Hrm, what draft to use? I’ll use the first draft I did this season, which I think turned out the best. Draft was August 14 (post-Vick, pre-Pennington, pre-Stewart ;)), a Yahoo! public league, 10 teams, 15 players per team, fairly standard rosters and scoring.
Your First Pick : I had the first pick and I wasted no time in making my first and only homer pick of the draft: Ricky Williams.
Your best/worst pick: My best pick(s) might have been Driver and Green with the last pick in 5 and first in 6, after guys like O.Smith, Canidate, Conway, and J.Smith had already been drafted. Best pick overall was probably A.Green in late 3 (27th overall). I also really like W.Dunn in late 12 (119th overall). If he starts, Hambrick leading off the 13th was probably my best pick. Alternatively, picking up Q.Morgan off waivers after he went undrafted might have been my best pick.
Zeroue in the last round (141st overall) was also nice. We’ll see what he does.
My worst pick I would say was Buckhalter at 120th (last in 12th). But at the time Staley was still holding out and I overestimated Reid’s stones. Kevin Faulk finishing off the 10th was also a bad pick, I don’t know what had me so high on him. Pennington to close the 8th seemed like a great pick at the time – fortunately I traded him just days before he went down.
First player selected overall in the draft: Ricky, as mentioned above. The rest of the first round was McNabb, Tomlinson, Holmes, Portis, Faulk, Alexander, Harrison, Deuce, and Edge.
Primo player that was a steal for someone: Oops, answered this one above. I also got Favre in the 7th. Green, McNair, and Hasselbeck all going in the 10th are actually even better.
Worst pick by someone in your league: Where to start? (Although I could never top taking C.Martin at 5th overall. WOW.) Fred Taylor in early 2 (14th overall) with S.Davis, Henry, Barber, J.Lewis, A.Green, and George all still on the board is pretty atrocious, but you gotta blame Yahoo’s ranks for that one. Garcia in mid 3 (26th overall) is the same story… TB DEF at 42nd is bad, and Vanderjagt at 51 is too; but the first DEF and K taken always are. Jerramy Stevens at 71 stands out. Jimmy Smith at 44 is a huge reach.
What positions did you draft for your first 5?: RB RB WR WR WR (RB QB QB DEF RB WR RB RB TE RB, I like to be pretty straightforward, and no, I didn’t draft a kicker).
QB Favre, Pennington
RB R.Williams, W.Green
RB T.Barber, T.Hambrick, K.Faulk, A. Zeroue, C.Buckhalter
WR E.Moulds, D.Jackson
WR P.Price
WR D.Driver
TE C.Fauria
D Balt
K -
Not too bad. Through trading and free agent acquisitions I arrived at my opening day roster:
QB Favre, Mcnair
RB R.Williams, W.Green
RB M.Faulk, T.Hambrick, A.Zeroue
WR E.Moulds, Q.Morgan
WR D.Driver, D.Jackson
WR D.Boston
TE Fauria
DEF Balt
K Stover
Quite a bit better. I’d like to get Betts but can’t really spare the roster room, and I’d also like to improve at TE (Fauria’s a throwaway (actually I’m thinking of replacing him with Walls (actually I just did, but I’m sure I’ll be picking up someone else next week too))). But I’m certain I’ll reach the playoffs with this squad.