light strand, since we’ve corresponded on the stem cell and diabetes issue, let me run this one by you. (I wrote up a medium sized post on this yesterday, but the hampsters appear to have eaten it.) I’ve shared this anecdote in the past, so bear with me if you’ve all heard it before. When my oldest son was three, he was diagnosed with diabetes. I was fairly devastated at learning this news, knowing only the bare minimum about diabetes, and having read about the risks for serious secondary conditions and death.
When I was talking about this with a coworker, she said, “Oh, I know how you feel. My cat has diabetes.” How does that strike you? To me, it was insane to compare the two. However, I realized that she was simply trying, in a very self-centered way, to show some kind of empathy. That’s how, in general, I regard any comment to the effect of “My pets are my children.” I try to recognize that some folks cannot appreciate the marked difference between the two, generally because they have not experienced both.
Our understanding of emotions is dependent on our experience of them, and thus our scales for gauging them are not standardized. While I understand that cognitively, it does feel as if a person is minimizing my emotional experience by trying to equate their feelings for an animal with my feelings for my children. No, it’s not fair, but it is a human reaction. As an analogy, I’ve seen exchanges in group therapy that seem similar to me. For example, if you tell a rape victim that you understand the fear she felt because you were once trapped in an elevator for 15 minutes, heck it may be true. Perhaps your fear, vulnerability and desperation was actually equivalent to hers. Who can know? But in reality, the equivalence is unlikely to ring true for her, and may evoke some ire on her part.
I’m just trying to explain why I think such comparisons draw a range of responses from bemusement to hostility. For my part, it is mostly bemusement - kind of like you might feel if you’ve ridden a hair-raising roller coaster, and someone says “I know how you feel. I’ve ridden the merry-go-round!”
I’m not sure why the comparison is necessary at all. Why does a pet owner need to make the link? Without trying to compare children and pets, I’m sure that most people could grasp that pets are important and differently valued by their owners than a houseplant. (Hey, what about those people who say “my houseplants are my pets”? Fuckers!)
And just to finish off the other component I had in my original post:
Yeah, and no neighborhood child ever jumped up and bit my penis when I was eight years old. And no neighbor has yet shit on my lawn.