It’s okay.” I’d assumed that meant “I assure you there’s no need for one.” Well, a week later I thought I’d gotten an infection; it was only a reaction to the climate change. But I freaked out again, and told her that I blamed her, much to show my ingnorance (evidence would have shown much later). Today I regret so much my words, buecause even though she was willing to have unprotected sex, it was ultimately my responsibility no matter what she said. Even if she’d actually infected me, it would have been my fault. I was just so out of my head.

I will never have unprotected sex again. I’ve known women who protest against it, but I hope it’s not for my sake–it’s all the same to me; I feel no difference.

I guess my point is that communication is one of the important tools–no, the MOST important tool–in preventing STDs. Instead of simply blaming these women, I should have just asked them, if they’d experienced symptoms like herpes.

If anybody out there has genital herpes, please look into lysine and Acyclovar. Talk to your doctor. If you have oral herpes, do the same; just be aware of when you have them, they’re very common. In fact, you can keep them to you mouth, it’s just cold sores. Also, chicken pox is just another form of herpes, and some poor people never get rid of chicken pox–it comes back as shingles–basically, it’s a virus that inhabits nerve fibers, inflating and irritating them.

But if the person who has the herpes infection understands all of it’s parameters, yes, there can be a healthy sexual relation, when precaution is taken. Just realize you need to communicate, and if you are infected, you should know all of the precautions for both parties.

I was fortunate–I’d thought twice I’d been infected with herpes, and I was wrong. But I didn’t handle the situation correctly. I should have said: “honey, I’m not sure, but maybe I have an STD. Could it be possible that I got it from you?–I don’t think so, but I have to check to be sure…”

  1. I’ve had cold sores before (about 3 in my life) so it wouldn’t be a problem.

  2. Nope. Wouldn’t want to take the risk.

As a slight aside, Holden cars are very popular in this part of the world - think Ford vs. Chevrolet - and their tuning arm badges cars as HSV’s: it’s truly funny to see all the petrolheads with personalised plates advertising the Herpes Simplex Virus: HSV1, HOTHSV et al.

As to the OP, no way in hell: worst I’ve had is a dose of thrush {Oh, and an AIDS scare, but that’s a long story in itself} from an ex with somewhat dubious sexual mores, and that was quite enough on the STD front, thank you.

  1. Yes, I’ve been in this situation, and we have slept together. We’re not intimate while she has a cold sore, and I’ve never developed them. We’ve been intimate roughly four times in the past year.

  2. That one’s harder for me. Purely recreational I’m-never-going-to-see-you-again sex? Probably not worth it too me. Extended but casual relationship wherein I can see us being good friends with benefits or having a strong emotional connection? Then maybe, but only with a condom and never during an outbreak or time of stress.

And as others have said, being honest about it gets you mucho sexy points in my book!

I forgot to add in my earlier post that HSV also stands for Holden Special Vehicles.

I have a question - is it only me who seems to assume that herpes is exclusively transmitted sexually?

It’s not.

I would certainly appreciate knowing my partner’s medical problems beforehand, if any, and I would get royally POd if they claimed to have “a perfectly clean bill of health” knowing it was a lie, but I wouldn’t stop having sex with someone because they had some virus or other. Yes, that includes HIV, hepatitis, herpes and I’m sure there’s other nasties out there starting with H.

Excuse me, “only me who does not seem to assume” - some day I’ll learn to type as fast as I think.

I had a big long indignant post detailing how I would NEVER EVER fornicate with ANY infected woman, condom or not, prepared and previewed many times, ready to fire off in that pit thread…

Then I remembered this.