Bumping from the Peanut Gallery to wallow in self-pity about how slow the off-site game is going. I feel like the worst mod ever… 
Don’t worry, Dot, you are doing fine over there. PM me if you ever want to commiserate on the woes of modding mafia games.
Sorry about the lack of color Hockey. but the scum have selected a Night kill and I still have no time to really write something up for you. If you would like to submit some ideas to me, I will be happy to post a death scene of your choosing.
Brewha - associate
is dead.
Here is the current player list.
faithfool
Hawkeyeop
Pleonast
Rysto
sachertorte
It’s lynch or lose for the town. And will take 3 votes to secure a lynch, 4 votes to end the Day instantly.
You have 7 Days from this post.
Down to the wire. Continuing the vote counts…
Day 1
Mhaye (10): OAOW, zuma, brewha, freudian slit, Diomedes, Hawkeyeop, Kat, Cookies, Pleonast, Hockey Monkey
zuma (4): sachertorte, Mhaye, Hal Briston, HazelNutCoffee
Diomedes (1): storyteller
Hal(1): faithfool
brewha (1): shadowfacts
No Vote (1): Rysto
Day 2
Day 2 votes in correct order… I’m not sure there’s much to be gleaned from day 2, for when Cookies revealed the killer’s trait, a OAOW lynch was inevitable.
However, I thought I’d list the pre-revelation vote count:
brewha (2): shadowfacts, Hockey Monkey
faithfool (2): Diomedes, Pleonast
Diomedes (1): faithfool
Here’s the end of day vote count:
OAOW (10): Hal, Hawkeyeop, sachertorte, shadowfacts, freudian slit, Kat, Hockey Monkey, faithfool, Diomedes, OAOW
Diomedes (1): Rysto
No Vote (5): brewha, Hazel, zuma, story, Pleonast
The only things to note were that Pleonast placed the 5th vote on OAOW, then unvoted because he said he didn’t want to end the day early. Diomedes placed the 9th vote (I think we’ve discussed that one), and OAOW self-hammered the 10th vote to end the day instantly. Rysto said he placed his vote on Diomedes because of Diomedes’s 9th vote.
Day 3
Day 3 vote counts: (This was the no-lynch day - Brewha was 1 vote short of majority)
brewha (7): sach, Hockey Monkey, Hawkeyeop, fruedian slit, Rysto, Hal, Pleonast
faithfool (2): Diomedes, zuma
Diomedes (2): faithfool, kat
Hawkeyeop(1): Brewha
No Vote (2): HazelNutCoffee, storyteller
Day 4
Here was the state of voting before story laid out his case against Fruedian Slit if anyone is interested:
brewha (6): Hockey Monkey, freudian slit, hawkeyeop, sachertorte, Diomedes, faithfool
faithfool (2): Pleonast, zuma
Diomedes (1): HazelNutCoffee
Not yet voted: Rysto, storyteller, brewha, Hal
And the final vote count in the correct order:
Freudian Slit (8): storyteller, brewha, zuma, Diomedes, sachertorte, rysto, hawkeyeop, faithfool
brewha (3): Hockey Monkey, Freudian Slit, Pleonast
Diomedes (2): HazelNutCoffee, Hal
Day 5
Hazel: Pleo, Diomedes, zuma, Hockey Monkey
brewha: faithfool
Diomedes: Hazel, Rysto, Hawkeye, Hal, sach, brewha
Day 6
HazelNutCoffee: Pleo, zuma, brewha, Rysto, Hockey
brewha: hawk, sach, faithfool
No Vote: Hazel
Day 7
Hockey Monkey: Pleo, Rysto, brewha, Hawk, sach (not certain about order)
Sachertorte: Hockey Monkey
No Vote: faith
Not sure how much these help, but I want to look over them, so might as well post 'em.
faith
1st Hal (Single)
8th OaOW (Lynch, Hammer)
1st Diomedes
8th Freud (Lynch, Post-Hammer)
1st brewha (Single)
3rd brewha
(No Vote)
Hawkeye
6th MHaye (Lynch)
2nd OaOW (Lynch)
3rd brewha
7th Freud (Lynch, Hammer)
3rd Diomedes (Lynch)
1st brewha
Hockey (Lynch)
Pleonast
9th MHaye (Lynch)
(No Vote)
7th brewha
3rd brewha
1st Hazel
1st Hazel (Lynch)
Hockey (Lynch)
Rysto
(No Vote)
1st Diomedes (Single)
5th brewha
6th Freud (Lynch)
2nd Diomedes (Lynch)
4th Hazel (Lynch)
Hockey (Lynch)
sach
1st zuma
3rd OaOW (Lynch)
1st brewha
5th Freud (Lynch)
5th Diomedes (Lynch)
3rd brewha
Hockey (Lynch)
I may well miss the end of this Day, guys. I will be skiing next week. It’s not booked yet, so I don’t know when I’ll be gone. When I know my schedule I’ll let you know.
It’s lynch or lose, which means that all three townies must vote together. And if two townies mis-vote, the two scum can insta-hammer and win the game. Be very wary before placing a vote.
I’m going to take a real long look at faithfool. Her voting record is awful, and with Hockey turning up town, I don’t think that a single scum was on that initial bandwagon. That makes me very suspicious.
I also have to say that I’m very surprised to see that Pleonast is still alive. Was it just me, or did everybody seem to trust that he was town? Why didn’t the scum eliminate him? It’s in their interest to kill off the most trusted townies.
Hey, everyone’s final vote was on scum twice. How symmetrical. This isn’t going to be easy, even if we can figure out who the last 2 scum are. We need all three town members to agree, and be able to post, or we lose. My current order of suspicion is.
Sach
Rysto
Pleo
Faith
I will not vote until Brewha’s death post comes in though.
Sorry Brewha. I was right on Hockey atleast…
I was more surprised that I survived the Night after we got Hazel. If they didn’t kill me after that, well, I didn’t do so hot going after Hockey. I need to see if my vote analysis comes up with a clear answer, but I’m not sure it’s enough to base a vote on. I’m more tempted to look at the Dossiers now. They may be killing us off based on our traits somehow.
I’ll step through the different Days and comment on each player. With two scum left among the four of you, I gots 50-50 odds.
Day 1: You each voted differently. The three of you who voted for a player, voted for a Townie. Rysto didn’t vote for anyone. I think that makes Rysto the most suspicious of that Day.
Day 2: You all voted for OAOW, while Rysto voted for Diomedes. Another bad mark for him.
Day 3: You all voted for brewha, while faithfool voted Diomedes. I’m tempted to think this is a good mark for faith. I think the brewha vote was dominated by scum.
Day 4: You all voted for Freud, and were in fact the last four voters! Hawkeye was the hammer, and faith jumped on after. I’ll count that as a bad mark for faith.
Day 5: You all voted for Diomedes, except for faithfool who went for brewha. Not sure what to make of this.
Day 6: You all voted for brewha, except for Rysto who followed me on Hazel. And everyone else who voted for Hazel is now a dead Townie. Is Rysto a Scum who put a vote on Hazel to break up the block on brewha? Or was he a Townie voting with the rest of us? Based on how the story vote went (where I know two Scum jumped on the wagon), I’m inclined to say Scum.
Day 7: You all voted for Hockey, except for faith who didn’t vote. Whatever faith’s alignment, I believe his real life problems prevented a vote. No tell.
Looking over the Days, I now see exactly why I am still alive–every Day, you four voted in a block, with one of you not in the block. That fact totally screws my previous method of analysis. :smack:
But based on a Day by Day look, I think I rank you guys from most scummy to not:
Rysto
sach == Hawkeye
faith
My vote would be on Rysto at this point, but I won’t place it yet. I’m equally suspicious of sach and Hawkeye. I’m not seeing faith as Scum right now. And brewha’s clue may change my mind.
Now come on, I explained that. I was right at the end of my exam period, I lost a day traveling and I spent the next day Christmas shopping. I got caught up with an hour to go with MHaye already at the required majority. I let you all know well ahead of Day 1 that I would not be able to participate much.
I wasn’t going to insta-hammer OAOW. That bandwagon was giving me awful flashbacks to the Autolycus lynch in M2. Unanimous rushes to judgment scare the crap out of me.
Me, too. That’s why I unvoted OAOW. But why did you vote for Dio?
Anything to say about your vote for Hazel on Day 6? Do you want to present an argument for lynching someone else?
I was expressing my displeasure that he put OAOW on the clock.
What? Now I need to justify voting for scum, too? Would you prefer that I had voted for brewha? I think that my reasons for voting Hazel are pretty clear.
Of course, Hockey Monkey’s lynch has shown that my case was crap, but my reasons for voting for Hazel are a matter of record.
I want to, but I want to pass Networks more. I’m afraid that this game will have to wait.
Anyone?
I’m generally waiting for Brewha at this point. I think Sach is scum. I don’t think Faith is scum. I’m torn between you and Rysto, but leaning towards Rysto.
Just cause I like to argue with you Hawkeye - you’re waiting on Mtgman, not me. 
He has my lame death scene and is presumably checking it over.
It’s been fun and I’m actually relieved to have been killed by scum. I do not envy the remaining town and the decisions that you have to make.
Good luck town!
Rot in Hell Scum!
I had a friend in college whose beliefs were, pretty much across the board, the polar opposite of mine. We both tended to be fairly outspoken, so throughout the years, we argued about any topic that would come up. We had one memorable exchange towards the end recapping a previous discuss on amending the constitution of an extracurricular organization.
Him “Joel (my actual name) and I disagreed on everything.”
Me “That’s not true.”
Took me a few seconds to realize why everyone was laughing.
And now, a musical interlude.
These eyes
arrrreeee glazin
these eyes have seen a lotta death
but they’re never gonna see another death
like they have with brew
ha ha ha ha
These eyes
AAAARRRRRRRREEEE glazin…
Enjoy,
Steven
This is a new killer. Unless this clue matches one of faithfool’s traits, this confirms her as a Townie.
Which blows yet another of my theories completely out of the water.
What’s the trait the clue is referring to? I’m at a loss.
Here are the traits of the people still alive.
Pleonast 1 I am scared of moths.
Pleonast (public) 1 I had my last cat, Clawdia, professionally preserved and she sits in my bedroom.
Pleonast 1 I have handled and fed a lot of snakes, alligators and crocodiles.
Pleonast 1 I was once bitten by a wild animal while visiting Dollywood.
Pleonast 1 I’ve wandered and built on an old, live Soviet bomb dump.
Pleonast 1 My mother was a former NFL cheerleader.
faithfool (public) 5 I believe the Honda Element is a good-looking car.
faithfool 5 I enjoy practicing the cello.
faithfool 5 I have been shot in the head with a muzzleloading .45 caliber pistol and in leg with a bow and arrow.
faithfool 5 I have performed an exorcism.
faithfool 5 I provided a line in a song that became a top 20 hit for the band Traffic.
faithfool 5 I voted for a boy for prom queen.
Rysto 6 Farts are really funny. People only pretend to not think they are.
Rysto 6 I believe that the world would be a much better place if about 25% of the population were taken out back and shot.
Rysto 6 I believe the cruelty makes foie gras all the more tasty.
Rysto 6 I started a forest fire by playing with matches.
Rysto 6 I was in a biker movie.
sachertorte 13 I got an autograph from Billy Crystal on top of the World Trade Center.
sachertorte 13 I have gone to Disney World 3 times and Disneyland at least 5 times
sachertorte 13 I watched as over 30 people jumped out of an airborne aircraft.
sachertorte 13 I’ve been a model appearing on the cover of a nationwide catalog.
sachertorte (public) 13 I’ve climbed to the top chamber of Cheops.
sachertorte 13 I’ve eaten grilled cow udder more than once.
Hawkeyeop (public) 17 I have performed an exorcism.
Hawkeyeop 17 I speak Swahili.
Hawkeyeop 17 I was in a biker movie.
Hawkeyeop 17 I’ve been a model appearing on the cover of a nationwide catalog
Hawkeyeop 17 I’ve been on the cover of a Chicago area phone book.
Hawkeyeop 17 I’ve bowled two perfect 300 games